Allahabad High Court Flags ‘Stage-Managed’ Full Court Meetings; Says Judges’ Dissent Not Recorded

7 min read

Questioning whether the Full Court of the Allahabad High Court still works as a genuine collegiate forum, Justice Vinod Diwakar has recorded an impression that its last two Full Court meetings were “stage-managed” like a government whipping members through a confidence vote, noting that only 16 Full Court meetings were held in a decade and that individual Judges’ views are never put on record.

Allahabad High Court building, where Justice Vinod Diwakar recorded that Full Court meetings appeared stage-managed

Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has raised serious concerns over the functioning of its own Full Court, observing that its proceedings do not record the concurrence or dissent of individual Judges and that an impression had been given that the last two Full Court meetings were “stage-managed in the manner of a government whipping its members through a confidence vote” [Pappu Met @ Pappu v. State of U.P. and Another].

A single-judge bench of Justice Vinod Diwakar made the observations in an 80-page common judgment delivered on September 28, 2026, disposing of four petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution that exposed delays in criminal trials, non-compliance with bail directions by the district judiciary, and wider questions of judicial discipline and institutional accountability.

Only 16 Full Court Meetings In Ten Years

Turning to the administrative side of the High Court, the bench examined the place of the Full Court under the Allahabad High Court Rules, 1952. It pointed to Rule 8 of Chapter III, under which the Chief Justice is to convene a Full Court meeting once every three months, leaving out the summer vacation, and must call one within a week if not fewer than five Judges ask for it.

Against that requirement, the Court recorded that just 16 Full Court meetings have been convened by the Chief Justice over the last ten years.

The bench also went through what had actually been placed before those meetings. On a review of the agenda of the last ten meetings, it found that the designation of Senior Advocates had come up twice, and that the designations approved on one of those occasions are now under challenge on the judicial side before the Lucknow Bench. Everything else on the agenda concerned the service conditions of judicial officers. The judgment records:

“No matter of general policy, no matter affecting the powers and status of the Court, and no annual report on the administration of justice has been placed before the Full Court during this period.”

The Court further noted that the general annual reports on the administration of justice had neither been laid before the Full Court nor sent to the Government as the Rules require, which, in its view, was enough to show the prevailing “state of functioning, working, and administrative culture in the High Court”.

The ‘stage-managed’ remark

The sharpest remark appears in a footnote to this discussion, where Justice Diwakar wrote:

“It was given an impression that last two Full Court meetings of this Court were stage-managed in the manner of a government whipping its members through a confidence vote, and this affronts the dignity of a Judge’s office.”

The Court tied this to the way Full Court proceedings are minuted. Since the record does not show whether individual Judges agreed or dissented, it said, the very deliberation the forum is meant to secure leaves no trace:

“Where a collegiate body resolves without recording the views of its members, the deliberation which the forum exists to secure is not evidenced on its record.”

Why individual views must be recorded

Explaining why the Full Court exists at all, the bench said its rationale rests on the principle of “mutual recognition” of the individual views of its Judges. The Full Court, it reasoned, is not simply a place where a final resolution is formally noted; its purpose lies in acknowledging what each member thinks through collegiate deliberation. A resolution recorded without those views, therefore, does not fully reflect why the forum was created.

The Court added that ignoring the Rules and failing to minute individual concurrence or dissent could create a perception of disrespect towards a Judge’s personal identity and dignity. It also observed that the minutes of the committees constituted by the Chief Justice have never been communicated to the Full Court, giving the impression that they function independently of the High Court itself, and went on to say:

“Consequently, there exists no institutional forum within the High Court to raise such issues, except by addressing them through judicial orders. Otherwise, the Judges would [be] left to endure and lead a frustrating professional life in an environment that is neither conducive to judicial work nor reflective of the dignity of this great institution.”

At the same time, the Court counselled restraint, warning that unless such matters are handled carefully they could weaken institutional discipline and the rule of law, and that responses driven by personal affront or subjective notions of identity risk “arbitrariness, bias, and a departure from established legal norms”, contrary to procedural fairness and natural justice.

Who judges the judge

The bench placed the Full Court within a broader concern about accountability inside the judiciary. Where formal review structures are missing, it said, the task of “judging the judge” falls informally on the institution itself, through full-court deliberations, internal checks and, more and more, public scrutiny. Such diffuse accountability, the Court cautioned, may not be enough, and it called for “clearly articulated administrative standards, reason-giving obligations, and limited but meaningful review mechanisms based on rule-bound procedure”.

In the same judgment, the Court also called for a recalibration of the Chief Justice-centric model of High Court administration, noting that successive Chief Justices had not consistently followed the 1952 Rules, that allocation of work is not linked to performance, that there are no codified and notified parameters for elevation and promotion, and that administrative decisions attract no accountability or independent audit. It further noted that the High Court’s administrative business runs through 84 committees, most of which, over the last three and a half years, have been chaired by two or three senior Judges.

Background of the case

The observations arose from four petitions heard together. In the lead matter, petitioner Pappu Met @ Pappu, an accused in a 2024 Bareilly case over the theft of two buffaloes and a calf, challenged a bail order of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bareilly, requiring a personal bond of Rs 1,00,000 with two sureties of the same amount, even though co-accused had been released on bonds of Rs 25,000. He argued that the condition ignored the Supreme Court’s directions in In Re: Policy Strategy for Grant of Bail and the High Court’s own ruling in Smt. Bacchi Devi v. State of U.P., which dispensed with the mandatory requirement of two sureties.

By orders of December 11 and December 18, 2025, the Court called for explanations and data. The District Judge, Bareilly, reported 2,326 bail orders across 47 courts of the judgeship that departed from Bacchi Devi after August 12, 2025. Statewide figures compiled by the Registry showed 9,775 anticipatory bail orders and 1,56,155 regular bail orders after that date in which accused persons were directed to furnish two sureties.

The three connected petitions concerned stalled trials. In Urmila Mishra, a Prayagraj criminal case pending since 2009 had been listed more than 178 times without charges being framed. In Sarfraj Ahmad, a Ghaziabad case with a 2010 charge-sheet had been listed about 143 times with no charge framed. In V.S. Palitube, a 2013 cheque bounce complaint over Rs 59,000 remained at the summoning stage after more than 100 listings, despite a 2023 High Court direction to decide it within six months.

Data gathered from the district courts in the Urmila Mishra matter showed 16,15,655 cases pending across Uttar Pradesh in which charges had not been framed, 14,08,134 before Magistrates and 2,07,521 before Sessions Courts, with pendency going back to 1981. In the five years from 2021 to 2025, the police filed 22,51,629 charge-sheets, a gap the Court said pointed to institutional capacity that has not kept pace. The Court also recorded that most District Judges had sent incomplete or deficient reports despite repeated reminders, and that no suggestions or written submissions were placed on behalf of the High Court through its counsel despite specific requests.

Case Title: Pappu Met @ Pappu v. State of U.P. and Another [Matters Under Article 227 No. 15205 of 2025], with V.S. Palitube v. State of U.P. and Another, Urmila Mishra v. State of U.P. and 4 Others, and Sarfraj Ahmad v. State of U.P. and Another
Bench: Justice Vinod Diwakar, Allahabad High Court
Date of Judgment: September 28, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Arun Pratap Singh and Kamaluddin for the petitioner in the lead matter; Advocate Rajeev Sawhney for V.S. Palitube; Government Advocate for the State; Senior Advocate Manish Goyal, assisted by Advocate Sudhir Mehrotra, for the High Court; Advocates Pratima Vishwakarma and Juveriya Kazmi as Amicus Curiae

Similar Posts