Bombay High Court Slams Public For Flouting Firecracker Restrictions, Reserves Order On Maharashtra-Wide Ban

4 min read

“Why every time the court is required to say?” the Bombay High Court asked on Thursday, criticising residents of Mumbai for flouting firecracker restrictions during Diwali as it reserved its order on whether to impose a complete ban on the sale and bursting of firecrackers across Maharashtra.

Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Dr Neela Gokhale of the Bombay High Court, who reserved orders on a Maharashtra-wide firecracker ban

Mumbai: Reserving its order on a plea for a complete ban on the sale and bursting of firecrackers throughout Maharashtra, the Bombay High Court on Thursday expressed serious concern over severe post-Diwali air and noise pollution in Mumbai and said the police and municipal machinery could not be faulted when people willingly break the rules [In re: Noise and Environmental Pollution].

The remarks were made orally on November 19, 2026, by a Division Bench of Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Dr Neela Gokhale, who were hearing the suo motu proceedings on festive noise and air pollution. The Court has not yet ruled on the plea for a total ban, and its observations at the hearing are not a final decision on the issues raised.

Livelihood against life

Referring to Supreme Court rulings, the Bench said the right to trade under Article 19(1)(g) is subservient to the right to life under Article 21. It told the retailers:

“You may have a right to do business, but not to harm the lives of the people.”

Hazardous practices, the judges added, do not enjoy protection under Article 25. The Bench likened stray rockets to an intrusion into a home, asking whether anyone would let somebody “enter the flat and burn firecrackers inside the house”, and observed that “everybody cannot afford to have these big air purifiers at home”.

Who said what in court

Amicus Curiae Anand Pai suggested a total halt on the sale of firecrackers until the authorities designate regulated community firework grounds.

Placing test data on record, Advocate Rohaan Cama, appearing for the petitioners, claimed that half of the sampled “green” crackers carried fake QR codes and contained banned barium.

A blanket ban was opposed by counsel for the Mumbai and Thane District Fireworks Dealers Welfare Association, who argued that licensed traders were being penalised for the conduct of illegal vendors.

After Diwali, in the Bench’s words

The Bench referred to news reports of more than 330 fire incidents caused by stray rockets striking high-rise buildings and to Air Quality Index readings above 400 after the festival. Existing restrictions, it noted, had not stopped widespread violations, with firecrackers being burst until 4 am across the city. The Bench remarked:

“People appear to have no consciousness for the societal cause. People are really insensitive. Why every time the court is required to say? Why don’t we improve our habits?”

Enforcement agencies had done what they could, the Court said, and the failure lay with the public:

“Police are totally helpless; they did their best. The municipal machinery also did their best. But ultimately it is totally beyond control.”

Justice Gokhale also flagged posts on social media urging others to burst firecrackers, observing that social media was “replete with instances where people are actually encouraging others to burn firecrackers for whatever reasons”.

Before reserving its order, the Court indicated that any directions it issues would apply across Maharashtra and not only to urban centres.

What the order could settle

Over the festive season the Bench has issued piecemeal directions on firecrackers, from extending the street-bursting ban to all festivals to asking the police for a standard operating procedure. Thursday’s hearing signals that the Court now sees those restrictions as insufficient on their own and is weighing a statewide regime instead.

The remarks also set out the constitutional frame the Court is likely to apply: commercial interests under Article 19(1)(g) and claims of religious practice under Article 25 give way where an activity endangers health and property protected under Article 21. Whether that leads to a total ban or regulated alternatives such as designated firework grounds will be known when the order is pronounced.

Case Title: In re: Noise and Environmental Pollution (Suo Motu Public Interest Litigation)
Bench: Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Dr Neela Gokhale, Bombay High Court
Date of Hearing: November 19, 2026 (order reserved)
Appearances: Amicus Curiae Anand Pai; Advocate Rohaan Cama for the petitioners; counsel for the Mumbai and Thane District Fireworks Dealers Welfare Association

Similar Posts