The Karnataka High Court remarked that the State admits the Pratap Simha FIR was sent to a court without jurisdiction and that the order deleting the defamation charge came from a Sessions Court also lacking jurisdiction, as the prosecution argued the lapse is a mere irregularity and no ground to quash.

Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court on Monday heard BJP leader and former MP Pratap Simha’s petitions to quash two FIRs registered over his alleged speech during a Ganesha Visarjan procession at T. Narasipura, with the State submitting that sending an FIR to a court lacking jurisdiction is only a procedural irregularity and does not by itself warrant quashing of the criminal proceedings. [Prathap Simha v. State of Karnataka & Anr.]
A single-judge Bench of Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde is hearing the petitions, CRL.P No. 14747/2026 and CRL.P No. 14769/2026. The allegations against Simha are untested, he is presumed innocent, and the Court has expressed no view on the merits.
Background
The FIRs relate to remarks Simha allegedly made during the Ganesha Visarjan procession at T. Narasipura on 18 September. A suo motu FIR was registered on 20 September under Sections 132, 191, 194, 196 and 353 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). A second FIR was registered on 22 September on a complaint by the President of a local association, who alleged that Simha ridiculed Dalit activists by referring to a “blue shawl” in his speech. That FIR invokes Sections 352 and 356 BNS and Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(u) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.
The petitions challenge the legality of both FIRs and allege that they were registered due to political pressure. Simha maintains that his remarks were directed at the alleged conduct of a police officer and not against any religion or community. On 24 September, the High Court had refused to grant him interim relief.
Simha’s submissions on jurisdiction
Appearing for Simha, Advocate Venkatesh Dalwai submitted that the FIR invoking Section 356 BNS, which deals with defamation, was sent to the Mysuru Sessions Court even though, as a former MP, Simha’s case could only be dealt with by the designated Special Court for MPs and MLAs. He argued that the Sessions Court therefore lacked jurisdiction to delete Section 356 from the FIR.
“It’s not a special court, I am a former Member of Parliament. After 2018, the Karnataka Government constituted special courts… As of today, 356 has been conveniently deleted so that FIR could be sustained.”
Advocate Dalwai also relied on Section 222 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which corresponds to Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, to argue that cognizance of defamation can be taken only on a complaint by the aggrieved person.
“Once you invoke 356 BNS, the bar under 222 BNSS applies… If there is a legal bar, the entire registration of FIR becomes illegal.”
State’s response
The State Public Prosecutor opposed the petitions, arguing that even if the FIR was sent to the wrong court, the error would not vitiate the proceedings. Sending the FIR to the wrong court, he submitted, was at best an irregularity and not an illegality warranting quashing.
“If we accept the argument that the FIR is sent to the wrong court, can it be quashed? The answer is no, milord.”
The State Public Prosecutor added: “Wrongly I have incorporated 356 in the FIR. Rightly I have sent a requisition. But does the wrong court vitiate the entire proceedings?”
ALSO READ: Bengaluru Court Dismisses Defamation Case Against CM Siddaramaiah Over RSS, Bajrang Dal Remarks
Court’s remark
Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde put it to the State that it had conceded two jurisdictional lapses and was relying on the BNSS provisions on irregularities that do not vitiate proceedings to save them.
“Two things you admit: the FIR was sent to a court with no jurisdiction, and the order was passed by a Sessions Court also without jurisdiction. But you are saving this by Section 506 BNSS & Section 508 BNSS…”
Sections 506 and 508 of the BNSS deal with procedural irregularities, including proceedings in a wrong place, that do not by themselves vitiate criminal proceedings. The petitions remain pending before the High Court, which has made no finding on the allegations against Simha.
Case Title: Prathap Simha v. State of Karnataka & Anr. | CRL.P No. 14747/2026 and CRL.P No. 14769/2026 | Hearing: 5 October 2026 | Bench: Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde
Appearances: For the Petitioner: Advocate Venkatesh Dalwai. For the State: State Public Prosecutor.
