Karnataka High Court Refuses To Quash Hate Speech Case Against Ex-MP Pratap Simha, Relieves Organisers

4 min read

Whether Pratap Simha intended to cause rioting “has to be considered at the time of investigation”, the Karnataka High Court has said, refusing to quash the hate speech case against the former BJP MP over a 2024 speech at Shahapur while quashing the FIR against three event organisers.

Karnataka High Court building, which refused to quash the hate speech FIR against former BJP MP Pratap Simha over a 2024 speech

Kalaburagi: The Karnataka High Court has declined to quash an FIR registered by the Shahapur police against former Member of Parliament and BJP leader Pratap Simha under Sections 192 and 299 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) over a speech he delivered in Yadgir district in September 2024, directing that the investigation continue against him [Pratap Simha & Ors. v. State of Karnataka].

Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde, sitting at the Kalaburagi Bench, passed the order on October 8, 2026, partly allowing the petition filed under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).

Why the probe against Simha goes on

Noting that no rioting had taken place, the Court held that the first part of Section 192 BNS did not apply, but said the second part can be attracted even without a riot. It observed:

“From the contents of the complaint and from the contents of the speech more particularly, the Court is of the view that the matter requires investigation as against petitioner no.1. Whether the petitioner No.1 had intention to cause rioting has to be considered at the time of investigation.”

It added that the basic ingredients of the offence under Section 299 BNS appear in the complaint and call for investigation.

The three organisers go free

As for petitioners No. 2 to 4, Karan, Shivakumar and Gururaj, the Court found nothing in the complaint to show that they instigated the speech; the only allegation was that they organised the event and invited Simha as chief guest. The proceedings in Crime No. 212/2024 were quashed against them, while the investigation will continue against Simha.

What the complaint says

According to the complaint lodged on September 23, 2024, Simha was the chief guest at a function at Shahapur on September 21, 2024, the day of the Ganesha idol immersion, organised by the other petitioners, who had obtained permission for the event. The complaint alleges that his speech was aimed at disturbing communal peace. The police registered Crime No. 212/2024 under Section 192 BNS (wantonly giving provocation with intent to cause riot) and Section 299 BNS (deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings).

As quoted in the complaint, the speech, delivered in Kannada, questioned stone-pelting at Hindu religious processions and referred to what might happen if Hindus, said to form 80 per cent of the population, also took to such acts, with references to petrol bombs and a call for Hindu unity. These are allegations in the complaint, which the investigation will test. The petitioners’ counsel did not dispute the contents of the speech before the High Court.

Arguments on both sides

The petitioners argued that the event had valid permission, that the speech did not attract either offence, and that since the offences carry less than seven years’ imprisonment, the police should have obtained the permission of an officer not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police under Section 173(3) BNSS before registering the FIR. They added that the organisers made no speech and that the FIR was an abuse of process.

The State, represented by the Additional State Public Prosecutor, contended that permission to hold an event was no licence for such a speech, that it was made with malicious intent to outrage the religious feelings of a community, and that it was given knowing that the provocation was likely to cause rioting.

Section 173(3) BNSS not a bar

The Court held that Section 173(3) BNSS does not mandate prior permission of a Deputy Superintendent of Police for every offence punishable with three to seven years; that procedure applies where a preliminary enquiry is needed before registration. As the investigating officer had a video recording of the speech, registering the FIR did not violate the provision. The copy of the speech, it said, would have to be supplied if a charge sheet is filed.

The Court made clear that its observations were confined to the petition under Section 528 BNSS and were not on the merits of either side’s case, keeping all contentions open. The allegations remain untested, Simha is presumed innocent, and LawChakra expresses no view on the merits.

Why the order matters

The ruling separates the speaker from the organisers of a permitted public event: hosting a speaker is not, by itself, instigation of what the speaker says. It also clarifies that the second limb of Section 192 BNS can be investigated even where no riot follows.

On procedure, the Court’s reading of Section 173(3) BNSS, that a Deputy Superintendent’s permission is needed only where the police choose a preliminary enquiry, will matter in many speech-related FIRs where accused persons seek quashing on that ground.

Case Title: Pratap Simha & Ors. v. State of Karnataka [Criminal Petition of 2025, Kalaburagi Bench, arising from Crime No. 212/2024, Shahapur Police Station]
Bench: Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde, High Court of Karnataka, Kalaburagi Bench
Date of Order: October 8, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Chaitanyakumar Chandriki for the petitioners; Additional SPP M V Anoop Kumar for the State

Similar Posts