Allahabad High Court Questions UP Authorities Over Fresh Gangsters Act FIRs Despite Supreme Court ‘Stillborn’ Ruling

4 min read

The Allahabad High Court is not expected to keep pointing out the authorities’ inaction in following Supreme Court judgments, it has said, staying a fresh FIR and calling for a personal affidavit from the Additional Chief Secretary (Home) on why Gangsters Act FIRs are still being registered in Uttar Pradesh months after the Supreme Court called the 1986 law “stillborn”.

Allahabad High Court building, which questioned UP authorities over fresh Gangsters Act FIRs after the Supreme Court stillborn ruling

Prayagraj: An FIR registered on October 23, 2026 under Section 3(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986 has been stayed by the Allahabad High Court, which has also directed the Additional Chief Secretary (Home), Uttar Pradesh, to explain on a personal affidavit why such FIRs continue to be lodged despite the Supreme Court’s August 2026 ruling declaring the Act “stillborn” [Brijesh Kumar alias Banty Verma v. State of U.P. and Others].

The order was passed by a Division Bench of Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava on a writ petition challenging an FIR registered at Akbarpur Police Station in Ambedkar Nagar district. The matter will next be heard on December 15, 2026.

The Bench’s displeasure

The Bench expressed concern that the FIR had been registered on October 23, 2026, well after the Supreme Court’s judgment. It said the law on the 1986 Act had already been settled by the Apex Court and there was no occasion for the authorities to keep registering FIRs under it.

“Once the law with regard to the Act, 1986, has been enunciated by the Apex Court in August, 2026, consequently, there cannot be any occasion for the authorities to continue with the registration of First Information Reports under the provisions of the Act, 1986.”

The Court added that it was not expected to repeatedly point out the inaction of the authorities in not adhering to Supreme Court judgments. It observed that the insistence on registering such FIRs forced litigants to approach the High Court and wasted the “precious judicial time of the Constitutional Court”.

It also recorded that Additional Government Advocates had earlier been informed that FIRs were being registered despite the Supreme Court judgment, but “it appears that no heed has been paid to the same”.

The petition and the stay

The petitioner, Brijesh Kumar alias Banty Verma, challenged the FIR lodged against him last month under Section 3(1) of the Gangsters Act. His counsel relied on the Supreme Court’s August 2026 judgment in Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu v. State of U.P. and Others, in which the 1986 Act was described as “stillborn”, and argued that the authorities could not continue investigating an FIR registered under its provisions.

The State’s counsel did not dispute this submission. Taking note of the Supreme Court ruling, the Bench directed that the operation of the impugned FIR would remain stayed until further orders and that no further proceedings would be taken on it.

What the Home Department must explain

The Additional Chief Secretary (Home) has been directed to file a personal affidavit within three weeks explaining why FIRs under the Act are still being registered, what action is proposed against the authorities responsible, and what remedial measures will be taken. If the affidavit is not filed, the officer will have to appear in person with the relevant records to assist the Court.

Another Bench, a different view

The order comes days after another Division Bench of the High Court, on November 19, 2026, held that the 1986 Act remains operative despite the Supreme Court’s “stillborn” observation. That Bench reasoned that the Supreme Court had not declared the Act unconstitutional, and that the Full Bench decision in Ashok Kumar Dixit v. State of U.P. and Another (1989), which upheld the Act’s validity, continues to bind the High Court. Last month, a Single Judge had also sought the State Government’s response on the Supreme Court’s observation.

Why the order matters

Under Article 141 of the Constitution, the law declared by the Supreme Court binds every authority in the country. The Bench treated the continued registration of Gangsters Act FIRs after the August 2026 ruling as a failure to follow that binding law, and placed responsibility at the top of the State’s Home Department by asking for a personal affidavit from the Additional Chief Secretary.

The order also highlights an unsettled question. With one Division Bench holding the Act still operative and another questioning why FIRs under it are being registered at all, the status of the 1986 law in Uttar Pradesh may need authoritative clarification, either from a larger Bench of the High Court or from the Supreme Court itself.

Case Title: Brijesh Kumar alias Banty Verma v. State of U.P. and Others (writ petition challenging FIR under Section 3(1), U.P. Gangsters Act, PS Akbarpur, Ambedkar Nagar)
Bench: Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava, Allahabad High Court
Date of Order: November 2026
Next Date of Hearing: December 15, 2026

Similar Posts