Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has reportedly moved two matters out of a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah: the private universities case that grew out of a student’s complaint against Amity University, and a Chennai building dispute that became a nationwide inquiry into unauthorised constructions. The reported reason is that the bench turned individual disputes into nationwide PILs even though its roster does not include PILs. No official statement has been issued.

New Delhi: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has withdrawn at least two cases from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah and reassigned them to other benches. The bench had expanded individual disputes into nationwide public interest litigation (PIL) although its roster does not cover PILs, according to a report in the Hindustan Times that cited people aware of the matter.
According to the report, the CJI consulted Justices Vikram Nath, BV Nagarathna, MM Sundresh and PS Narasimha before reassigning the matters. The move reportedly came about four weeks after a full court meeting at which the CJI stressed that judges must work strictly within the subjects allotted to them in the roster.
No administrative order or statement has been made public by the Supreme Court. Justice Amanullah could not be reached for comment, according to the reports.
The first case: from one student to every private university
Ayesha Jain v. Amity University, Noida & Ors., W.P.(C) No. 531 of 2025, began as a student’s petition. She alleged harassment by university officials after she legally changed her name from Khushi Jain to Ayesha Jain, and said the university’s refusal to update its records left her short of attendance and cost her an academic year. The university later refunded her fees and paid Rs 1 lakh as compensation.
Not satisfied with the university’s conduct, a bench of Justice Amanullah and Justice NV Anjaria on November 20, 2025 expanded the case to examine how private universities across the country are established, governed, funded and regulated. It sought information from the Union, the States, the Union Territories and the University Grants Commission, and later directed the Cabinet Secretary, the Chief Secretaries and the UGC Chairman to file affidavits personally.
In September 2026, the bench directed private universities to disclose five years of audited accounts, fund use, fee structures, investment of surpluses and payments to persons not directly involved in education, observing that they “cannot be permitted to operate as profit-making institutions”. In October, it took note of an alleged fake medical college in Etah, Uttar Pradesh, said to be run from a dilapidated farmhouse, and directed regulators to issue public advisories to students.
The case is now listed on November 19 before a three-judge bench of Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh.
The second case: a Chennai building to every major city
Loganathan v. State of Tamil Nadu concerned a one-and-a-half-storey building in Chennai constructed without an approved plan. From March 25 this year, the bench of Justice Amanullah and Justice R Mahadevan took up unauthorised constructions and the commercial misuse of residential properties across the country. It sought responses from States and from municipal authorities in major cities, including Delhi and the National Capital Region, with Senior Advocate Ajit Kumar Sinha, assisted by Advocate Govind Jee, as amicus curiae.
That case is now expected to be heard on November 23 by a bench headed by Justice BV Nagarathna.
Why the roster matters
Under the current roster, according to the reports, Justice Amanullah’s bench is not assigned PILs. A person familiar with the matter told the newspaper that judges “ought to work as per the roster to keep case allocation orderly”. If the bench felt a matter needed to be heard as a PIL, the source said, it should have been referred to the CJI through the Registry.
The Chief Justice’s power over the roster rests on a line of Supreme Court rulings:
- In State of Rajasthan v. Prakash Chand (1997), the Court held that the Chief Justice alone has the prerogative to constitute benches and allocate judicial business.
- In Jasbir Singh v. State of Punjab (2006), it held that a judge who thinks a matter should go before another bench must seek orders from the Chief Justice instead of assuming jurisdiction.
- In Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms v. Union of India (2017), a five-judge Constitution Bench held that the CJI is the master of the roster and that no judge can take up a matter unless it has been allocated by the CJI.
- In Shanti Bhushan v. Supreme Court of India (2018), the Court reaffirmed that the CJI, as master of the roster, has the exclusive power to allocate cases and constitute benches.
The reports also refer to Kishore Samrite v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2012), in which the Court said claims of public interest must be scrutinised to guard against misuse of PIL jurisdiction.
The other view
The CJI’s control over the roster has long drawn criticism from sections of the Bar, who argue that the power to allocate and withdraw cases should be exercised transparently and not shift matters already being heard. Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave has separately questioned the CJI’s handling of a contempt matter relating to the deputation of IPS officers to the Central Armed Police Forces. He said it interfered with a September 29 order passed by Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul Chandurkar, and cited Shanti Bhushan to argue that a matter already assigned to a bench should not be interfered with.
Supporters of the reassignment point to the Court’s own rulings that a bench may hear only what the CJI allocates to it, and say a bench without a PIL roster widening a case into a nationwide inquiry sits uneasily with that rule.
Why the reassignment matters
Both cases had moved well beyond the individual disputes in which they began, and both had produced directions affecting authorities across the country. The proceedings themselves continue. What changes is the bench, and with it the approach that new benches take to the nationwide scope of the cases. The Nath bench’s hearing on November 19 in the private universities case will be the first indication of whether that scope is retained, narrowed or sent back to the individual dispute.
The account of the reasons for the reassignment rests on unnamed sources, and the Supreme Court has not issued any statement on it.
Cases reassigned:
1. Ayesha Jain v. Amity University, Noida & Ors., W.P.(C) No. 531 of 2025: earlier before Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and NV Anjaria; now before Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh; listed November 19, 2026
2. Loganathan v. State of Tamil Nadu: earlier before Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and R Mahadevan; now before a bench headed by Justice BV Nagarathna; expected November 23, 2026
Source: Hindustan Times report citing people aware of the matter; no official order published
