Supreme Court Reserves Verdict On District Judges’ Retirement Age Of 62, Asks AG To Persuade States

5 min read

With 15 States and Union Territories in favour, 12 opposed and four seeking more time, the Supreme Court on Wednesday reserved its verdict on District Judges’ Retirement Age of 62 and asked the Attorney General to make one last attempt to bring the opposing States and Union Territories on board, telling them not to equate judicial officers with civil servants.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, the Supreme Court bench that reserved verdict on district judges' retirement age.

New Delhi: Reserving judgment on whether the superannuation age of District Judges across the country should be raised to 62 years, the Supreme Court on November 18, 2026 asked Attorney General R Venkataramani to persuade the States and Union Territories that still opposed the move. The reluctant States/UTs have been given two weeks to revisit the issue while the judgment is being written [All India Judges Association & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.].

The hearing was before a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, in the long-running All India Judges Association case. The Court had earlier asked all States/UTs to consider raising the retirement age of district judges to 61 or 62 years after consulting their High Courts.

Fifteen in favour, twelve against

Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar, the amicus curiae, gave the Bench the current count: 15 States/UTs favoured the enhancement and 12 continued to oppose it, while four (Gujarat, Jharkhand, Delhi and Puducherry) wanted more time. Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Haryana, Bihar, Manipur, Meghalaya, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan were among those opposing.

Several States spoke for themselves. Meghalaya’s Advocate General said the proposal was pending before the State Cabinet, and Telangana informed the Court that an Ordinance had already been promulgated raising the age to 62. Haryana’s Advocate General said his instructions were to leave it to the Court to pass an appropriate order, while Punjab said the issue was under active consideration and sought time.

The old objections and the Bench’s reply

Back in September, the States/UTs had based their opposition on three grounds: the added burden on the exchequer, “heartburn” among other State employees, and the effect on the legitimate expectations of young entrants to judicial service. The Court had then rejected the financial burden argument, noting that retaining officers longer would in fact defer payment of pension and retiral dues.

When a State Advocate General again cited the financial burden, Justice Bagchi said:

“You are agreeable to pay pension without taking work, and increase your human resource load, and that is a burden. And secondly is legitimate expectation of the cadre. We already have so much of vacancy that the question of legitimate expectation itself is illusory. On the other hand, it’s a crying demand that we have low attrition rate of judges.”

Chief Justice Surya Kant said the system loses an experienced officer while paying both the retiree and a new incumbent:

“In the entire bargain, you lose an experienced person. Resulting in pay to new incumbent. We don’t have anything against new incumbent. New blood also is to be infused. It’s not that. But it’s a question of 2 years service only. We will request the AG to speak to the states/UTs and convince them. We’d like to close the proceedings with a happy note.”

“Please don’t compare civil services with judicial services,” the CJI added, urging the reluctant States/UTs to come back with a constructive proposal. Some of the opposing States/UTs were “minor”, he remarked, but Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan in particular needed the Attorney General’s intervention.

What counsel urged

Senior Advocate Vijay Hansaria argued that States/UTs had been given enough leeway and sought a judicial order in favour of the enhancement. On the financial burden argument, he submitted that about 20 per cent of judicial posts lie vacant at any given time.

Senior Advocate Vikas Singh submitted that the retirement age must be uniform and opposed any condition requiring High Courts to assess the suitability of every officer before extending service to 62. States already have the option of compulsory retirement for officers found unfit, he said, and asked that officers eligible for elevation who retired in the meantime be protected. Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta sought protection for a group of officers who, he said, were receiving neither pension nor salary.

These remarks were made orally during the hearing. The Court has reserved its judgment and is yet to rule on the issue.

What the reserved verdict could settle

District judges retire at 60 in most States, even as trial courts carry heavy pendency and a large share of posts remain vacant. A uniform age of 62 would keep experienced officers on the bench for two more years and, as the Bench pointed out, defer retiral payouts. With the judgment reserved and the States given a final window, the ruling could settle a question that has run through the All India Judges Association litigation for years and set a single national standard for the subordinate judiciary.

Case Title: All India Judges Association & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., W.P.(C) No. 1022/1989
Bench: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana
Date of Hearing: November 18, 2026 (judgment reserved)
Appearances: Senior Advocates Vikas Singh, Siddharth Bhatnagar (Amicus Curiae), Vijay Hansaria and Jaideep Gupta; Attorney General R Venkataramani; Advocates General of States/UTs

Similar Posts