Delhi High Court Says Aadhaar Alone Not Proof Of Date Of Birth, Upholds Worker’s Back Wages

3 min read

Aadhaar alone not proof of date of birth: the Delhi High Court has upheld a Labour Court award that found a factory worker illegally retrenched after her employer relied on her Aadhaar card to treat her as having reached retirement age.

Delhi High Court building, where Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri held that an Aadhaar card alone is not proof of date of birth.

New Delhi: An employer that had itself furnished a worker’s date of birth to the ESIC could not later rely on a different date in her Aadhaar card to end her service a year early, the Delhi High Court has held, dismissing the management’s writ petition against a Labour Court award [M/s J. J. Electronics v. Smt. Rosamma Joy].

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri pronounced the judgment on November 13, 2026 in W.P.(C) 16476/2022, filed against the award of Labour Court-IX, Rouse Avenue Courts Complex, in LID No. 78/2018.

Two dates of birth on record

The worker, Rosamma Joy, had an Aadhaar card showing her date of birth as May 20, 1959, but the management received it only in March 2017, about two months before ending her service. Against it stood the ESIC record. An ESIC official examined as a court witness deposed that she was registered with the ESIC on June 26, 2010 and that her date of birth, 20.05.1960, was furnished by the management itself. The management did not cross-examine him or produce the documents behind that entry, and the Labour Court drew an adverse inference. The High Court held:

“Having recorded her date of birth as 20.05.1960, the management could not later rely upon a different date in an Aadhaar card to end her services a year earlier.”

The Court cited a UIDAI circular of December 22, 2023 and earlier rulings to reiterate that Aadhaar is primarily proof of identity, not per se proof of date of birth, and that where age records conflict, courts must rely on the material with greater evidentiary value. It also noted that the Industrial Disputes Act is beneficial legislation.

How the dispute arose

Rosamma Joy’s case was that her services were terminated on May 20, 2017 after she demanded the increased minimum wages notified by the Delhi government and her wages for April 2017. The management said she had turned 58, its retirement age, on May 20, 2017, as shown in the Aadhaar card she submitted, and that she had in any case resigned and taken her dues after cataract surgery. The Labour Court held that she was illegally retrenched and awarded full back wages from May 20, 2017 to May 20, 2018 with consequential benefits.

Why Section 25F decided the termination

The High Court found the Labour Court’s view on age to be “a plausible view” that could not be called perverse, and declined to interfere under writ jurisdiction. On the termination, it held:

“Once the workwoman was held not to have attained the age of superannuation, and the management failed to prove her resignation or voluntary retirement, the termination of her services without compliance with Section 25F of the ID Act was rightly held to be illegal.”

The petition was dismissed. The amount deposited with the Registrar General under the order of November 30, 2022, with accrued interest, is to be released to the worker, and any balance paid directly by the management within four weeks.

What the ruling means for employers

Employers increasingly treat Aadhaar as the default record of age. The ruling makes clear that an Aadhaar entry cannot override an employer’s own earlier records, especially when produced shortly before a dispute, and that ending a worker’s service on that basis without following Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act is illegal retrenchment.

Case Title: M/s J. J. Electronics v. Smt. Rosamma Joy, W.P.(C) 16476/2022
Bench: Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri, High Court of Delhi
Reserved on: August 14, 2026; Date of Judgment: November 13, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Renu, Kamlesh Kumar Mishra, Piyush and Mansi for the petitioner-management; Advocates Aarlin Moncy and Sruti Mehrotra for the respondent-worker

Similar Posts