Delhi High Court Returns 10 More IP Suits, Says Slender Delhi Link Cannot Decide Jurisdiction

4 min read

Returning 10 more IP suits, including patent cases involving Novartis and Waaree Energies, the Delhi High Court has held that a slender connection with Delhi cannot deprive a court with a closer link to the dispute of its rightful jurisdiction.

Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav of the Delhi High Court, who returned ten IP suits for lack of territorial jurisdiction.

New Delhi: Ten intellectual property suits, each found to have only a weak link with Delhi and a stronger connection with another forum, were turned away by the Delhi High Court on Thursday for want of territorial jurisdiction. The plaints were returned to the plaintiffs for presentation before the appropriate courts [Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. and connected matters].

Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav delivered the 69-page common judgment on November 19, 2026, applying his November 3 ruling in ABD Maestro Private Limited v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd, in which he had returned the plaints in 17 commercial suits on similar grounds.

The order

The plaints in CS(COMM) 973/2026, 350/2026, 1060/2026, 1054/2024, 609/2024, 484/2021, 1208/2026, 785/2026, 1176/2026 and 251/2026 were returned under Order VII Rule 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiffs were given liberty to seek appropriate directions under Order VII Rule 10A CPC, and pending applications were disposed of.

Why part of the cause of action is not enough

Even where part of the cause of action arises in Delhi, the Court held, it may decline to hear a suit if the dispute is more closely connected with another forum. It said:

“A slender connection with Delhi ought not to become a reason to deprive another court of its rightful and appropriate jurisdiction over a given lis.”

The judgment traced the doctrine of forum conveniens and noted that even the enforcement of fundamental rights is subject to it. It then asked whether a common law right of passing off could be placed higher:

“Is a common law right of passing off more sacred than the rights guaranteed by Articles 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution? The answer lies in the negative.”

The Court added that the High Courts of Calcutta, Bombay and Madras routinely invoke the doctrine while testing civil suits under Clause 12 of their respective Letters Patent.

Suit by suit

Novartis’ patent suit against Lucius Pharmaceuticals and two others, over the cancer drug Dabrafenib, was one of them. The Court accepted that part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, where the allegedly infringing version was sold, but held that Mumbai, where Novartis’ Indian affiliate holding the marketing and import licence is based, had a closer connection.

German company Gebr Schmid’s patent suit against Waaree Energies rested on a sale invoice and an investigator’s purchase. The Court said that even assuming an offer for sale and delivery took place in Delhi, Schmid sought an injunction that would also stop manufacture, and the products were made in Surat, where the dispute was centred.

A similar approach was taken in a suit over alleged copying of turbojet engines. The Court said it could have heard a claim confined to exports from Delhi, but the plaintiffs sought a wider injunction covering engines manufactured in Punjab, where the alleged breach of confidentiality also took place.

Nyra Chocolates’ design suit over confectionery jars relied on a “trap order” placed with a dealer in Bihar and sent to Badarpur in Delhi. The Court found the bill unsigned and the details insufficient to judge whether the transaction was fair. Since Nyra’s agent paid the freight, the handover to the carrier was treated as delivery to Nyra in Indore, and the bill itself confined disputes to Siwan jurisdiction.

The remaining suits were filed by Sotkon, Mold-Tek Packaging, HLE Glascoat, Plusplus Lifesciences, Global Music Junction and Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories.

Why the judgment matters

The Delhi High Court has long been the preferred forum for IP litigation, with plaintiffs often relying on investigator purchases, trap orders or isolated sales to found jurisdiction. This judgment, following ABD Maestro, signals that such thin links may no longer be enough where the manufacture, the parties or the core of the dispute lie elsewhere. It comes less than two weeks after a larger bench of the High Court reserved its verdict on the same question, so the final position will depend on that ruling.

Case Title: Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. and connected matters [CS(COMM) 484/2021; 2026:DHC:10260]
Bench: Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav, High Court of Delhi
Date of Judgment: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate J Sai Deepak for Gebr Schmid, HLE Glascoat and Global Music Junction; Senior Advocates Sandeep Sethi and Gaurav Miglani for První Brněnská Strojírna Velká Bíteš and PBS India; Senior Advocate Rajeshwari Hariharan for Plusplus Lifesciences; Advocates Tanya Varma, Devyani Nath, Ruchika Yadavi, Vivek Shandilya and Hansika Bajaj for Sotkon

Similar Posts