Karnataka High Court Refuses To Stay Centre’s Ban On Sugar-Based Ethanol Amid Sugar Shortage

5 min read

A distillery and a jaggery unit asked the Karnataka High Court to let them keep running while they challenge the Centre’s ban on sugar-based ethanol. The Court refused to stay the ban, holding that their commercial interests cannot prevail over orders issued to deal with a shortage of sugar in the 2026-27 season.

Karnataka High Court building in Bengaluru, which refused to stay the Centre's ban on sugar-based ethanol amid a sugar shortage

Bengaluru: Declining interim relief, the Karnataka High Court has held that the commercial activity of an ethanol distillery and a jaggery manufacturer cannot prevail over the Central government’s October 22, 2026 orders, which bar the production of ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for the Ethanol Supply Year 2026-27 [M/s Askins Biofuels Private Limited & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.].

Justice C.M. Poonacha passed the oral order on November 17, 2026 in Writ Petition No. 33398 of 2026, rejecting the petitioners’ prayer to be allowed to run their units until the writ petition is decided.

Why the Court would not interfere

The Court noted that the Sugar (Control) Order, 2025, published on May 1, 2025, empowers the Centre to regulate the diversion of sugar for producing ethanol from sugar-based feedstock. Since the October 22 orders only bar ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses, and not from C-heavy molasses, it held that it could not be said that the authorities lacked power to issue them.

The two Division Bench orders on which the petitioners relied, dated March 31, 2023 and November 21, 2025, in the Court’s reading, dealt with State closure orders under the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1966, and did not decide the Centre’s power under the Sugar (Control) Order. The coordinate Bench ruling in Hermes Distilleries Pvt Ltd v. Union of India concerned the 2024-25 supply year, before the 2025 Order came into force. The Court also observed that the petitioners’ status as a standalone distillery was a contested position. It then held:

“In view of the contention on behalf of the respondents that the impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 have been passed having regard to the current situation whereunder there is a shortage of sugar, keeping in mind the estimates of the cane production for the year 2026-2027, the question of interdicting the impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 in any manner does not arise. The commercial activity of the petitioners cannot prevail over the impugned orders which have been issued due to the prevailing situation as noticed above.”

What the petitioners wanted

The petitioners are M/s Askins Biofuels Private Limited, set up as a standalone distillery for producing ethanol, and M/s Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, a jaggery maker that proposed to supply sugarcane juice and syrup to Askins under an MoU. They challenged the communications dated October 22, 2026 under which sugar mills and distilleries were not allowed to produce ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for the supply year running from November 1, 2026 to October 31, 2027.

Their case rested on the two Division Bench orders, which held that Askins, as a standalone distillery, falls outside the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1966. They argued that they source cane only from the 5% of the cane-allotted area left to farmers’ discretion, so the 95% allotted to sugar factories would be untouched, and that the ban would bring their units to a standstill and cause irreparable loss to them and their workers, calling it “practically a death knell”.

The Centre’s answer

Additional Solicitor General K. Aravind Kamath, for the Union, argued that the Sugar (Control) Order and the Sugarcane (Control) Order are made under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955, and that the ban was necessary because of a scarcity of sugar. He told the Court that the orders do not prohibit ethanol made from C-heavy molasses, and that they were part of a set of interim measures, including stock limits on dealers, curbs on bulk consumers and duty-free import of raw sugar, to be revisited once further cane estimates for 2026-27 are available.

An adjacent sugar factory, M/s Alagawadi Bireshwar Sugars Private Limited, sought to be impleaded, pointing out that it has challenged the Division Bench orders before the Supreme Court and disputing Askins’ claim to be a standalone distillery.

Liberty to seek relaxation

Rejecting the interim prayer, the Court gave the petitioners liberty to make a representation to the authorities for any permission or relaxation permissible in law, and gave both sides liberty to seek modification of the order on subsequent changes. It directed the petitioners to file objections to the impleading application and the respondents to file their statement of objections within three weeks, and listed the matter on January 7, 2027.

Why the order matters

The order signals that, at the interim stage, courts are likely to defer to the Centre’s supply-management decisions under the Essential Commodities Act when the government points to a shortage of an essential commodity like sugar. Distilleries that depend on cane juice or B-heavy molasses will have to work through representations for relaxation, or switch to C-heavy molasses, while the validity of the ban is decided. The Court has not ruled on the merits of the challenge.

Case Title: M/s Askins Biofuels Private Limited & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. (WP No. 33398 of 2026 (GM-RES))
Bench: Justice C.M. Poonacha, Karnataka High Court at Bengaluru
Date of Order: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Anirudha Ramchandra Nayak for the petitioners; Additional Solicitor General K. Aravind Kamath for the Union of India

Similar Posts