Panchkula Consumer Commission Calls Reliance Refund-To-Wallet Diversion A Dark Pattern, Awards Rs 7,500

3 min read

A refund promised to the original payment mode cannot be quietly split into a reward wallet, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Panchkula has held, calling the practice a dark pattern and ordering Reliance Retail and Reliance Smart Superstore to pay Rs 7,500 in all.

Judge’s gavel, illustrating the Panchkula Consumer Commission order calling a refund-to-wallet diversion a dark pattern

Panchkula: Re 1 out of each Rs 19 refund owed to a customer was credited to her Twid reward wallet instead of her bank account, and for that the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Panchkula on October 28, 2026 held Reliance Smart Superstore and Reliance Retail Limited jointly and severally liable for deficiency in service and a deceptive practice [Nishtha Raghav v. Reliance Smart Superstore & Anr.].

The complaint was filed under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and allowed by a Commission comprising President Satpal and Members Dr. Sushma Garg and Dr. Suman Singh.

Where the deficiency lay

Examining the unrebutted documents on merits, the Commission said that a product being out of stock is not, by itself, a deficiency in service. The fault was in how the refund was handled, since a bank account and a reward wallet are distinct ways of holding money.

“A consumer cannot be compelled to accept wallet credit in place of a refund to the original mode of payment, particularly when the opposite parties had represented that the amount would be refunded through the original payment mode.”

Under the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023, the Commission classed the practice as a deceptive dark pattern. Holding part of a refund inside a digital reward ecosystem without informed consent, it observed, manipulates consumer choice, because users are nudged into repeat purchases on the platform to use up the credit. The same thing having happened on two separate orders, it ruled out an inadvertent accounting error.

Two orders, two short refunds

The complainant, Nishtha Raghav, a Panchkula resident, placed two grocery orders on the JioMart app on January 23 and January 25, 2026. Each time, a Munch Max chocolate bar priced at Rs 19 was unavailable. JioMart told her that a Rs 19 refund had been initiated to her original payment mode for each order, yet only Rs 18 reached her bank account on both occasions. The remaining Re 1 from each transaction went to her Twid (Pay with Rewards) wallet without prior disclosure or authorisation.

Her in-app grievance was closed without relief, and a legal notice sent on February 14 went unanswered. The opposite parties entered appearance through counsel but did not file a written statement despite several opportunities, and the Commission struck off their defence on June 26.

Rs 7,500 in all

Invoking the proviso to Section 39(1)(d) of the Act, the Commission directed the opposite parties to pay Rs 2,500 to the complainant as lump-sum compensation for harassment and litigation costs, and Rs 5,000 as punitive damages to the Free Legal Aid account of the Haryana State Commission, within 45 days.

Small sums, wider principle

The amounts are tiny, but the principle is not. Quick-commerce and e-commerce platforms routinely push refunds into wallets, coupons or reward points. Where the customer was told the money would return to the original payment mode, the order treats such a diversion as both a deficiency in service and a dark pattern that can attract punitive damages.

It also shows District Commissions applying the 2023 dark pattern guidelines directly in individual complaints, alongside the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s regulatory action against platforms.

Case Title: Nishtha Raghav v. Reliance Smart Superstore & Reliance Retail Limited [Consumer Complaint No. DC/70/CC/45/2026]
Coram: Satpal (President), Dr. Sushma Garg and Dr. Suman Singh (Members), District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Panchkula
Date of Order: October 28, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Parmod Bhardwaj for the complainant; Advocate Rahul Goyal had appeared for the opposite parties

Similar Posts