MP High Court Says Husband Holding Restitution Decree Cannot Seek Divorce On Desertion Within A Year

5 min read

A husband who obtained a restitution decree and then sought divorce on desertion within a year of it “attempted to sail in two boats at the same time”, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has held, ruling that such a move undercuts his own claim that he wants his wife back.

Madhya Pradesh High Court building at Jabalpur, where a Division Bench ruled on a restitution decree and divorce appeal.

Jabalpur: The Madhya Pradesh High Court has dismissed a husband’s first appeal against a Family Court order refusing him divorce, holding that a spouse who obtains a decree for restitution of conjugal rights and then files for divorce within a year of that decree “attempted to sail in two boats at the same time”, and that he had failed to prove cruelty, desertion or adultery [Lomesh Kumar Bahetwar v. Smt. Sarita Bahetwar].

A Division Bench of Justice Anand Pathak and Justice Ramkumar Choubey, sitting at Jabalpur, delivered the judgment on October 29, 2026. Justice Ramkumar Choubey wrote the judgment, which affirmed the decree dated July 26, 2024 passed by the Second Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Jabalpur, in RCS HM No. 1060/2023.

The one-year window

Relying on Tulsa Bai v. Rajendra Singh, the Bench said that a spouse who obtains a restitution decree shows an intention to resume cohabitation, and that filing for divorce within a year of that decree by itself negates that intention. The decree-holder, it clarified, need not first seek execution of the restitution decree, since compliance rests with the other spouse. The one-year statutory period, however, still had to run.

At the appellate stage, the husband also sought to bring the restitution decree on record under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court refused, noting that the document was within his knowledge from the start and that he never sought to amend his petition. It reiterated that no evidence can be looked into without relevant pleadings.

“The fact that the statutory period may have elapsed during the pendency of the proceedings cannot cure the absence of the requisite pleadings or substitute an adjudication on a ground which was never put in issue. Consequently, the appellant cannot claim a decree of divorce on the said ground in the present proceedings.”

How the marriage reached court

The couple married on December 7, 2009 at Kohka in Gondia district of Maharashtra and had two children. Their son died in May 2021 after an illness. According to the husband, the wife went to her parental home with their daughter in June 2021 and refused to return.

He obtained an ex parte decree for restitution of conjugal rights on July 1, 2023. On September 12, 2023, he filed a divorce petition under Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging cruelty, desertion and adultery. The petition did not plead the restitution decree, or any failure to comply with it, as a ground for divorce. The Family Court dismissed the petition, and the husband appealed under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act read with Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984.

Cruelty, desertion and adultery not proved

On adultery, the Court found neither a pleading nor “even an iota of evidence”. On cruelty, it noted that the husband’s testimony did not state specific facts and that what he described appeared to be the “ordinary wear and tear of married life”.

Desertion needed more than living apart, the Bench stressed. The petitioner must prove that the other spouse left without reasonable cause and intended to end cohabitation permanently, since desertion is “a withdrawal not from a place, but from a state of things”. The couple had lived together for years, and the wife left while in considerable mental anguish after the death of their son. The husband’s letter, his application to a counselling centre and his police complaint were never produced before the Family Court.

The wife did not contest the case in either court, but the Bench held that this did not help the husband. Section 23(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act requires the court to be satisfied that a ground for divorce exists “whether defended or not”, and her silence, it said, is not by itself proof of the appellant’s case.

The outcome and the liberty granted

The Court held that the husband failed to establish any ground for divorce and found no reason to interfere with the Family Court’s decree. It made clear, however, that the separate ground of non-compliance with the restitution decree had never been examined on merits.

“The appellant would, however, be at liberty to avail such remedy as may be available to him under Section 13(1A)(ii) of the HMA, in accordance with law, upon fulfillment of the statutory requirements.”

The appeal was dismissed and the impugned judgment and decree were affirmed, with the liberty remaining subject to the Court’s observations.

Why the judgment matters

The ruling draws a firm line between two matrimonial remedies that pull in opposite directions. A restitution decree asks the court to restore the marriage, while a divorce petition seeks to end it. A spouse who wins the first cannot, within the one-year window that Section 13(1A)(ii) builds in, turn around and claim desertion, because that conduct contradicts the very intention the restitution decree rests on.

It also reinforces two procedural basics in family litigation. A ground that is not pleaded cannot be decided, and the lapse of time during an appeal does not cure that gap. And an uncontested divorce petition is not an automatic win, since Section 23(1) obliges the court to be satisfied on evidence that a ground exists even when the other spouse stays away.

Case Title: Lomesh Kumar Bahetwar v. Smt. Sarita Bahetwar [First Appeal No. 1654 of 2024]
Bench: Justice Anand Pathak and Justice Ramkumar Choubey, Madhya Pradesh High Court at Jabalpur
Date of Judgment: October 29, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Atul Shukla for the appellant; none for the respondent, though served

Similar Posts