Telangana High Court Says Protective Homes For Trafficking Victims Cannot Hold Accused, Issues Statewide Directions

5 min read

Can protective homes meant for trafficking victims also be used to hold the accused? The Telangana High Court has answered no, and has set out a statewide framework for police, Magistrates, legal services bodies and departments to keep survivors and alleged exploiters apart.

Telangana High Court building, where a Division Bench issued directions on protective homes for trafficking victims.

Hyderabad: On a writ petition filed by an anti-trafficking NGO that runs a Protective Home, the Telangana High Court has held that such homes exist exclusively for victims and cannot be used to detain or remand persons accused of trafficking. It has also issued detailed directions on verification, separate placement and periodic review [M/s. Prajwala v. State of Telangana & Ors.].

A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda delivered the judgment on November 13, 2026 in Writ Petition No. 15506 of 2025, reserved earlier on April 27, 2026. The judgment was authored by Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda.

What Magistrates must do

Before passing an order under Section 17 of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956, the Court said, a Magistrate must hold the inquiry the law requires, look at material bearing on the safety and suitability of the placement, and give a reasoned order. The judgment states:

“They shall take necessary precautions to prevent genuine victims from being placed with suspected exploiters in the same Protective Home; where the material discloses a safety risk, appropriate separate placement, protection and rehabilitation orders shall be passed in accordance with law. Mere suspicion shall neither authorise punitive detention nor dispense with the statutory inquiry and opportunity of hearing.”

Children are to be dealt with under the applicable child-protection laws and produced before the competent authority. The Registry was also asked to place the order before the Chief Justice on the administrative side, so that it can be circulated to Magistrates and used for sensitisation.

Telling victim from perpetrator

Protective homes and corrective institutions, the Court held, serve distinct statutory functions. It also cautioned that nobody can be branded a trafficker merely because of an FIR or a past accusation, just as the label of a “rescued person” does not remove the need for a careful risk assessment. If the two are not told apart, it warned, genuine victims could face intimidation and manipulation. It said:

“The possibility of an organiser or perpetrator presenting as a victim requires careful verification. The nature and extent of care and rehabilitation required by victims necessarily differ from the corrective and rehabilitative measures lawfully applicable to perpetrators and organisers. Separate facilities and individual measures must therefore correspond to the legal status, assessed needs and safety requirements of the persons concerned.”

Directions for implementation and review

Among the directions on implementation, the Court ordered that:

  • Women and Child Development, Labour, Social Welfare, Health, Education and district administration designate contact officers to coordinate with district Anti-Human Trafficking Units and DLSAs, and facilitate referrals, survivor-sensitive care, rehabilitation and preventive outreach through One Stop Centres and Bharosa Centres.
  • District Collectors convene interdepartmental review meetings at least once every six months, without intruding on pending investigations or proceedings.
  • The DGP, through the Women Safety Wing, designate a State nodal officer and circulate the existing SOP and these directions to Anti-Human Trafficking Units and police, with periodic training.
  • The Telangana State Legal Services Authority call for quarterly statements from DLSAs and review them every six months, and the education departments obtain semester-wise implementation reports.
  • Nodal authorities file an initial compliance report with the Principal Secretary, Home, within three months, followed by six-monthly reports for a year, stating steps towards separate facilities, segregation protocols and inter-agency information sharing, without disclosing the identity of any victim.

The police were also asked to issue advisories to landlords to exercise due diligence so that premises are not used for trafficking, with the caveat that verification must not lead to discrimination based on sex, occupation or social background. The Court clarified that its observations are confined to systemic issues and are not a finding on anyone’s culpability.

How the dispute began

Prajwala had challenged an order of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Nampally, directing it to admit a woman found during a raid on a spa. According to the NGO, she was also an accused in a separate human trafficking case, and putting an alleged organiser among vulnerable survivors would create a security risk. The NGO said it took her in only to avoid contempt. She was later released to her mother, but the petitioner pressed for wider institutional safeguards, arguing that treating protective homes as default custodial institutions was dangerous.

Senior Advocate L. Ravichander, instructed by Advocate Deepak Misra, appeared for the petitioner. Government Pleader G. Vijaya Kumari appeared for the Law Department and the Government Pleader for Home for the Home Department. Advocate K.V. Raman also appeared.

What the ruling changes

Rescue operations often sweep up survivors and alleged organisers together, and Magistrates under pressure to place everyone somewhere safe have tended to treat NGO-run homes as a default. The ruling draws a firm line between care for survivors and custody of the accused, requires a reasoned, individual assessment before any placement, and backs it with reporting duties for the police, legal services authorities and the State.

Case Title: M/s. Prajwala v. State of Telangana & Ors.
Case No.: Writ Petition No. 15506 of 2025
Bench: Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda, High Court for the State of Telangana
Date of Judgment: November 13, 2026 (reserved April 27, 2026)
Appearances: Senior Advocate L. Ravichander with Advocate Deepak Misra for the petitioner; Government Pleader G. Vijaya Kumari for respondent No. 1; Government Pleader for Home for respondent No. 3; Advocate K.V. Raman

Similar Posts