Bombay High Court Orders Release Of Undertrial Kept In Jail Despite Bail, Faults Vikhroli Magistrate

4 min read

An undertrial held in jail despite bail in every case against him has been ordered released by the Bombay High Court, which found that a Vikhroli magistrate wrongly issued a non-bailable warrant and remanded him while he was already in custody in another case.

Bombay High Court building, where a Division Bench ordered release of an undertrial kept in jail despite bail in two cases

Mumbai: Setting aside a non-bailable warrant of July 7, 2026 and a remand order of July 15, 2026 passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, 50th Court, Vikhroli, the Bombay High Court on November 19, 2026 directed that petitioner Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki be released forthwith, if not required in any other case [Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki v. State of Maharashtra].

The criminal writ petition was allowed by a Division Bench of Justice Sarang V. Kotwal and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, with Justice Kotwal authoring the judgment.

What the Bench found wrong

The facts were undisputed and were accepted by the Additional Public Prosecutor. On them, the High Court was direct about the magistrate’s three missteps:

“Learned JMFC was not right in ignoring the earlier bail order granted in favour of the Petitioner in connection with C.R. No.1234 of 2025 of Pant Nagar Police Station. Learned JMFC further erred in issuing NBW against the Petitioner though he was in custody in some other case and he could not remain present before the Court. Learned JMFC also erred in granting Magisterial Custody remand to the Petitioner in connection with C.R. No.1234 of 2025.”

“Hence, the Petitioner remains in custody though he is granted bail in both these offences. This situation needs to be corrected. The Petitioner deserves to be released from custody.”

Five cases, bail in each

Solanki is named in five criminal cases registered at police stations in Bhosari, Alandi, Chaturshringi, Vashi and Pant Nagar under various provisions of the IPC and the BNS. It was undisputed, the Court recorded, that bail had been granted to him in all of them. These are allegations, and nothing in the order is a finding on guilt in any of the cases.

Two of the cases decided the petition. In the Pant Nagar case, C.R. No. 1234 of 2025 under Sections 305(a) and 331(4) read with Section 3(5) of the BNS, an Additional Sessions Judge in Mumbai granted bail on May 4, 2026. Once Solanki furnished sureties, the JMFC, Vikhroli passed a release order on May 26, 2026, addressed to the Superintendent of Thane Central Prison. Even so he could not leave, because he was in custody in the Alandi case, C.R. No. 168 of 2021, where bail came only on September 19, 2026.

From a missed hearing to a fresh remand

The Pant Nagar case was listed before the JMFC, Vikhroli on July 7, 2026. Solanki, already in jail, could not appear. The magistrate recorded his absence and issued a non-bailable warrant. On July 13 the police reported that he was lodged in Thane Central Prison in the Alandi case, and on July 15 he was produced and remanded to magisterial custody, with no reference to the bail order.

The consequence was that after he furnished sureties in the Alandi case on October 6, 2026 and a release order was passed there, he stayed in jail all the same, held by the magisterial custody in the Pant Nagar case.

The directions

The July 15, 2026 remand order and the July 7, 2026 warrant were set aside. As Solanki had already met the bail conditions, including sureties, in both the Pant Nagar and Alandi cases, the Bench directed his release subject to the conditions imposed by the courts that granted bail, and forthwith if he is not required in any other case. The petition was disposed of and Rule was made absolute.

Why the judgment matters

For trial courts, the ruling is a reminder that an accused already in jail in another case cannot be treated as absconding because he missed a hearing. Before a non-bailable warrant or a fresh remand, the custody status and any existing bail orders have to be checked.

It also shows how overlapping cases can keep an undertrial in prison long after bail has been granted. The High Court treated that gap as a wrong to be corrected at once, in keeping with the guarantee of personal liberty.

Case Title: Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki v. State of Maharashtra [Criminal Writ Petition No. 5741 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Sarang V. Kotwal and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale
Date of Judgment: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Sahil Tejwani, Aditya Navpute and Gaurav Tejwani i/b AKT Legal for the petitioner; APP M.M. Deshmukh for the State

Similar Posts