Kerala High Court Disposes Of PILs On Waqf Board Composition, Says Reconstitution Creates Fresh Cause

4 min read

Can PILs over Waqf Board Composition go on once the Board itself has been reconstituted? The Kerala High Court has closed them, saying the reconstitution in October may give rise to a fresh cause of action to be raised in separate proceedings.

Kerala High Court building, where Chief Justice Soumen Sen's Bench disposed of PILs on the Kerala State Waqf Board's composition

Kochi: Noting that the State has since reconstituted the Kerala State Waqf Board, the Kerala High Court on Thursday disposed of a batch of public interest litigations challenging the Board’s constitution, and said any grievance about the new Board may be raised in separate proceedings [Shone George v. State of Kerala & Ors.].

The order of November 19, 2026 was passed by a Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M.

Reconstitution, a separate matter

An urgent petition brought the matter back to the Bench after a single judge, by order dated October 17, 2026, adjourned two writ petitions against the reconstitution (W.P.(C) Nos. 36037 and 36041 of 2026) for hearing by the Division Bench, relying on the Bench’s earlier observations. The Bench held:

“This Bench in the PILs is not seized with the said issue as the reconstitution of the Waqf Board has taken place during the pendency of the PILs. The reconstitution of the Waqf Board may give rise to a fresh cause of action.”

The single judge’s order is under challenge in W.A. No. 2191 of 2026, so the Bench only clarified that “the issue of reconstitution was never the subject matter of PILs and hence there may not be any requirement to refer the writ petitions” to it.

What the PILs sought

The PILs challenged the non-inclusion of non-Muslim members on the Board, which the petitioners said is mandated by the Waqf Act as amended in 2025. BJP leader Shone George sought a direction to the State to nominate two non-Muslim members immediately and a declaration that the Board was functioning in violation of Section 14(1) of the amended Act.

Another PIL, filed by the Christian charitable organisation Assembly of Christian Trust Services (ACTS), also questioned the non-inclusion of Shia, Bohra and Aghakhani communities and challenged the Board’s upload of details of the disputed Munambam land on the Centre’s UMEED portal. A third PIL raised similar grounds and questioned the inclusion of CPI(M) leader and former MLA Kunhammed Kutty Master on the Board.

Unfilled non-Muslim seats

Senior Advocate Santhosh Mathew, for Shone George, argued that the PIL survived because the posts earmarked for non-Muslims remained unfilled even after the reconstitution. The Bench did not accept that the PIL should continue:

“In view of the fact that the Board has since been reconstituted, any grievance in that regard may be agitated in separate proceedings.”

The PILs were disposed of, Review Petition No. 1238 of 2026 was closed, and the two writ petitions were detagged from the batch. The Court did not rule on whether the reconstituted Board meets the requirements of the amended Act.

Why the order matters

The inclusion of non-Muslim members on State Waqf Boards under the 2025 amendment has been contested in several courts, with petitioners pressing for strict compliance and State Boards defending their composition. This order draws a line between the old constitution of the Kerala Board, which the PILs targeted, and the reconstituted Board, whose validity must now be tested afresh.

Challenges to the reconstitution will proceed before the single judge as per roster, subject to the pending writ appeal, and the petitioners remain free to file fresh proceedings on the unfilled non-Muslim seats.

Case Title: Shone George v. State of Kerala & Ors. and connected cases [WP(PIL) No. 117 of 2026 & Con. Cases]
Neutral Citation: 2026:KER:88730
Bench: Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M., Kerala High Court
Date of Order: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocates Santhosh Mathew, S Sanal Kumar and P.B. Krishnan with Advocates Shinto Mathew Abraham, K.B. Rahim and others for the petitioners; Special Government Pleader P.M. Saneer, K Jaju Babu, ASGI P Sreekumar, Senior Advocate T Krishnanunni and Advocates Jamsheed Hafiz and Harikrishnan P.B. for the respondents

Similar Posts