Supreme Court Stays Madras HC Findings On Thiruparankundram Deepathoon, Allows One-Time Karthigai Lamp Lighting

6 min read

The Karthigai Deepam may be lit at the Thiruparankundram Deepathoon on November 24, the Supreme Court has said, but only by a restricted temple team and as a one-time measure that creates no custom or right for the future; the Court has also stayed the Madras High Court’s findings on the stone pillar.

Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi of the Supreme Court, whose Bench passed interim directions in the Thiruparankundram Deepathoon case.

New Delhi: Staying the findings recorded by the Madras High Court on the nature of the disputed stone pillar atop Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai, the Supreme Court on November 20, 2026 nonetheless permitted the ceremonial Karthigai Deepam to be lit at the Deepathoon on November 24 this year as a one-time, tightly controlled arrangement [The Commissioner v. Rama Ravikumar & connected cases].

The interim order was pronounced by a Bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi on the appeals filed by the State of Tamil Nadu and others against the Division Bench judgment of January 6, 2026, which had upheld the December 2025 single-judge direction of Justice G.R. Swaminathan to light the lamp at the pillar. The matter will be heard further in January 2027.

What stays suspended

The findings in paragraphs 1 to 140 of the Division Bench judgment dated January 6, 2026, so far as they are under challenge, will remain stayed until further orders, the Bench directed. These include the High Court’s conclusions on the character of the pillar and the land on which it stands.

A one-time arrangement, nothing more

The Court said the case raised important questions, including the reach of religious rights under Articles 25 and 26 of the Constitution, but it would not go into them at this stage. It made clear that its interim arrangement was not an endorsement of the High Court’s reasoning:

“The present arrangement does not proceed on any finding that the stone pillar is or has historically been a place of customary religious observance, nor does it determine whether the lighting of the lamp at the said location constitutes an essential religious practice or whether any individual, institution or denomination possess any enforceable right in that regard.”

Two judicial forums, the single judge and the Division Bench, had allowed the ceremony at the disputed spot, and the Bench treated that as a significant consideration for interim relief. What weighed with it, the Court said, was the peculiar nature of the occasion and the closeness of the festival.

“The opportunity to perform the festival on the said date (November 24), if denied, cannot be restored by a subsequent adjudication. Equally, we are conscious of the fact that the performance of the ceremony, once performed, cannot be undone.”

The interim arrangement therefore had to be narrowly confined, the Court said, and a limited one-time permission with stringent safeguards would balance the competing interests. No party can rely on the permission or the ceremony as evidence of an established custom, or as a basis to claim a similar ceremony in later years.

Conditions for November 24

  • The lamp will be lit on November 24 at the stone pillar identified as the Deepathoon by a restricted team organised by the Devasthanam.
  • The Madurai District Collector, acting as nodal officer, will settle the size and composition of the team in consultation with the temple Executive Officer, the Archaeological Survey of India and the Madurai Commissioner of Police.
  • Only the authorised team and officials needed for supervision and security may go to the site. Members of the public cannot accompany them, and processions, congregations, demonstrations and slogan-raising are barred.
  • The district administration will fix the timing, route and duration, and the team must leave immediately after the ceremony.
  • No structure, structural alteration, excavation or permanent construction is permitted at the site.
  • Worship at customary sites and lawful access to and enjoyment of the Dargah and the mosque must continue undisturbed.
  • Adequate security must be arranged, with central forces deployed if required, and the Collector must file a compliance report within three days after the festival.

Where the dispute began

It started when the temple Executive Officer rejected Ravikumar’s request to light the Karthigai Deepam at the pillar, which stands about 50 metres from the Dargah. On December 1, 2025, Justice Swaminathan held the pillar to be a Deepathoon and directed the temple to light the lamp there in addition to the customary site. The lamp was not lit at the pillar that year after police cited a prohibitory order.

On January 6, 2026, a Division Bench upheld the direction, held that the pillar stood on temple land and rejected the State’s case that it was a British-era survey stone. The Supreme Court issued notice on the State’s appeal on August 3 but had not stayed the judgment until now.

Submissions before the Bench

Seeking a stay of the High Court judgment were Senior Advocates Jaideep Gupta for the State, Gopal Sankaranarayanan for the Madurai District Collector and Shekhar Naphade for the HR&CE Commissioner, with Additional Advocate General Prashanto Chandra Sen. They argued that there was no custom of lighting the lamp at the pillar and that, under the Agamas, the lamp is traditionally lit near the Uchi Pillaiyar temple. The Collector relied on historical survey records to contend that the pillar was a survey marker.

Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi for the Sikandar Badusha Dargah contended that the single judge had inspected the site without notice to the Dargah and that a new custom could only be established through a civil suit, not a writ petition. Senior Advocate Amit Tiwari, for the Dargah, relied on a 1923 decree to argue that the Dargah owns the entire hillock. Senior Advocate Narender Hooda, for a priest supporting the State, pointed to the hill’s mixed religious heritage and earlier refusals of similar requests.

For the writ petitioners led by devotee Rama Ravikumar, Senior Advocate Guru Krishnakumar relied on photographs annexed to the High Court judgment to argue that the hill has two peaks and the Deepathoon is not on the peak where the Dargah and mosque stand. He described the argument on ownership of the whole hillock as a “red herring”, and the petitioners maintained that the High Court had only allowed an existing festival practice at an additional spot with access limited to the temple team.

Why the order matters

The order shows the Court separating interim relief from final rights. It suspends the High Court’s findings on custom and land, which were the core of the dispute, while allowing a ceremony that would otherwise be lost for the year. By expressly declaring that the ceremony proves nothing and confers nothing, the Bench has kept every party’s case open for the final hearing.

The safeguards, from a small official team and a ban on gatherings to protection of access to the Dargah and the mosque, reflect the sensitivity of a shared religious site. The larger questions on Articles 25 and 26, on proof of custom and on whether such claims belong in a writ court or a civil suit, remain to be decided when the matter is heard in January 2027.

Case Title: The Commissioner v. Rama Ravikumar & connected cases [SLP(C) Nos. 27891-27910 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi, Supreme Court of India
Date of Order: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocates Jaideep Gupta, Gopal Sankaranarayanan and Shekhar Naphade, and AAG Prashanto Chandra Sen for the State parties; Senior Advocates Huzefa Ahmadi and Amit Tiwari for the Dargah; Senior Advocate Narender Hooda for a priest; Senior Advocate Guru Krishnakumar for the writ petitioners

Similar Posts