“The welfare of the child, important as it is, cannot be treated as a substitute for the judicial inquiry required before directing DNA examination,” the Karnataka High Court has held, setting aside a Bengaluru Family Court order that had directed a DNA paternity test of a man and a minor boy in a maintenance case. […]
The Telangana High Court has set aside a trial court order permitting a potency test of an accused in a sexual offence case, holding that medical and scientific tests of an accused cannot be ordered routinely or merely because the allegation is grave, and must meet the tests of relevance, necessity and proportionality.
The Delhi High Court upheld a Family Court order directing a DNA test, ruling that a child’s right to know biological parentage outweighs an adult’s concern over reputation. The Court observed that truth cannot be suppressed merely because it causes personal discomfort.
The Rajasthan High Court dismissed a husband’s plea seeking narco-analysis, polygraph and DNA tests in a divorce dispute. Justice Sanjeet Purohit upheld the family court order, ruling that such tests were unnecessary, delayed, and could not be imposed without consent.
The Supreme Court dismissed a mother’s appeal against the Delhi High Court’s refusal of maintenance for her daughter, holding that scientific evidence prevails over legal presumptions. It ruled that “a man cannot be directed to pay maintenance if a DNA test disproves fatherhood.”
The Andhra Pradesh High Court ruled that a husband cannot demand DNA tests of his children to prove his wife’s alleged adultery. The Court stressed that children cannot be used as tools in marital disputes and their rights must be protected.
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that a DNA test may be ordered in divorce proceedings where the objective is to prove alleged adultery and not to question a child’s legitimacy. The Court emphasized sufficient pleadings of non-access and the need to balance privacy with justice.
A Delhi family court has ruled that a divorced woman proven to be living in adultery is not entitled to maintenance under Section 125(4) CrPC. The court relied on a DNA test and prior divorce judgment to dismiss her plea.
The Karnataka High Court ruled that DNA tests can’t be ordered on mere demand, stressing strict legal justification to protect privacy, dignity, legitimacy, and fundamental rights.
Bombay High Court rules that suspicion of a wife’s adultery is no ground for forcing a minor to undergo a DNA test, prioritizing the child’s rights and welfare in paternity disputes.
