Calcutta High Court Upholds Murder Charge Against Promoter In Garden Reach Building Collapse That Killed 15

5 min read

Refusing to dilute the murder charge against promoter Md. Wasim over the Garden Reach building collapse that killed 15 people, the Calcutta High Court held that a lesser charge at the threshold would leave the prosecution hardly any scope to proceed effectively.

Calcutta High Court building, where the murder charge against a promoter in the Garden Reach building collapse case was upheld

Kolkata: A revision petition filed by building promoter Md. Wasim @ Wassi against the charges framed against him under Sections 120B, 302, 307 and 427 of the Indian Penal Code was dismissed by the Calcutta High Court on November 20, 2026. The charges relate to the collapse of a five-storey under-construction building at Azhar Molla Bagan in Garden Reach in March 2024 [Md. Wasim @ Wassi v. State of West Bengal & Anr.].

Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das, who delivered the judgment, declined to interfere with the trial court’s order of December 11, 2024 framing the charges.

Why the charge stays

Revisiting the role attributed to Wasim, the Court noted that the prosecution’s specific case was that he was the developer along with the co-promoter and that the building was raised without any sanctioned plan. It recorded the allegations in the charge sheet:

“In particular, statements have been recorded indicating that the petitioner instructed the labourers engaged in the construction to mix the ingredients of construction materials disproportionate quantities and to use of inferior qualities materials while raising the columns of the building. More importantly, the petitioner despite possessing no requisite technical qualifications actively involved himself in the construction of the building, which ultimately collapsed, resulting in death 15 persons and injuries to several others.”

The prosecution had also brought up Wasim’s alleged criminal antecedents, the Court noted. On altering the charge at this stage, it held:

“This Court is of the considered view that if at this threshold stage, charge is altered and a charge for substantially lesser offence is framed there would hardly remain any scope for the prosecution to proceed effectively with the trial in respect of the gravity of the allegation and the role attributed to the petitioner, even if later found some ingredients against the petitioner for commission of grave offence. On the contrary, the petitioner cannot be said to have suffered any prejudice, since the charge has been framed in respect of an offence carrying the maximum punishment.”

Whether a case falls under Section 302 or Section 304 Part II IPC is to be decided after the evidence is led, according to Supreme Court precedent on which the Court relied. It left the final question to the trial:

“The Court shall, therefore, have the liberty to determine the culpability of the petitioner and the ultimate of the case upon proper appreciation of the evidences to be adduced in course of trial.”

The collapse and the case

According to the prosecution, the Officer-in-Charge of Garden Reach Police Station received a complaint dated March 18, 2024 from Sub-Inspector Pranay Tamang, who had been told by phone around 00:02 hours that night that the five-storey building at J-506B and J-506C, Azhar Molla Bagan, Kolkata had collapsed. Adjacent single-storey tiled rooms were badly damaged. Local residents told police that the building was being developed by Wasim.

Officials of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation complained that the construction was wholly unauthorised. Garden Reach Police Station Case No. 55 of 2024 was registered, and on June 13, 2024 a charge sheet was filed against Wasim and five others under Sections 302, 307, 288, 427, 34 and 120B IPC. The case was committed to the Court of Sessions and transferred to the Additional District and Sessions Judge, 14th Court, Alipore, as Sessions Trial No. 127 of 2024.

The promoter’s case

Counsel for Wasim argued that the complaint disclosed none of the essential ingredients of murder or attempt to murder, and that the case was registered under Sections 302 and 307 IPC without any enquiry in what was a building collapse. It was also contended that the charge sheet material showed that day-to-day construction was carried out under the supervision of co-accused Sk. Ripon, and that the role of co-promoter Abdul Rauf Nizami alias Sheru, who died in the incident, had also surfaced. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, opposed the plea.

The outcome

The High Court found no reason to interfere with the impugned order, dismissed the revisional application without costs and disposed of connected applications. The charges remain allegations to be proved at trial, and the accused is presumed innocent until then. The High Court’s ruling is confined to the framing of charge and expresses no final view on guilt.

Why the judgment matters

Deaths in building collapses are often prosecuted as negligence or culpable homicide not amounting to murder. The ruling shows that where the charge sheet alleges deliberate unauthorised construction and the knowing use of substandard material, a court may frame a murder charge at the outset and leave it to the trial to decide whether the case falls under a lesser offence.

It also reaffirms that an accused facing the gravest charge suffers no prejudice at the charge stage, since the trial court can still convict for a lesser offence on the evidence.

Case Title: Md. Wasim @ Wassi v. State of West Bengal & Anr. [CRR 127 of 2025]
Neutral Citation: 2026:CHC-AS:2002
Bench: Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das
Date of Judgment: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Sandip Kumar Bhattacharya, Dipta Dipak Banerjee, Srijita Dhar and Srilekha Dhar for the petitioner; Public Prosecutor Kallol Mondal with Pritam Roy and Samira Grewal for the State

Similar Posts