Criminal proceedings cannot be used as a “strong arm tactic” to recover money, the Supreme Court has observed while granting anticipatory bail in property deal litigation over a Rs 60 lakh advance. The Court prima facie found a commercial transaction turned into a criminal case, and said the Patna High Court went overboard in roping in tax departments.

New Delhi: Accused in a 2024 FIR at Buxar Nagar Police Station in Bihar over the alleged non-refund of an advance paid for a property purchase, Mukesh Kumar alias Mukesh Kumar Sarraf has been granted anticipatory bail by the Supreme Court, which on October 30, 2026 observed that criminal proceedings cannot be used as a “strong arm tactic” to recover money [Mukesh Kumar @ Mukesh Kumar Sarraf v. State of Bihar & Anr.].
A Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran set aside the Patna High Court’s May 7, 2026 order in CRLM No. 4486 of 2026, which had refused him anticipatory bail.
Tax departments and a bail plea
The Bench found that the High Court had, regretfully, “gone overboard”. Observing that the petitioner seemed to be involved in large-scale monetary transactions, the High Court had directed the Income Tax and Sales Tax departments to place details of the taxes assessed and paid by him before the district court. The Supreme Court noted that even the State did not support that direction:
“While considering bail applications, the High Court should either allow it or reject it and there is no point in making such order involving tax departments, who have a robust mechanism in place to find out evasion and curb it as also compensate the State by mulcting tax, interest and penalty.”
A court hearing a bail plea, the Bench said, is concerned mainly with the culpability of the accused and should not take an adversarial role against them unless an apparent and compelling circumstance calls for it.
What the FIR alleges
FIR No. 415 of 2024 was registered under Sections 406, 420, 467, 468 and 471 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. According to the complainant, he paid an advance of Rs 60 lakh to the petitioner and co-accused persons to buy a property, later found that the property was disputed, and demanded a refund.
The complaint alleges that the petitioner then issued five cheques of Rs 12 lakh each, all of which were dishonoured. The allegations remain to be tested in the investigation and at trial, and the accused is presumed innocent.
The petitioner told the Supreme Court that Section 138 of the NI Act could not be invoked in a police FIR, that the FIR was registered after an unexplained delay of more than three years, and that the dispute was essentially civil.
Money advanced, cheques returned
The respondents asked the Court to consider the petitioner’s criminal antecedents. The Bench, however, noted that the case was essentially about money advanced for a property purchase, secured by blank cheques returned for “insufficient funds”, and that it had not been told of any NI Act proceedings or civil suit for recovery. It held:
“In the present case, we prima facie find that a commercial transaction was attempted to be converted into criminal liability.”
The terms of protection
If he is arrested, the petitioner is to be released on bail on terms the Investigating Officer may impose, subject to his continued cooperation with the investigation. On release, he must appear before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Buxar, when directed by the Investigating Officer or summoned by the court, furnish bail bonds and ensure his presence during trial. The observations are prima facie and confined to the question of bail.
Why the order matters
The order adds to a line of Supreme Court rulings warning against using criminal law to pressure parties in money disputes. It also reminds bail courts to stay within their task rather than issue sweeping directions to tax authorities that have their own machinery.
Case Title: Mukesh Kumar @ Mukesh Kumar Sarraf v. State of Bihar & Anr. [SLP (Crl.) No. 16198/2026]
Bench: Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran
Date of Order: October 30, 2026
Appearances: AOR Navneet R. for the petitioner; AORs Azmat Hayat Amanullah and Yashasvi Virendra with Advocates Vanshita Gupta, Karl P. Rustomkhan and Gyanendra Kumar for the respondents
