The Supreme Court has set aside an NCLAT decision invalidating Valentis Laboratories’ resolution plan for Manjeera Constructions because the successful applicant was not heard. The relief rests on natural justice: separate appeals against approval of the plan remain pending, with all substantive issues left open.

New Delhi: A resolution plan could not be invalidated behind the back of the successful resolution applicant, the Supreme Court has held while setting aside the NCLAT’s March 19, 2026 decision concerning Manjeera Constructions Limited [Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd and another].
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva delivered the judgment on November 16, 2026. Justice Sanjay Kumar authored the decision, carrying neutral citation 2026 INSC 1225.
The bench disposed of two appeals under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. It did not give the resolution plan unconditional clearance on its merits: challenges to the NCLT’s approval order remain before the NCLAT.
A creditor’s objection preceded formal plan approval
Insolvency proceedings against Manjeera Constructions, the corporate guarantor of Manjeera Retail Holdings, were admitted in July 2023 at the instance of financial creditor Catalyst Trusteeship Limited.
Valentis Laboratories’ plan received approval from the Committee of Creditors on June 10, 2024 with a 91.64% voting share. S2 Tech.com India, which held 3.3% of the voting share, sought rejection of the plan. One objection was that Valentis had failed to remit its earnest money deposit within the deadline prescribed in the Request for Resolution Plan.
The NCLT rejected that application on July 30, 2024. It reasoned that the minority creditor had participated in the meeting and could not challenge the majority’s approval, while noting that the Tribunal still had to examine the plan within the IBC’s parameters. The Supreme Court’s present decision does not endorse that reasoning on minority-creditor standing; it rests on the lack of a hearing.
The applicant was never made a party
S2 Tech.com appealed against rejection of its objection in September 2024. The NCLT subsequently approved Valentis’ resolution plan on March 26, 2025.
The Supreme Court noted that S2 Tech.com knew the creditors had approved Valentis’ plan when it filed the appeal, yet did not implead the successful applicant. It did not secure Valentis’ inclusion even after the NCLT formally approved the plan.
The Court was told that an impleadment application had in fact been filed, but was not pursued and had not even been numbered when the NCLAT decided the appeal.
Nevertheless, the NCLAT invalidated the plan and issued directions to the resolution professional. Valentis was not a party and had not been afforded an opportunity to defend its position.
Natural justice was decisive
In paragraph 10, the Supreme Court held that the decision imposed serious civil consequences on the successful applicant without hearing it. That violation of the principle of audi alteram partem—the obligation to hear the affected party—was sufficient to make the judgment unsustainable.
The bench also observed that the NCLAT had gone beyond the issues raised in the creditor’s original application, but expressly declined to examine the validity of the decision on that broader basis.
No remand; pending appeals will address the merits
The Supreme Court declined to send this particular appeal back for a fresh hearing because separate appeals already challenged the NCLT’s March 26, 2025 approval of the plan.
Those pending proceedings include appeals by Gajjala Yoganand, Manjeera Constructions’ homebuyers and Saasa Villa LLP. The Court was informed that the earnest-money-deposit issue was also raised there.
Paragraphs 12 and 13 therefore set aside the NCLAT judgment solely for breach of natural justice and leave all issues open in the appeals against the plan-approval order. This allows the parties to present their respective cases in proceedings properly directed against that approval.
The ruling reinforces the need to hear the party whose approved plan is at risk. It does not decide whether the deposit was timely, whether the plan otherwise satisfies the IBC, or whether the pending challenges should succeed. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
Case: Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd and another
Numbers: Civil Appeal No. 4171 of 2026, with Civil Appeal No. 4585 of 2026
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva
Date: November 16, 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1225
Outcome: NCLAT judgment set aside; appeals disposed of; merits left open in pending challenges to plan approval.
