Bombay High Court Directs Bosch To Pay ₹25 Lakh Each To Nashik Workers Over Unlawful Transfers

5 min read

Bosch workers compensation of Rs 25 lakh each has been ordered by the Bombay High Court, which held that the transfer of over 500 temporary workmen from the company’s Nashik plant to far-off places across India was a device to get rid of them.

Bombay High Court building, where Bosch was ordered to pay Rs 25 lakh each to transferred Nashik temporary workers.

Mumbai: Transfers of its New Entrant Temporary Workmen (NETWs) were unlawful, the Bombay High Court held on November 19, 2026, but instead of directing Bosch Ltd. to take them back at the Nashik plant, it partly allowed the company’s writ petition against an Industrial Court ruling and fixed a lumpsum compensation of Rs 25 lakh per worker [Bosch Ltd. & Ors. v. NETW Kamgar Sangathana & Anr.].

Justice Sandeep V. Marne delivered the judgment in Writ Petition No. 13945 of 2026, which had been reserved on October 30, 2026.

What the Court ordered

The Industrial Court’s directions at Serial Nos. 1 to 4 were upheld, while the direction at Serial No. 5 allowing the transferred workmen to join at the Nashik plant was set aside. Bosch must pay Rs 25 lakh to each NETW covered by Complaint (ULP) No. 46 of 2024 within six weeks, failing which the amount will carry interest at 8 percent a year from the end of that period. Beyond this sum, the workers will not be entitled to claim any other financial or service benefits from the company. There was no order as to costs.

After the judgment was pronounced, the union sought a four-week stay. Bosch opposed it, and the Court refused, noting that the company had been directed to pay compensation to the workers.

A tool devised to remove workers

The High Court agreed with the Industrial Court’s finding of unfair labour practice. The transfers, it held, were not driven by any genuine business need but were meant to remove surplus workers without following the statutory procedure for retrenchment. The Court said:

“The real intention is to get rid of the workers and the tool of transfer is devised at achieving that objective.”

It also had pointed words for the company’s conduct:

“The Petitioner No.1 is a large organisation and is expected to act as a model employer and not to indulge into unlawful methods such as initial implementation of Red-Light Activation concept and later by resorting to throwing out over 500 NETWs at far off places across the country to ensure that they are ultimately dismissed on account of non-joining at the transferred places.”

From Red-Light Activation to transfer orders

Bosch, its Managing Director and its Senior General Manager (HR) Shrikant Dyaneshwar Chavan had challenged the Industrial Court, Nashik’s judgment of September 29, 2026 in Complaint (ULP) No. 46 of 2024. That court had allowed the union’s complaint and set aside transfer orders dated September 7, 2024, by which members of the respondent union were transferred to various places across the country.

The company’s case was that stricter emission norms and the decision of major customers to stop making diesel passenger cars had sharply cut demand for the diesel injectors made at Nashik. It first introduced a “Red-Light Activation” system, under which workers were not allowed to report for duty when there was not enough work. The workers challenged that system and secured orders for wages even on days when no work was assigned, orders which were upheld up to the Supreme Court.

Bosch then recalled the workers in August 2024 and, within weeks, transferred them to different locations across India. Disciplinary proceedings followed against those who did not join at the new places, and according to the union, 235 workers were eventually dismissed.

Why money and not a return to the plant

Manufacturing at Nashik had come down, the Court accepted, and ordering the workers back to the plant could prolong the dispute. It noted that Bosch, with an admitted turnover of Rs 7,700 crore in 2024-25, would otherwise have to pay wages from September 7, 2024 and, if the workers were lawfully retrenched, retrenchment compensation and statutory dues. It also took into account amounts already paid under interim orders on the Red-Light Activation system: Rs 3.5 lakh to 128 NETWs and Rs 8.5 lakh to 470 NETWs. Bosch had offered Rs 14 lakh per worker and later indicated it could pay Rs 18 lakh.

“Considering these circumstances, in my view, it would be appropriate to determine the amount of lumpsum compensation at Rs. 25,00,000/- to each of the NETWs involved in Complaint (ULP) No.46 of 2024. This would balance the equities between the parties.”

The payment, the Court added, would relieve Bosch of back wages since September 2024 and of employing the workmen at Nashik, while giving “some solace” to workers who have not been in continuous service for five years since the Red-Light Activation began in 2021.

Why the judgment matters

The ruling makes clear that an employer cannot use transfers to do indirectly what the retrenchment procedure requires to be done openly. At the same time, it shows the Court’s willingness to close a long industrial dispute through a fixed lumpsum where reinstatement is no longer practical, which may guide similar disputes where plants scale down operations.

Case Title: Bosch Ltd. & Ors. v. NETW Kamgar Sangathana & Anr. [Writ Petition No. 13945 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Sandeep V. Marne
Date of Judgment: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocates C.U. Singh and Kiran S. Bapat with Advocates A.D. Patwardhan, C.A. Deolalkar and T.R. Yadav for the petitioners; Advocate T.K. Prabhakaran for Respondent No. 1

Similar Posts