Gujarat High Court Dismisses Kejriwal’s Appeal On PM Modi Degree; RTI Cannot Serve Political Vendetta

6 min read

A political leader holding public office cannot use statutory proceedings for political motives, the Gujarat High Court has said, dismissing Arvind Kejriwal’s appeal against costs in the PM Modi degree case and ruling that the Central Information Commission’s 2016 direction to disclose the Prime Minister’s degrees fell outside the RTI Act.

Ahmedabad: The Gujarat High Court on Tuesday, September 29, dismissed Arvind Kejriwal’s intra-court appeal against the March 2023 judgment of a Single Judge, which had quashed the Central Information Commission’s order of April 29, 2016 and imposed costs of Rs 25,000 on him, declining to expunge the Single Judge’s remarks against him and confirming the quashing on merits [Arvind Kejriwal v. Gujarat University and Others].

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Sunita Agarwal and Justice D.N. Ray passed the judgment, authored by the Chief Justice, after reserving it on September 24.

Background of the case

While hearing a third party’s second appeal under the RTI Act about an Electoral Photo Identity Card transport request concerning Kejriwal, the CIC called for his response. By a letter dated April 28, 2016 and a written submission, Kejriwal, then Chief Minister of Delhi, asked the Commission to order disclosure of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s degree information. By an order of April 29, 2016 in CIC/SA/C/2015/000275, Information Commissioner M. Sridhar Acharyulu treated this as an RTI application and directed the PMO to provide the specific number and year of the degrees to Delhi University and Gujarat University, and directed their Public Information Officers to search for and provide information on the graduation degree of 1978 and the post-graduation degree of 1983 to Kejriwal.

Gujarat University challenged this before the High Court, and on March 31, 2023 the Single Judge quashed the CIC’s order and imposed costs of Rs 25,000 on Kejriwal, observing in paragraph 40 that he had persisted with the matter although the University had put the degree on its website. His review petition was rejected on November 9, 2023. He then appealed.

What the parties argued

Senior Advocate Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, with Dr. Aum M. Kotwal, Vivek Jain and others, told the Court at the outset that Kejriwal did not challenge the merits of the Single Judge’s judgment and confined his challenge to paragraphs 40 and 41, the remarks on his conduct and the costs. He argued that Kejriwal was a bystander who never filed an RTI application, that the CIC acted suo motu, that he did not respond to the writ petition between 2016 and 2023 or pursue the University’s own appeal, and that the University had itself admitted that only details of the degree, not the degree, were on its website.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing with Manisha Luvkumar, Additional Advocate General, and others for the University, argued that Kejriwal’s conduct in triggering the proceedings, and his review petition on the merits, justified the remarks and costs. He said the letter of April 28, 2016 showed an oblique motive, that the CIC had acted wholly without jurisdiction, and asked the Court to decide the merits under Section 8 of the RTI Act for the guidance of the CIC.

Remarks and costs not disturbed

The Bench said that, having noticed the contents of the April 28, 2016 letter and the CIC’s order, and the manner in which the matter proceeded before the CIC, it found no merit in the plea to expunge the remarks or set aside the costs. Adding to what the Single Judge had observed, it said:

“…statutory authorities and the Courts should not be treated as a public platform to ventilate the political vengeance. A political leader holding the public office cannot use the statutory proceedings for their political motives.”

The Bench added that the manner in which Kejriwal responded to the CIC and pursued the matter through written submissions “speaks of itself” and needed no further comment. It also observed that the RTI Act cannot be used as a tool to ventilate personal grudges or political vendetta against an individual, even one holding public office.

CIC acted outside the RTI Act

Accepting the Solicitor General’s request, the Court said it found it proper, in the interest of justice, to address the procedure under the RTI Act and the CIC’s reasoning. It held that under Section 6(1) a person must make a written request, with the prescribed fee, to the Public Information Officer, and that the CIC had no power to entertain a request at the second appellate stage. It held that the CIC’s taking suo motu cognizance and treating Kejriwal’s letter and written submissions as an application was completely outside the scope of the RTI Act, and that in the course of the case the Commissioner had crossed the boundaries within which he was supposed to act.

Degrees are personal information held in a fiduciary capacity

Relying on CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay, Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v. Subhash Chandra Agarwal and the nine-Judge Bench ruling in K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India, the Court held that educational qualification documents such as a mark-sheet and degree are the personal information of the individual, exempt under Section 8(1)(j), and are held by universities and examining bodies in a fiduciary capacity on behalf of former students, which attracts Section 8(1)(e), subject to a larger public interest. It noted that Section 8(1)(j) has since been substituted under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 to give an absolute exemption for personal information. On the public interest question, it held:

“No public interest much less larger public interest would require seeking of information of the educational qualification of the Prime Minister of India, who is an elected representative of the people and when his educational qualification has no bearing on his election to the Constitutional post.”

The Court said the CIC’s order records no reasons for disclosure within the meaning of clauses (e) and (j), and that its remark that education-related information about a public servant or political leader in a constitutional position is not hit by Section 8 is contrary to Subhash Chandra Agarwal and Puttaswamy. It held that the information does not automatically become a matter of public interest merely because it concerns the Prime Minister, that the degree being already in the public domain, as the CIC had noted, is irrelevant to the obligations under the Act, and that a public servant cannot be compelled to disclose personal information to the public merely because he holds public office. The CIC’s directions to the PMO and the two universities were held to be directly hit by Sections 8(1)(e) and (j), and none of the information was found necessary to disclose in public interest.

Directions

Holding that the Single Judge’s decision stands confirmed both on the CIC’s lack of jurisdiction in the absence of a proper Section 6(1) application and on the information being exempt under Section 8(1)(e) and (j), the Court found no error in the judgment under appeal, dismissed the appeal with no further order as to costs, and disposed of the civil application for stay. The Rs 25,000 costs imposed by the Single Judge are therefore not disturbed.

Case Title: Arvind Kejriwal v. Gujarat University and Others
Case Number: R/Letters Patent Appeal No. 796 of 2026 in R/Special Civil Application No. 9476 of 2016, with Civil Application (for Stay) No. 1 of 2023
Citation: 2026:GUJHC:61557-DB
Bench: Chief Justice Sunita Agarwal and Justice D.N. Ray, Gujarat High Court
Date of Judgment: September 29, 2026 (reserved on September 24, 2026)
Appearance: Senior Advocate Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi with Vivek Jain, Aayushi A. Shah, Amit Bhandari, Mohd. Irshad and Dr. Aum M. Kotwal for the appellant; Solicitor General Tushar Mehta with Manisha Luvkumar, Additional Advocate General, Rajat Nair, Aman Mehta and Dharmishta Raval for Gujarat University

Similar Posts