Prior Gram Sabha Consent Is Mandatory: Supreme Court Quashes Odisha Land Acquisition For Dalmia Mining Project

4 min read

The Supreme Court has set aside land acquisition proceedings for a private mining project in Odisha, holding that prior Gram Sabha consent in Scheduled Areas is mandatory. It also ruled that the required consent of affected families cannot be collected later to cure an acquisition that proceeded without it.

Supreme Court of India building, which quashed an Odisha land acquisition for a Dalmia mining project over missing Gram Sabha consent.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on November 18, 2026 quashed the acquisition of land in three villages of Odisha’s Sundergarh district for mining by M/s Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited, finding violations of the safeguards governing consent, public participation and independent scrutiny [Bibol Toppo & Ors. v. State of Odisha & Ors.].

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma set aside the Orissa High Court’s September 6, 2024 judgment, along with the acquisition and its relevant notifications and orders. Justice Sharma authored the reportable judgment. The authorities remain free to begin a fresh acquisition in accordance with law and the Court’s findings.

A mining lease did not settle the landowners’ rights

The dispute concerned land in Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna. The company already held mining rights under a State lease but sought acquisition of surface rights to extend its mining operations. The acquisition process was initiated under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.

The State and company argued, among other things, that the acquisition was for the State and that the existing mining lease supported the company’s entitlement to surface rights. The Supreme Court rejected the attempt to treat it as acquisition for the government’s own use. Its purpose was mining by a private company; the fact that title would vest in the State did not determine which statutory procedure applied.

Consent must come before the statutory decision

In paragraphs 27–34, the Court held that Section 2(2)(b) applied and required prior consent of at least 80 per cent of the affected families covered by the provision. That process must take place alongside the Social Impact Assessment study and must be completed before the government examines the acquisition proposal under Section 8.

The High Court had treated consent as a continuing process that could run through different stages of acquisition. The Supreme Court found that approach inconsistent with the statute. It also found no supporting material demonstrating that the State’s claimed consents had been obtained in the prescribed Form J and procedure. Even assuming later consents existed, they could not replace the required prior consent.

Scheduled Area protection is binding

The Bench separately examined Section 41(3), which requires prior consent of the concerned Gram Sabha or the other specified local institution in Scheduled Areas. The High Court had relied on qualifying expressions in other sub-sections to treat this requirement as directory.

Rejecting that reasoning in paragraphs 38–43, the Supreme Court held that those sub-sections address distinct stages. Once the government decides to acquire land in a Scheduled Area, the mandatory consent requirement cannot be diluted by borrowing qualifications from the preceding provisions.

The Court stated in paragraph 39: “the requirement of Section 41(3) of the Act is mandatory in nature”. It found that the concerned Gram Sabhas had expressly rejected the proposal through resolutions dated January 26, 2020, and that there was no consent in the prescribed Form M.

Public hearing and independent scrutiny also failed

The Court found no material establishing that the scheduled public hearing on the draft Social Impact Assessment had actually taken place. RTI responses pointed to its cancellation because of COVID-19 restrictions, while the affected persons’ views were absent from the final report.

It also held that inclusion of the company’s land-acquisition adviser in the Expert Group compromised the independence required by Section 7. The ability to include a technical expert did not permit appointment of someone whose financial and professional links undermined independent evaluation of the project.

Fresh acquisition remains possible

The Bench held that the mining law and the 2013 acquisition law operate in distinct spheres. Having chosen the acquisition route under the 2013 Act, the respondents could not defend violations by arguing that another legal route might have been available. The Court expressly refrained from finally deciding those alternative possibilities.

Paragraphs 58–60 set aside the acquisition and the High Court judgment, while preserving liberty to initiate a fresh, lawful process. The ruling therefore invalidates the acquisition before the Court; it does not impose a permanent prohibition on a fresh proposal.

Case Title: Bibol Toppo & Ors. v. State of Odisha & Ors.
Case Number: Civil Appeal No. 8294 of 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1244
Court and Bench: Supreme Court of India; Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026
Outcome: Acquisition and relevant notifications/orders set aside; High Court judgment set aside; fresh acquisition in accordance with law permitted.

Similar Posts