“I just cracked a joke, okay?” That is how Justice GR Swaminathan of the Madras High Court described his “atonement” suggestion on fraudulently procured library books, as he answered CPI(M) MP Su Venkatesan’s criticism from the Bench while the State reported a DVAC FIR and five suspensions.

Madurai: The State told the Madras High Court on Monday (November 16) that the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) has registered an FIR over alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for Tamil Nadu’s public libraries. In the same hearing of a contempt petition, Justice GR Swaminathan criticised Communist Party of India (Marxist) MP Su Venkatesan for advising him on how to discharge his judicial duties, and questioned the MP’s lifestyle [Contempt Petition concerning procurement of books for public libraries; case title to be verified].
The Division Bench comprised Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi.
Five officials suspended, searches at seven locations
State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan informed the Bench that the DVAC FIR names Agal Vilakku Pathippagam proprietor Mohan as an accused. Five officials have been suspended, the State said, and searches were under way at seven locations. The Court was also told that about Rs 20 crore had been disbursed out of Rs 30 crore sanctioned for the procurement.
Advocate General Vijay Narayan assured the Bench that the investigation would reach everyone involved, whatever their position:
“No person who was involved in this will go unpunished. That Your Lordship can be assured.”
The Court recorded the assurance. It indicated that it intends to conclude the contempt proceedings within one or two more hearings and leave the investigation to the competent authorities. The matter will be heard next on November 20.
A book release remark and a post in reply
At a recent book release function, Justice Swaminathan had suggested that books on Maha Periyava, the late Kanchi Shankaracharya, be placed on the shelves of the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore, where books supplied by Agal Vilakku Publications had been stocked. He framed it as a way of atoning for the alleged wrongdoing in their procurement.
Venkatesan, who represents Madurai in the Lok Sabha, responded on X on November 15. He said the alleged irregularities amounted to corruption and that those responsible should be punished according to law. Punishing corruption was the job of judges, he said, while prescribing atonement for sins was the work of astrologers. He also invoked Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Periyar, saying they were remembered for their contributions to legal thought and rationalism respectively.
The judge’s reply from the Bench
Justice Swaminathan recalled meeting the MP at Chennai railway station about six months ago, before boarding the Pandian Express to Madurai, and said:
“He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything and I don’t know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle.”
The MP was travelling in First AC, the judge said, while he himself was headed for the Sleeper Class compartment. He recounted telling the MP, “I normally travel by Sleeper Class. My number is S3-23.” Turning to the MP’s later criticism, he remarked, “So this…he is telling me as to what I should do as a judge.”
Justice Swaminathan also clarified that his earlier suggestion was made in a lighter vein:
“I just cracked a joke, okay? It was really meant to be a joke only… By buying these books and stacking the racks, they have committed a sin. Let them wipe away that sin by replacing them with books on spirituality.”
These were oral remarks made during the hearing and do not form part of any order. The MP’s response to the remarks made in court was not before the Bench.
What the hearing signals
With an FIR, suspensions and searches now on record and the Bench signalling that it will soon step back, the library books case is moving from court monitoring to criminal investigation. The exchange over the MP’s criticism also brings into focus the public debate on judges’ remarks made off the Bench and the responses they draw from elected representatives.
The allegations in the FIR are yet to be tested. The Court has expressed no view on the guilt of any person, and every accused is entitled to the presumption of innocence.
Case Title: Contempt Petition concerning procurement of books for Tamil Nadu public libraries (title and number to be verified)
Bench: Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi, Madras High Court (Madurai Bench)
Date of Hearing: November 16, 2026 (next hearing November 20, 2026)
Appearances: Advocate General Vijay Narayan and State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan for the State of Tamil Nadu
