Eviction proceedings against the Delhi Gymkhana Club may go on, the Supreme Court has said, but the Estate Officer cannot pass any final order without the Court’s permission until the appeals are heard on December 10.

New Delhi: The Central government’s eviction proceedings against the Delhi Gymkhana Club can continue before the Estate Officer, the Supreme Court said on Monday (November 16), but the officer is restrained from passing a final order without the Court’s prior permission [Atul Dev & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.].
The interim direction came from a Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu, which was hearing connected appeals arising from the long-running dispute over the government takeover of the club’s management and the resumption of its land in Lutyens’ Delhi. The Bench ordered:
“Proceedings before the Estate Officer may continue, but no final order may be passed without the permission of this Court.”
The matter has been listed for final hearing on December 10.
Two tracks of litigation
The first track began in April 2022, when the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) allowed a petition by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs under Sections 241 and 242 of the Companies Act, 2013. It suspended the club’s elected General Committee over allegations of financial irregularities and nepotism and allowed the Centre to nominate 15 directors. On October 21, 2024, the NCLAT upheld the takeover but directed the government-appointed committee to complete remedial measures by March 31, 2025 and to hold fresh elections within three months after that. The erstwhile members, led by Major Atul Dev, and the Centre both challenged the ruling in the Supreme Court in 2025.
The second track concerns the land. On May 22, 2026, the Land and Development Office terminated the club’s perpetual lease for its 27.3-acre Safdarjung Road premises, citing the need to strengthen and secure defence infrastructure. Eviction proceedings followed under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act. In October 2026, after the Supreme Court allowed members to raise their grievances before the Delhi High Court, the High Court restrained the Estate Officer from passing a final eviction order until November 17. Monday’s order extends that protection until the Supreme Court’s December 10 hearing.
Centre’s 203-day delay under scrutiny
The appeals before the Court come from erstwhile members of the club’s General Committee and from the Central government, each challenging different parts of the NCLAT judgment. On Monday, the Bench took up an application seeking recall of an earlier order that had condoned a 203-day delay in the Union’s cross-appeal.
The Bench asked whether it had jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution to entertain a statutorily time-barred appeal, observing that the Union could instead have filed a cross-objection in the main appeal already pending before it.
Appearing for the Centre, Attorney General R Venkataramani submitted that the core question in the government’s appeal was whether the strict timelines fixed by the NCLAT for holding club elections could be complied with in letter and spirit. He said the NCLAT had declined to hear the government on the timeline because the erstwhile members’ appeal was already pending in the Supreme Court. The Bench indicated that it was not persuaded by the justification for the delay, remarking:
“They have applied for a recall of the order of this Court whereby the 203-day delay was condoned. We are on this application today. And we find that whatever you have stated in your notes are not persuasive, learned Attorney.”
Members flag risk of dispossession
Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, for the appellant members, had earlier urged the Court to protect the club from dispossession. He pointed to what he called an anomalous position: the Union of India is the lessor of the land, while a government-appointed committee controls the lessee club, leaving the erstwhile members to defend the club’s possession in civil proceedings.
The Bench assured the parties that no irreversible prejudice would be caused while the appeals are heard on merits, and said that if any erroneous interim order had been passed earlier, it would be the first to vacate it at the final hearing.
The Court has not ruled on the merits of the takeover, the lease termination or the eviction proceedings. Its direction is interim and operates until the final hearing.
Why the order matters
Until the Supreme Court decides who should run the club and whether the Centre’s own time-barred appeal can be heard at all, the club’s century-old premises stay out of reach of a final eviction order. By letting the Estate Officer proceed but holding back the last step, the Court has balanced the Centre’s claim over prime public land against the members’ fear of being dispossessed before their appeals are decided.
Case Title: Atul Dev & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. (with connected appeals)
Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu, Supreme Court of India
Date of Hearing: November 16, 2026 (final hearing December 10, 2026)
Appearances: Attorney General R Venkataramani for the Union of India; Senior Advocate Vikas Singh for the appellant members
