Appeals against the single judge’s service charge ruling have been admitted by the Delhi High Court, but without interim relief, so the bar on mandatory service charge on food bills stays in force.

New Delhi: The National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI) had their intra-court appeals admitted by the Delhi High Court on Thursday, November 19, but the Court expressly declined to grant them any interim relief. The appeals are against a single judge judgment which held that service charge and tips are voluntary payments and cannot be made compulsory on food bills [National Restaurant Association of India v. Union of India & Anr.].
The matter was heard by a Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma. The Bench’s remarks during the hearing were oral, and the Court has not yet ruled on the merits of the appeals.
The Bench’s questions to the restaurants
The Bench asked why the service charge is not built into the price on the bill. Counsel for one of the appellants submitted that restaurants voluntarily show it separately because it is meant as a contribution towards the staff.
The Bench then questioned why hotels do not include all their charges in the food bill itself and why they charge extra. Acting Chief Justice Sambre remarked:
“Suppose you bring something of Rs. 100. You process it. You sell it for Rs. 1000. Do they come and question you from where this Rs. 900 come from? No. It is your processing fees…”
He further observed:
“In foreign countries, there are restaurants where they compel you that you must pay this much percentage of the bill as tip. This is not in our country. There is no legislation.”
The Centre’s concern
As the appeals were admitted, Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, appearing for the Union of India, told the Court that thousands of complaints have come in from consumers across the country that some restaurants are still collecting service charge. This, he said, is despite the reasoned single judge judgment, which also clarified that restaurants have no power to levy a tax.
He submitted that restaurants earlier cited the pendency of the appeals, and that with the appeals now admitted, some of them might continue to impose the charge. The Bench responded that it had not granted the interim prayer:
“We haven’t granted interim prayer.”
The ruling under challenge
The restaurant bodies had challenged the guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) in July 2022, which prohibit hotels and restaurants from levying service charge “automatically or by default” on food bills.
In March 2025, the single judge upheld the guidelines and dismissed the writ petitions, directing each petitioner body to deposit Rs 1 lakh with the CCPA for use in consumer welfare. The judgment held that collecting service charge as a mandatory, default addition to the bill is contrary to law, though a customer remains free to pay a voluntary tip.
The single judge found the manner of enforcement coercive, noting that customers often confuse the charge with service tax or a government levy. A default service charge imposed without giving the consumer a choice, it was held, cannot be treated as contractually binding.
The CCPA was asked to consider allowing a change in nomenclature, since the charge is in substance a tip, gratuity or voluntary contribution. Terms such as “voluntary contribution”, “staff contribution” or “staff welfare fund” could be permitted, the single judge had said.
Why the order matters
Admission of an appeal is not a stay. Since the Division Bench has expressly refused interim relief, the single judge’s judgment and the CCPA guidelines continue to operate, and restaurants cannot add service charge to bills by default while the appeals are pending. Consumers remain free to pay a tip of their own choice.
The appeals will now test whether a voluntary staff contribution, shown separately on a bill, can ever be treated as part of the contract between a diner and a restaurant, and how far the CCPA can regulate pricing practices it considers unfair to consumers. The Centre’s statement about continuing complaints also signals that enforcement of the guidelines on the ground remains an open concern.
Case Title: National Restaurant Association of India v. Union of India & Anr. (with the connected appeal of the Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India)
Bench: Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma, Delhi High Court
Date of Hearing: November 19, 2026
Appearances: ASG Chetan Sharma for the Union of India
