In the Shiv Sena disqualification case, the Eknath Shinde faction told the Supreme Court that skipping a legislature party meeting cannot amount to voluntarily giving up party membership under the Tenth Schedule, arguing that “dissent is not defection”.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday, November 17, continued hearing the Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray faction’s challenge to the Maharashtra Assembly Speaker’s refusal to disqualify MLAs of the Eknath Shinde faction under the Tenth Schedule, with Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta arguing for Shinde that absence from a legislature party meeting is not a ground for disqualification [Shiv Sena (UBT) v. Speaker, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly & Ors.].
The matter is before a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana. A connected petition by Uddhav Thackeray challenging the Election Commission of India’s decision recognising the Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and allotting it the ‘bow and arrow’ symbol is also listed before the Bench.
“How have I given up membership?”
Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta submitted that the disqualification petitions filed by Shiv Sena (UBT) member Sunil Prabhu rest on the Shinde group’s absence from a legislature party meeting on June 21, 2022. Under paragraph 2(1)(a) of the Tenth Schedule, he argued, disqualification requires voluntarily giving up membership of the political party, and not attending a legislature party meeting does not meet that test.
“By not attending legislative party meeting, how have I given up membership of the political party?”
Mehta told the Court that the disqualification petitions themselves pleaded that the respondents had given up membership of the Shiv Sena legislature party and stayed away from meetings ahead of the Maharashtra Legislative Council elections, and that the notices were issued on the letterhead of the Shiv Sena legislature party office, signed by Prabhu.
Meeting call “not a whip”
According to Mehta, the call for the June 21 meeting was a WhatsApp message sent to Shinde’s personal assistant at 12:31 PM, a minute after the meeting had begun at 12:30. He submitted that it was merely a call for a meeting, not a whip, that the meeting had no agenda and passed no resolution, and that Prabhu had accepted in cross-examination that it was called because the Shinde group was not reachable, as an attempt at reconciliation.
Attendance register questioned
Mehta also attacked the UBT side’s reliance on an attendance register, calling it self-contradictory to argue that the Shinde group defied the party by staying away while also relying on signatures of the same members in the register. He alleged that the signatures were fabricated and that two signatures had been forged and inserted, noting that the Speaker had found the register unreliable.
“Our idea is, dissent is not defection as this is not the purport of the Tenth Schedule.”
The other side of the case
The Uddhav Thackeray faction contends that the Shinde group MLAs incurred disqualification under the Tenth Schedule and that the Speaker erred in refusing to disqualify them. The allegations of fabrication and forgery are submissions made on behalf of the Shinde faction and have not been tested or ruled upon. The Court has expressed no view on the merits, and arguments are to continue on November 18.
Why the hearing matters
The case turns on where the line falls between internal party dissent and defection under the anti-defection law. How the Supreme Court reads “voluntarily giving up membership” in paragraph 2(1)(a), and whether absence from a legislature party meeting can trigger it, will shape how Speakers across India decide disqualification petitions arising from party splits.
Case Title: Shiv Sena (UBT) v. Speaker, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly & Ors., with Uddhav Thackeray v. Eknath Shinde & Ors.
Bench: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, Supreme Court of India
Date of Hearing: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta for Eknath Shinde
