The petitioner wants the SIR voter restoration offer widened beyond seven States, and says an SIR-only declaration was built into the ordinary online Form 6 without any amendment of the Rules. In a rejoinder before the Supreme Court, he argues that electors left out of draft rolls elsewhere are being denied the second chance the Election Commission has now extended. The Commission says Form 6 was never amended.

New Delhi: A declaration meant for the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) was written into the ordinary online Form 6 without any amendment of the Rules, the petitioner challenging the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) decision-making has told the Supreme Court. He has also asked that the Commission’s “one more opportunity” for electors left out of draft rolls, now limited to seven States and Union Territories, be extended to every State and UT where the SIR is ongoing or completed [Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors.].
The rejoinder affidavit was filed on November 15, 2026 by Rakesh Kumar Singh through Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta. It responds to the Commission’s counter-affidavit of October 26 and supplementary affidavit of November 14, both affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The matter is listed before the Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on November 17.
A statutory form, an added declaration
Form 6, used to apply for inclusion in the electoral roll, is a statutory form under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, framed by the Central Government under Section 28 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950. According to the rejoinder, the petitioner has never claimed that the printed text of Form 6 was amended. His grievance is that in July 2026 the online Form 6 was altered so that an applicant “could not proceed” without answering whether he, his parents or grandparents “exist” in the electoral roll of the last SIR.
It leans on three statements in the counter-affidavit: that the declaration “was entered into the online page of Form 6”, that this “could be construed as though an amendment of Form 6 had been made”, and that Form 6 “can only be amended by the Central Government”. The two were separated only by a decision of the Commission’s ER Division on October 21, 2026, after the petition was filed.
The Commission has defended the merger as a way to allow a single OTP and a single e-sign. The rejoinder says that explanation “finds no contemporaneous basis in any order or decision of the Commission”. Citing Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner (1978), it argues that an administrative action cannot be supported by fresh reasons supplied in an affidavit. In its view, the Commission has sidestepped the central question:
“Could an applicant submit the online Form 6 without completing the additional Declaration? They have not asserted that this was possible.”
The single e-sign, it adds, also authenticated a declaration carrying the Section 31 penal warning, which is not part of the statutory Form 6.
“Amended”, “substituted”, “rationalised”, yet “no significant change”
A comparative statement (Annexure R-2) is annexed to the rejoinder, setting the declaration under the first SIR order of June 24, 2025 (Annexure D) against the revised one under the order of October 27, 2025 (Annexure IV). As that statement has it, the revised declaration adds the applicant’s mobile number and family particulars, EPIC numbers of relatives, and mapping to the earlier SIR roll, particularly the 2002/2003 roll, by State, district, constituency, part and serial number. It also adds mapping through parents or grandparents, a separate BLO undertaking, and an Information Sheet that triggers a further ERO notice where mapping fails.
The counter-affidavit calls the declaration “amended”, “substituted” and “rationalised”, and still says there was “no significant change”. The rejoinder calls this a contradiction. First-time electors, it argues, are particularly prejudiced, since many may have no traceable entry of their own or of parents or grandparents in the 2002/2003 rolls. It adds that a methodology meant only for an SIR under Section 21(3) cannot be imposed on ordinary Form 6 applicants outside it.
The Commission relies on Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India (2026). That judgment, the rejoinder says, concerned the documentation framework under the June 2025 SIR order. It expressly said the Commission’s residual authority “is not unbounded”, and it did not consider the later Annexure IV, the July 2026 online change or Section 18 compliance.
Seven States, though the SIR is wider
The Supreme Court suggested on October 28, in Anjali Bhardwaj v. Election Commission of India, W.P.(C) No. 1188 of 2026, that left-out electors be given another opportunity. The Commission followed with directions on November 6, 2026 (Annexure R-17). Electors marked ASDD (Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate) get another chance to be included, booth-wise lists are to be displayed afresh, BLOs are to make house-to-house visits, and the same EPIC number is to be reassigned when a form is accepted.
