“Here, the bottle may have changed but the wine it holds remains vintage,” the Supreme Court said as it struck down the UP Pension Validation Laws of 2021 and 2025, holding that Uttar Pradesh cannot use fresh legislation to undo the Court’s binding 2019 ruling that work-charged service counts towards pension.

New Delhi: Service rendered by government employees in a work-charged establishment, or as temporary, daily-wage or muster-roll staff before regularisation, cannot be retrospectively excluded from qualifying service for pension, the Supreme Court has ruled, declaring the Uttar Pradesh Qualifying Service for Pension and Validation Act, 2021, and the Uttar Pradesh Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, ultra vires the Constitution. The Court directed the State to decide every eligible retiree’s claim within six months, failing which it must pay 9% simple interest [Uttar Pradesh Ground Water Department Non Gazetted Employee Association (Regd.) & Anr. v. The Chief Secretary & Ors.].
The 78-page judgment, delivered on November 18, 2026 by a Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, decided a batch of writ petitions, civil appeals and contempt petitions. Justice Datta authored it.
Can a change of language change a judgment?
The ruling turns on how far a legislature may go after a final judgment, here the three-Judge Bench decision in Prem Singh & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2019) 10 SCC 516. The Bench accepted that a judgment does not become immutable merely because it has been pronounced, but framed the real question as follows:
“Legislature may change the law or basis of the judgment; but, can it by mere change of language, change the judgment?”
It described the State’s reading of Prem Singh as “a subterfuge”, and concluded in its summing up:
“The retrospective exclusion of service rendered in a work-charged establishment or as temporary / daily-wage / muster-roll employee, upon regularisation of service, from the computation of qualifying service for pension cannot be sustained merely by introducing a new statutory definition or validating past denials of pension.”
Its directions, the Court made clear, operate in rem. Every employee falling within the ambit of the judgment is entitled to its benefit, whether or not he is a member of the petitioner association.
How the dispute reached the Court
The petitioners were employees and retired employees of State departments, including the Public Works Department, the Ground Water Department and the Irrigation Department. Many were first engaged between the late 1970s and the mid-1980s in work-charged establishments, and some began as daily-wage or muster-roll workers or as Seasonal Collection Amins, before being regularised years later.
In Prem Singh, the three-Judge Bench had held that such service had to be counted as qualifying service for pension. The State’s review petition was dismissed on February 13, 2020, and its curative petition was later withdrawn. The State then enacted the 2021 Validation Act and, while the present petitions were pending, the 2025 Act.
The Court described the batch as “a new form for an old, continuing grievance”, observing:
“Here, the bottle may have changed but the wine it holds remains vintage.”
What each side argued
The employees argued that the 2021 Act did not cure the defect identified in Prem Singh but merely restored, in a different statutory formulation, the very exclusion the Court had found constitutionally untenable. The State relied on the legislature’s competence to change the basis of a judgment through validating legislation.
The directions
- Both the 2021 and 2025 Acts are declared ultra vires, and claims of eligible work-charged employees are to be considered in light of Prem Singh.
- Every retired employee covered by the judgment may approach the competent authority with full particulars of service, and the authority must decide the claim within six months of receipt.
- Arrears are limited to three years before the institution of the writ petition in Prem Singh, but this cap will not apply to claims by heirs of employees who retired and died before that decision, subject to unimpeachable proof of heirship.
- No claim can be rejected without a hearing and a reasoned order, and each settled claimant must receive a chart of all payments made.
- The State bears no interest for now, but must pay 9% simple interest if payment is not released within the time fixed.
The writ petitions and the civil appeals in Groups I and II were allowed, the High Court orders challenged by the employees were set aside, and the civil appeals in Group III were dismissed.
The contempt petitions
On the contempt petitions alleging non-compliance with Prem Singh, the Bench found that the office reports did not establish wilful disobedience by each alleged contemnor. It gave the State “one further and final opportunity” to pay the amounts due, with admissible arrears, within six months, failing which 9% simple interest will run. Disposing of the contempt petitions, it warned:
“Any failure on the part of the State to comply with the payment directions in Prem Singh (supra) within the aforesaid period shall be viewed extremely seriously and may constitute aggravated contempt.”
What the judgment means for retirees
The ruling restates a settled limit on legislative power: a legislature may remove the legal basis on which a judgment rests, but it cannot simply re-enact, in new words, the very classification a court has struck down. Validating laws that merely relabel an exclusion, without curing the defect, will not survive judicial review.
For thousands of long-serving Uttar Pradesh employees who began as work-charged, daily-wage or muster-roll staff, the judgment ends a dispute running for decades. Because the directions operate in rem and carry a six-month deadline backed by interest, retirees and the heirs of deceased employees can now press their pension claims directly before the competent authority.
Case Title: Uttar Pradesh Ground Water Department Non Gazetted Employee Association (Regd.) & Anr. v. The Chief Secretary & Ors. [Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1458 of 2020, with connected matters]
Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, Supreme Court of India
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026
