Can NHRC orders be challenged in Delhi just because the Commission is headquartered in the capital? The Delhi High Court has answered no, dismissing a plea from Chhattisgarh’s Sukma district on territorial jurisdiction and forum conveniens.

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has refused to entertain a writ petition against an order of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) on a complaint from District Sukma, Chhattisgarh, holding that NHRC orders are not open to challenge before it merely because the Commission’s office is in New Delhi, and leaving the petitioner free to approach the appropriate forum, including the High Court of Chhattisgarh [Baman Ram Kawasi v. Union of India and Anr.].
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, sitting singly, dismissed the petition for want of territorial jurisdiction and on the principle of forum conveniens. The judgment was pronounced on November 19, 2026, having been reserved on September 18, 2026.
The order under challenge
The petitioner, Baman Ram Kawasi, approached the NHRC on June 4, 2026 after complaints to the police and district administration. On June 9, 2026, the Commission disposed of the complaint (Case No. 219/33/20/2026) by transmitting it to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, Sukma, with a direction to take appropriate action within eight weeks. The petitioner sought a direction that this order be treated only as an interim step, that the NHRC take fresh cognizance after hearing him, and that the Union government ensure the Commission can effectively discharge its mandate.
What the petition alleges
According to the petition, the petitioner and other Adivasi families of Village Chitlanar in Sukma have practised Christianity for about 18 years. The petition alleges that on March 5, 2026 a mob, including local Panchayat members, entered their homes and demanded that they convert to Hinduism or leave the village, that two persons were assaulted with lathis and hospitalised, that the families were threatened, and that the local police did not intervene despite being present. It further alleges that the families were forced to leave and have been living in makeshift shelters in Sukma town, and that a similar threat was repeated on March 17, 2026 in the presence of police and revenue officials.
These are allegations made in the petition. The Court made clear that it was deciding only the question of territorial jurisdiction and expressed no opinion on the merits.
ALSO READ: Supreme Court Issues Notice On Plea Over Vacant, Defunct State Human Rights Commissions
Two views on jurisdiction
The petitioner argued that the challenge was to a specific decision taken by a statutory authority at New Delhi, so a material part of the cause of action arose within Delhi, and the location of the underlying incident did not oust the Court’s jurisdiction.
For the Union of India, counsel raised a preliminary objection that the entire cause of action arose in Chhattisgarh, since the incident, the complaints and the allegations of inaction all related to Sukma, and the NHRC’s headquarters in Delhi was not enough. The Union also contended that a petition on the same subject was pending in Chhattisgarh and had not been fully disclosed.
Why the seat of the Commission was not enough
Relying on Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, ONGC v. Utpal Kumar Basu and the Full Bench ruling in Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, Justice Sharma said the seat of an authority does not by itself confer jurisdiction, and that even where a small part of the cause of action arises within its limits, a High Court may decline to hear a matter on the principle of forum conveniens.
Every foundational fact, the Court found, pertained to Chhattisgarh: the residence of the petitioner, the alleged incidents, the hospital treatment, the complaints and the allegations of inaction. The NHRC case record itself showed the complaint was received online and listed the complainant, victims and place of incident in Sukma. On the nature of the impugned order, it observed:
“As noted above, by virtue of the impugned order/action, the NHRC has acted merely as a channel, routing the complaint back to the very authorities at Sukma against whom the grievance is directed.”
Neither the State of Chhattisgarh nor the Sukma District Magistrate or Superintendent of Police had been made parties, the Court noted. Complaints can be lodged with the NHRC online from anywhere in India, and it said:
“If the contention of the petitioner were to be accepted, every order of the NHRC, concerning an incident anywhere in the country, would be amenable to challenge before this Court merely because the NHRC has its office at New Delhi.”
The Court referred to coordinate bench rulings in The Indure Pvt. Ltd. v. Government of NCT of Delhi, cautioning against turning the Court into a “mini-pan-India Superior Court”, and Suhas Chakma v. National Human Rights Commission, which involved a similar NHRC order on displaced families in Arunachal Pradesh. The Court said the High Court of Chhattisgarh “has the most direct and substantial connection with the lis”.
The Court returned no finding on the Union’s concealment objection. It said, though, that if parallel proceedings were indeed pending in Chhattisgarh, entertaining the petition would risk conflicting orders, which further supported its view. The petition was dismissed with liberty to pursue remedies before the appropriate forum, with all rights and contentions left open.
What the judgment settles
Under Article 226(2), a High Court can hear a writ where the cause of action arises wholly or in part within its territory, but the Supreme Court has long held that the mere seat of a national authority is not decisive. The judgment applies that rule to the NHRC, a body that receives complaints from across the country, and treats an order that simply forwards a complaint to local authorities as having its real connection with the State where the events took place.
The ruling does not shut out the grievance. It directs the dispute to the forum closest to the facts, the parties and the record, and makes clear that the NHRC, as a national body, can also be proceeded against before the appropriate High Court. The allegations themselves remain untested, and the Court has expressed no view on them.
Case Title: Baman Ram Kawasi v. Union of India and Anr. (W.P.(C) 13699/2026)
Bench: Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, Delhi High Court
Date of Judgment: November 19, 2026 (reserved on September 18, 2026)
Appearances: Advocates Jaiwant Patnakar and Philip John for the petitioner; CGSC Premtosh K Mishra with Advocates Krish Bhatia and Vasu Agarwal for the Union of India
