The Calcutta High Court has extended Abhishek Banerjee’s Interim Protection till January 29, saying that his alleged remarks against the judiciary, though painful, did not amount to a change in circumstances that justified refusing it.

Kolkata: Rejecting the State’s argument that his alleged remarks against the judiciary disentitled him to an extension, the Calcutta High Court on Friday (November 20) extended till January 29 the interim protection granted to Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee in his plea against coercive steps in criminal proceedings against him [Abhishek Banerjee v. State of West Bengal & Ors.].
Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya heard the State’s opposition to the extension. The Court observed that the remarks were “painful” but said that, on the material before it, they did not amount to an alteration in circumstances requiring the interim order to be withdrawn.
What the State objected to
Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Mazumdar, for the State of West Bengal, drew the Court’s attention to a post on X allegedly made by Banerjee against the judiciary after protection was denied to his aide. He pointed out that Banerjee already faces criminal contempt proceedings and questioned whether protection could continue while such remarks were being made, arguing that protection is ordinarily given to a law-abiding citizen.
Contempt, the Court said, is a different proceeding
Justice Bhattacharyya repeatedly asked what had changed to justify refusing the extension, and separated contempt from the interim relief sought in the present plea:
“Can prayer for extension of interim protection be denied based on comments against the judiciary? Is that wilful contumacious conduct?”
“If an appropriate situation comes, we may initiate contempt. That is a different proceeding. Can that issue be flagged for refusing interim protection?”
Banerjee’s counsel was also questioned about the remarks. He said he would need instructions, and the Court asked how he could be unaware of his client’s speech while representing him, then directed him to file an affidavit by Monday. Counsel stated that he did not subscribe to any comments made against the Court.
Anyone aggrieved by a judicial order, the Court cautioned, should approach a higher forum rather than comment on the judiciary. It remarked:
“If an MP is making such statement then what message is sent to his follower?”
“It is painful if it’s found that the litigant is making comments against the court, even if it is not construed as a wilful deliberate violation.”
Protection extended, State to report on the probe
The State had not shown any change in circumstances, the Court held, nor established that Banerjee was failing to cooperate with the investigation. It observed:
“Today this court doesn’t find any alteration of situation requiring refusal to extend interim order.”
The interim protection was extended till January 29. The State, which sought time to file an affidavit, was directed to place on record a report showing the progress of the investigation so that the Court can consider its opposition.
The allegations in the criminal proceedings against Banerjee remain untested. The Court has expressed no view on their merits, and he is entitled to the presumption of innocence.
What the order separates
The order keeps two questions apart: whether a litigant’s public remarks about the judiciary may warrant contempt action, and whether interim relief already granted should continue. Extension of interim protection turns on a change in circumstances or non-cooperation with the investigation, not on the litigant’s conduct outside the courtroom, which the Court said can be dealt with separately if needed.
The Court’s comments also make clear that criticism of judicial orders by public representatives is viewed seriously, and that the remedy against an adverse order is an appeal to a higher forum.
Case Title: Abhishek Banerjee v. State of West Bengal & Ors. (plea against coercive steps)
Bench: Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya, Calcutta High Court
Date of Hearing: November 20, 2026 (interim protection extended till January 29, 2027)
Appearances: Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Mazumdar for the State of West Bengal
