A foreign national “cannot claim an unconditional right to reside in India”, the Delhi High Court has said in rejecting a US citizen’s spouse visa plea, holding that marriage to an Indian citizen does not by itself give a foreign national an enforceable right to stay in India or to claim an Entry (X-1) visa.

New Delhi: Holding that the entry and stay of a foreign national in India is a matter of sovereign discretion and not an enforceable right against the State, the Delhi High Court has dismissed a writ petition by a citizen of the United States who sought a direction to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO), Delhi to convert her e-Tourist Visa into an Entry (X-1)/Spouse Visa on the strength of her marriage to an Indian citizen [Lisa Hall Srivastava v. Union of India & Anr.].
Sitting singly, Justice Amit Mahajan delivered the oral judgment on November 17, 2026. He found the explanation in the authorities’ counter affidavit satisfactory and their suspicion “well-founded”.
Marriage alone confers no visa
Justice Mahajan held that the petitioner’s claim was “destined to fail” and observed:
“The mere fact that the Petitioner has entered into a marriage with an Indian citizen does not, by itself, confer an automatic or indefeasible right to conversion of her existing visa into an Entry (X-1) Visa.”
Visas, the Court said, are for the competent authorities to grant, convert and extend, and the regulation of a foreigner’s stay falls within their domain under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, which empowers the Central Government to prohibit, regulate or restrict the entry, departure and continued presence of foreigners. Relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Louis De Raedt v. Union of India (1991) 3 SCC 544, it noted that a foreigner’s fundamental rights are confined to Article 21 and do not include the right to reside and settle in India under Article 19(1)(e).
“Thus, in the present case, a foreign national cannot claim an unconditional right to reside in India or insist upon the grant of a particular category of visa merely on the basis of a matrimonial relationship.”
What the marriage certificate could not do
The petitioner had relied on the certificate issued under the Special Marriage Act. Such a certificate, the Court said, “does not, by itself, foreclose the power of the competent immigration authority to examine the surrounding circumstances”. It also noted that her husband, Mohd. Wasim Akram, had filed no affidavit to support her claims about the marriage and cohabitation, while clarifying that this absence could not by itself decide whether the marriage was genuine.
It is not for a writ court, the Court held, to substitute its own assessment for that of the competent authority in matters of admission of foreign nationals, and the petition was dismissed. The Court clarified, however, that it had not adjudicated on the validity or genuineness of the marriage, that its observations were confined to the claim for immigration benefits, and that any pending or future representation must be decided by the respondents in accordance with law.
Her petition
Lisa Hall Srivastava holds an e-Tourist Visa valid till September 14, 2027. According to the petition, she married Mohd. Wasim Akram on December 7, 2025 under Muslim rites and customs, and the marriage was later solemnised before the Marriage Officer under the Special Marriage Act, 1954 on March 18, 2026. On March 27, 2026 she applied to the FRRO to have her visa converted into an Entry (X-1) Visa.
Her case was that, despite her submitting the required documents, the application was not processed favourably and that she and her husband were instead subjected to repeated enquiries on account of the age difference between them. She asked the Court to quash the e-mails she described as an informal rejection, restrain any coercive action including deportation, frame guidelines for in-camera and dignified visa interviews of spouses, and award her Rs 5 lakh as compensation.
The authorities’ answer
The respondents said in their counter affidavit that the application was examined in light of the petitioner’s immigration history. They stated that she had earlier been married to George Daniel Williamson, an OCI card holder, and had obtained OCI status on that basis; that marriage was dissolved in July 2021 and her OCI status was cancelled in November 2023.
According to the respondents, she then married Deepak Srivastava in December 2022 and sought visa conversion and extension on that basis too, but could not secure the benefit due to deficiencies in documentation, and that marriage ended in November 2025. The present marriage, they said, was her third.
The authorities told the Court that the enquiry was not founded merely on the age difference. They pointed to her successive marriages, her prolonged stay in India, her earlier applications for immigration benefits based on marriage, her residential arrangements and her explanations about her source of income. They also said she had been living as a tenant in premises owned by Mohd. Wasim Akram before the marriage, and that he had accompanied her when she was pursuing benefits on the basis of her earlier marriage.
On this material, the competent authority formed a prima facie opinion that the present marriage was “a marriage of convenience”. Her application, the Court was told, has been processed as an Exit Permit Request, which is pending for non-compliance by the petitioner.
What the ruling confirms
The ruling restates a settled position: a foreigner in India is protected by Article 21 in matters of life and personal liberty, but has no fundamental right to reside or settle here. A marriage to an Indian citizen, even one registered under the Special Marriage Act, does not convert that position into a right to a particular visa.
It also confirms that immigration authorities may look beyond a marriage certificate at the wider circumstances, including past immigration history, and that writ courts will be slow to second-guess that assessment. At the same time, the Court kept the question of the marriage’s validity open and left the door open for the petitioner’s representations to be decided in accordance with law.
Case Title: Lisa Hall Srivastava v. Union of India & Anr. (W.P.(C) 7554/2026)
Bench: Justice Amit Mahajan, Delhi High Court
Date of Judgment: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Zahied F Chouhan, Iqura Khan, Nida Parveen and Kunwar Sultan Ali for the petitioner; CGSC Avshreya Pratap Singh Rudy with Advocates Usha Jamnal, Nyasa Sharama, Abhinav Mall, Nishtha Dhall and Harshita Chaturvedi for the Union of India
