A 73-year-old passenger fell inside a Kerala State Road Transport Corporation bus and fractured his wrist, and the Ernakulam Consumer Commission has now directed KSRTC to pay Rs 45,000 to his wife, holding the transport provider liable for deficiency in service.

Ernakulam: A woman whose 73-year-old husband suffered a Colles fracture of the left wrist after falling inside a KSRTC bus, when the driver braked suddenly during a journey to Malakkappara, has been awarded Rs 45,000 by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Ernakulam, against the Corporation. [Chandrika Mohandas v. Managing Director, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation]
Allowing the complaint, the Commission, comprising President D.B. Binu, Member V. Ramachandran and Member Sreevidya T.N., awarded Rs 40,000 as compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.
Rs 45,000, payable within 45 days
The Commission directed KSRTC to pay:
- Rs 40,000 as compensation for physical pain, mental agony, financial loss and other hardships; and
- Rs 5,000 towards the costs of the proceedings.
Both amounts are to be paid within 45 days of receipt of the order. If KSRTC misses that deadline, interest at 9% per annum will run on both sums from the date of the order until realisation.
A seat given up, then a sudden brake
The complainant, Chandrika Mohandas, said she, her husband Mohandas and their family boarded a KSRTC bus from Edappally on October 7, 2023, for a pleasure trip to Malakkappara organised by a local residents’ association.
Her case was that the bus crew, soon after the journey began near Kalamassery, asked her elderly husband to give up his seat for passengers who had booked seats from Angamaly. Later, she alleged, the driver braked suddenly and Mohandas fell heavily onto his left hand.
Doctors at Sanjoe Hospital diagnosed a Colles fracture of the left wrist. The complainant alleged that the bus was driven negligently and that KSRTC failed to ensure passenger safety. She asked for reimbursement of medical expenses of Rs 52,343, along with compensation for physical pain, mental agony and hardship.
No version from KSRTC
Notice was served, but KSRTC did not file its version. The Commission proceeded ex parte against the Corporation and decided the complaint on what the complainant had placed on record: the bus ticket, hospital records, medical bills and treatment papers.
What the ticket and the bills established
The Commission held that the bus ticket, marked as Ext. A3, established the consumer relationship between the complainant and the transport provider. The discharge summary and treatment records confirmed a wrist fracture following a fall inside the bus, and the bills showed medical expenses of Rs 52,343.
A public transport operator, the Commission said, is expected to ensure adequate safety arrangements and to give necessary help to passengers when an accident occurs. Weighing the circumstances of the fall, the nature of the injury and the physical and financial hardship faced by the family, it found that the complainant had made out her entitlement to relief for deficiency in service.
Why the order matters
The order treats passenger safety as part of the service a public transport operator sells with every ticket. A ticket is enough to make the traveller a consumer, and an injury suffered inside the bus during the journey can ground a deficiency-in-service claim before a consumer forum, without the passenger having to file a civil suit for damages.
It also shows what not contesting can cost. With KSRTC filing no version, the complainant’s ticket, medical records and bills went unchallenged, and the Commission decided the case on that record. For elderly passengers in particular, the order underlines that crews are expected to look after their safety and help them if they are hurt on board.
Case Title: Chandrika Mohandas v. Managing Director, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation
Case No.: C.C. No. 50/2024
Forum: District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Ernakulam
Coram: D.B. Binu (President), V. Ramachandran (Member) and Sreevidya T.N. (Member)
Date of Order: [VERIFY]
Appearances: KSRTC set ex parte
