Does an apology end the courtroom mobile phone ban? Not quite. The Allahabad High Court let off a man it sent to custody for filming its proceedings after he apologised unconditionally, but the mobile phone ban in courtrooms for litigants stays in place.

Prayagraj: Raj Kulshrestha, who had been taken into custody a day earlier for recording court proceedings on his mobile phone without permission, was ordered to be released immediately by the Allahabad High Court on November 20, 2026, after he tendered an unconditional apology and undertook not to record proceedings again [Kuldeep Batra v. State of U.P. and Another].
Justice Vikram D. Chauhan dropped the proceedings initiated over the incident, but clarified that the directions in his November 19 order barring litigants from entering the courtroom with mobile phones would continue.
Open justice is not free broadcast
In the November 19 order, the Court had explained that open justice means proceedings are generally open for the public to attend, but it does not give an unauthorised person a right of “free broadcast”. It pointed out that cases involving personal liberty, child sexual abuse, the CBI, the Enforcement Directorate and MPs/MLAs often involve facts that should not reach social media before judicial determination, and that court proceedings are not for entertainment.
“The publishing or recording such judicial proceedings without leave of the Court may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings and may adversely affect the court proceedings or the right of litigant.”
How it began on November 19
On November 19, 2026, the Court noticed Kulshrestha recording the hearing in a petition under Article 227 filed by Kuldeep Batra. When the Bench Secretary took the phone into custody, three videos of the proceedings were found on it. Kulshrestha had no case listed before the Court and was carrying a Registry pass that allowed access only to the Advocates’ Chamber. The Court directed that he be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, and asked him to explain why the recording should not be treated as interference with the administration of justice.
Apologies in court on November 20
Advocates Nitish Kumar Soni and Bhanu Pratap Seth appeared before the Court. Kulshrestha was produced in police custody, and the petitioner, Kuldeep Batra, was also present. Soni told the Court that he had been out of station the previous day and had sent Seth to seek an adjournment. He tendered an unconditional apology for the incident and regretted the inconvenience caused.
Seth, asked why he had not appeared on November 19 despite the Court’s direction, said he was frightened and could not appear alone. Kulshrestha tendered an unconditional apology and undertook to maintain the decorum of the Court and not to record proceedings in future.
The Court also noted that Batra had entered the courtroom on a pass meant for the Advocates’ Chamber. Soni said the wrong pass was issued because of an error in his office and apologised for that as well.
What the Court ordered
Noting that counsel had admitted the mistake, the Court dropped the proceedings and directed Kulshrestha’s release forthwith. It added:
“However, the directions contained in the order dated 19.11.2026 restricting from carrying the mobile phones to this Court room shall continue and no litigant would be permitted to enter the Court room along with the mobile phones. The mobile phones may be kept in the office of the concerned Advocate or may be kept somewhere else.”
Kulshrestha’s phone is to be returned to him after the recording is deleted and the device is reset. He has been restrained from publishing any such video on social media, and the video saved on a pen drive is to be kept in a sealed cover.
The Court also directed that its November 19 order be placed before the Division Bench hearing PIL No. 2436 of 2019, In Re: Suo Moto Relating To Security And Protection In All Court Campuses In The State of U.P., to consider measures that would keep litigants from carrying mobile phones into courtrooms. The case will be listed afresh on November 27, 2026.
Why the order matters
The order shows the Court balancing firmness with proportion. An unconditional apology and an undertaking were enough to end the proceedings against the individual, but the Court kept its larger direction on mobile phones intact, signalling that the concern was about courtroom discipline rather than punishment for its own sake.
By sending the issue to the Division Bench hearing the court-security PIL, the single judge has also opened the door to a uniform rule on phones in courtrooms across Uttar Pradesh. The underlying principle is that public access to courts does not include a right to record and circulate proceedings without leave, given the risk of social media trials and harm to litigants and victims.
Case Title: Kuldeep Batra v. State of U.P. and Another [Matters Under Article 227 No. 14284 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Vikram D. Chauhan, Allahabad High Court
Date of Order: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Nitish Kumar Soni for the petitioner; G.A., Prayageshwar Kumar Upadhyay and Saurabh Singh for the respondents
