An unrelated purchaser cannot be made responsible for proving that a company’s internal board meeting took place, the Supreme Court has held while applying the doctrine of indoor management. It set aside tribunal orders cancelling a land sale, also relying on audited accounts signed by the director who later claimed ignorance of the transaction.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has allowed Elaine Info Solutions Private Limited’s appeal against cancellation of its purchase of nine acres and 28 guntas from J & A Avenues India Private Limited [Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s. J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Ors.].
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva delivered the reportable judgment on November 16, 2026. Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva authored the ruling, carrying neutral citation 2026 INSC 1228.
The Court set aside the NCLT’s August 2, 2019 order and the NCLAT’s March 18, 2020 decision, and dismissed the petition under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013. It expressly left a separate specific-performance suit to be decided on its own merits.
The dispute over board approval
The seller company had two directors and equal shareholders: a mother and her son. The mother challenged the September 4, 2015 sale deed, saying she had neither received notice of nor participated in the August 1, 2015 board meeting said to have authorised her son to execute it.
The purchaser maintained that it had acted on a board resolution and paid the agreed consideration. The parties also disputed whether other payments related to this sale or to a separate proposed transaction involving the son’s land.
The NCLT held that valid authorisation was absent, declared the resolution and sale deed void, and directed cancellation and restoration of the property to the seller company. The NCLAT upheld the result. Those were the findings reversed by the Supreme Court.
Internal proceedings were for the directors to prove
In paragraphs 18 to 20, the Supreme Court emphasised that Elaine was an unrelated third party to the company’s affairs. Whether the meeting was held and the resolution passed lay within the personal knowledge of the directors and shareholders.
The Court held that it was erroneous to make the purchaser prove that the mother had received notice or attended the meeting. On these facts, the doctrine of indoor management applied: an outside purchaser acting bona fide on a resolution produced by one of the two directors could not be saddled with proving the company’s internal proceedings.
The ruling’s application of that doctrine rested on the surrounding evidence as well as the purchaser’s position. It should not be read as dispensing with good faith in every transaction involving a disputed company resolution.
Signed accounts contradicted claimed ignorance
The Court found that ₹4,36,50,000 had been received in the company’s account and used for its purposes. The audited accounts were signed by both directors, and their notes expressly recorded execution of the sale deed.
The mother signed the books and financial-statement notes on September 2, 2016. She had not challenged their authenticity or the reference to the land sale. The Court therefore held that she could not deny knowledge of the transaction and the use of its proceeds.
Although she disputed the signature attributed to her on the certified copy of the resolution, the Court also noted that she had initiated no criminal proceedings against her son over the alleged forgery. This was part of its assessment of the record, not a finding convicting anyone of forgery.
Separate civil suit remains open
The Court noted that the Section 241 petition was filed in October 2018, more than three years after the registered sale deed, despite the earlier signed accounts. It also drew an adverse inference from the company’s failure to produce income-tax returns showing the treatment of the transaction.
Elaine’s appeal was allowed. The son’s connected appeal was dismissed as infructuous because his five-year disqualification from the company’s directorship had already run its course.
The bench clarified that it had not examined the merits of either party’s allegations in O.S. No. 15/2016, pending before the First Additional District Judge, Sangareddy. That suit must be decided independently, without being influenced by this judgment.
Case: Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s. J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Ors.
Numbers: Civil Appeal No. 2821 of 2020, with Civil Appeal No. 6250 of 2021
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva
Date: November 16, 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1228
Outcome: Purchaser’s appeal allowed; connected appeal dismissed as infructuous; Section 241 petition dismissed.
