Supreme Court Hears Shinde Faction Argue Dissent Is Not Defection In Shiv Sena Disqualification Case

In the Shiv Sena disqualification case, the Eknath Shinde faction told the Supreme Court that skipping a legislature party meeting cannot amount to voluntarily giving up party membership under the Tenth Schedule, arguing that “dissent is not defection”. New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday, November 17, continued hearing the Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray faction’s challenge […]

Supreme Court Lists Sena (UBT) MPs’ Merger For Final Disposal, Lok Sabha Speaker Yet To Appear

Supreme Court Lists Sena (UBT) MPs’ Merger For Final Disposal, noting that the Lok Sabha Speaker has not entered appearance in the petition despite notice issued in July. New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday (October 27) directed that the Shiv Sena (UBT) petition challenging the Lok Sabha Speaker’s recognition of the merger of six […]

Supreme Court Shiv Sena Case: Symbol Not A Continuing Cause Of Action, Shinde Faction Argues

In the Shiv Sena case, Neeraj Kishan Kaul told the Supreme Court that the ECI was bound to give the bow-and-arrow symbol to the faction it found was the real party, and that a later disqualification cannot reopen that decision.

Supreme Court Shiv Sena Symbol Case: EC Had Only 2011 Party Constitution On Record, Kaul Argues

Senior Advocate N. K. Kaul told the Supreme Court that the Election Commission had only Shiv Sena’s 2011 constitution on record, and that it was never bound to wait for disqualification rulings before deciding the symbol dispute. The submissions are his; nothing has been decided.

Can A Defector’s Original Mandate Still Reflect Support For The Faction He Later Joined?: Justice Bagchi’s Question In Shiv Sena Case

As the Shiv Sena symbol hearing continued, Justice Joymalya Bagchi raised a question he said earlier decisions had not considered: whether an elected representative’s original electoral mandate can still be treated as support for a faction he later joins after a split. He pressed whether the Election Commission had considered all available options, including declining the historic symbol to both sides, and flagged that the answer would affect similar cases beyond this dispute.

No Cloud Of Disqualification Hangs Over Our MPs Today: Shinde Faction Defends Legislative-Majority Test In Shiv Sena Symbol Case

Resuming his submissions in the Shiv Sena symbol dispute, Senior Advocate Neeraj Kishan Kaul told the Supreme Court that the 40 MLAs backing the Shinde faction accounted for 76% of the vote secured by Shiv Sena’s winning candidates, that all disqualification proceedings against the faction stand dismissed with no stay, and that the pending petitions therefore have no bearing on the symbol question. He argued against making the two interim symbols a permanent arrangement.

Could The ECI Have Denied The Symbol To Both Uddhav & Shinde Factions?: Supreme Court Asks In Shiv Sena Hearing

As the Shiv Sena split hearing continued, Justice Joymalya Bagchi asked whether the Election Commission, finding all three tests problematic, could have denied the reserved symbol to both factions and let each establish its strength independently without drawing on Balasaheb Thackeray’s legacy. Senior Advocate Neeraj Kishan Kaul, for the Shinde faction, defended the Commission’s reliance on organisational structure. The matter is part-heard.

The Split Was In The Party, Not Just Among Legislators: Shinde Faction Tells Supreme Court As Shiv Sena Hearing Resumes

A Bench led by CJI Surya Kant resumed hearing the Shiv Sena split case, in which the Uddhav Thackeray faction challenges the Maharashtra Speaker’s refusal to disqualify Eknath Shinde faction MLAs and the Election Commission’s recognition of the Shinde group as the Shiv Sena. Senior Advocate Neeraj Kishan Kaul argued that the split was in the political party itself. The hearing continues.

A Party Constitution On Paper Cannot Stop The EC From Examining How The Organisation Actually Works: Neeraj Kishan Kaul In Shiv Sena Case

Defending the Election Commission’s recognition of the Shinde faction, Senior Advocate Neeraj Kishan Kaul argued in the Supreme Court that the Commission’s power under Article 324 lets it look past a party constitution on paper to how the organisation actually functions, and that an organisational majority resting on ad hoc appointees may not reflect the will of the cadre. The submissions are his; nothing has been decided.