Must a party attacking a scientific report first show exactly what is wrong with it? Yes, the Kerala High Court has ruled, setting aside a Munsiff Court order for a Second DNA Test that rested on nothing more than the absence of prejudice to the opposite party.

Kochi: Courts cannot order a fresh DNA examination as a matter of course just because the party against whom the first report went finds it unacceptable, the Kerala High Court has held. It set aside a Munsiff Court order that had sent the parties in a paternity suit for a second DNA test [Plaintiff v. Defendants (names withheld), OP(C) No. 624 of 2026].
On November 18, 2026, Justice Easwaran S. allowed the original petition filed by the plaintiff and dismissed the defendants’ application for a fresh test.
No prejudice is not the question
The Court found persuasive the view of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court that a party cannot keep seeking expert opinions until it gets a favourable one, and must first point out the defects in the earlier test. It then took up the argument that a fresh test would do the plaintiff no harm:
“The Court must not adopt an approach that could favour bastardy. The respondents may argue that the order should be upheld because remitting the matter to the DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics Centre, Hyderabad, would cause the plaintiff no prejudice. But that is not the question. The issue is whether the courts acted properly in ordering a second DNA test as a matter of course, merely because the person against whom the report was made found it unacceptable.”
“Court proceedings are governed by procedural law. A party challenging the accuracy of a scientific report must establish that it is materially flawed. Without proof of such defects, the court cannot order a fresh examination of the same subject.”
The pivotal question of precisely why the report was unacceptable or affected by infirmities was never answered by the defendants, the Court said. Having found their reasons insufficient to reject the report, the trial court should not have gone further and ordered fresh testing.
How the suit got here
The plaintiff filed OS No. 367 of 2013 before the Munsiff’s Court, Parappanangadi, seeking a declaration that he is not the biological father of defendants 2 and 3, who were born to the first defendant on June 11, 2012. He said the declaration was needed to protect his reputation, since the first defendant had alleged that he was their father, both in a criminal complaint registered against him in 2012 and in maintenance and divorce proceedings before the Family Court, Malappuram. The first defendant contested the suit. Those allegations are contested and the Court made no finding on them.
On the plaintiff’s application, and with the defendants’ agreement, the trial court referred the parties for DNA profiling at the Rajiv Gandhi Centre for Biotechnology, Thiruvananthapuram. Its report dated November 7, 2016 concluded that the plaintiff is not the biological father of defendants 2 and 3.
The defendants objected and filed IA No. 31 of 2017 seeking a fresh test at the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, Hyderabad. The Munsiff dismissed it on March 28, 2017. In O.P.(C) No. 2010 of 2017, the High Court on October 9, 2024 found that a second test was impermissible without an application to set aside the report, but on the defendants’ request sent the matter back for reconsideration. The expert who prepared the report was then examined.
On January 31, 2026, the trial court found that nothing on record showed the report was unacceptable or inadmissible. Even so, since paternity was the dispute in the suit, it allowed the application and directed a fresh test in Hyderabad. The plaintiff challenged that order.
The submissions
Counsel for the plaintiff, Soorya S. Shenoy, argued that the trial court gave no reasons for a second test after finding the first report correct and requiring no interference. The defendants, represented by Counsel O.V. Maniprasad, maintained that the paternity dispute justified a fresh examination.
The outcome
The January 31, 2026 order in IA No. 31 of 2017 was set aside and the application was dismissed. No costs were ordered.
Why the judgment matters
DNA reports carry great weight in paternity disputes, and a second test is often sought by whichever side the first one disappoints. The ruling makes clear that an unfavourable result is not a ground for a repeat test. A party must identify concrete and verifiable flaws in the original testing, whether in the sampling, the laboratory process or the expert’s evidence.
The judgment also rejects the idea that a fresh test can be justified because it costs the other side nothing. The test, the Court held, is whether the order is legally proper, not whether it is harmless. Trial courts will now have to give reasons grounded in the evidence before sending parties for another round of scientific examination.
Case Title: Plaintiff v. Defendants (names withheld) [OP(C) No. 624 of 2026; 2026:KER:88732]
Bench: Justice Easwaran S., High Court of Kerala
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026
Appearances: Advocates K.P. Sudheer, Sherry M.V., Bhavana J. Menon, Arundhati Nair, P. Anirudhan and Soorya S. Shenoy for the petitioner; Advocate O.V. Maniprasad for respondents 1 to 3