The supplementary affidavit says the directions went to the Chief Electoral Officers of “the States/UTs where the SIR is ongoing”. Annexure R-17, the rejoinder points out, is addressed only to the CEOs of Delhi, Maharashtra, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Jharkhand, Telangana and Nagaland, whereas the counter-affidavit itself says the SIR is ongoing in 16 States and 3 Union Territories. It says no explanation has been given for leaving out electors elsewhere.
The rejoinder reads the reassignment of the same EPIC number as recognition that “the persons concerned may be existing electors”, not fresh applicants, and asks why they were not given a proper restoration mechanism at the outset. It also notes that the form annexed to the November 6 directions still requires historical electoral-roll mapping and a declaration carrying the warning of prosecution under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
The fear of prosecution
In its letter of November 3, 2026 (Annexure R-16), the Commission clarified that no action under Section 31 would be taken against previously enrolled electors who were omitted from the draft roll and file Form 6. The letter records that such electors were “hesitant to submit Form 6” because its declaration required them to state they were being included for the first time. The rejoinder says the clarification confirms the hardship, but does not explain why those electors were omitted or why they had to seek inclusion afresh. It adds that the letter is conditional and is signed by an Under Secretary, with no decision of the Commission produced.
Goa and West Bengal
The rejoinder says 97 electors in Goa were found eligible by Electoral Registration Officers after hearings held under the Supreme Court’s order of January 29, 2026, but those decisions could not be recorded on ECINet. The office of the CEO, Goa sent eight communications between February 11 and 17, 2026 seeking the facility, which was not enabled before final publication, an averment it says has not been denied.
The Commission says the electors were made to file fresh Form 6. The rejoinder says that confirms the EROs’ statutory decisions “could not be given effect on ECINet”, and points to a gap between the 81 applications mentioned in the Commission’s September 26 press note and the 88 in its affidavit.
On West Bengal, it relies on the counter-affidavit’s statement that the electors against whom appeals were filed are on the rolls, voted in the recent Assembly elections, have documents on the portal and have favourable orders from judicial officers. It says 16.10 lakh appeals remain pending against such electors.
“There have been and will be problems”
The supplementary affidavit acknowledges that, given the volume of data and digitalisation, “there have been and will be problems”. Such difficulties, the rejoinder says, cannot dilute the Commission’s obligations:
“Purity of the electoral roll and inclusion of eligible electors are complementary obligations; neither can be pursued at the cost of the other.”
What the petitioner wants for voters
Within the existing prayers, the rejoinder asks the Court to:
- extend the Annexure R-17 restoration opportunity to similarly placed ASDD electors in every State and UT where the SIR is ongoing or completed, subject to verification, and place State-wise and constituency-wise data on record;
- direct the Commission to disclose from when, and in which States and UTs, the declaration was built into online Form 6, how many Form 6 applications were rejected, kept pending or left incomplete in that period, and how they will be processed under the 1960 Rules without the disputed requirement;
- call for State-wise ASDD figures, with separate counts for each category, and the number of enumeration forms received, accepted, rejected and pending under the November 6 directions;
- call for the action taken on the November 3 clarification; and
- call for the report of the ECINet compliance committee, along with access records, audit trails and changes made to ECINet since October 1, 2025.
The Commission’s stand
The Commission has said in its affidavits that Form 6 was not amended by its SIR orders, and that the declaration is separate from the statutory form. It says the declaration was upheld by the Supreme Court, and that outside the SIR the forms under the 1960 Rules will be used “without any additional Declaration”. It has placed on record the corrective steps it has taken, including the October 21 separation, the November 3 clarification on Section 31 and the November 6 directions for ASDD electors. It has said that no entry on ECINet is added, deleted or modified except by order of an ERO.
Why this matters for voters
If the Court accepts the petitioner’s plea, electors left out of draft rolls in States beyond the seven named in the November 6 directions could get the same chance to return to the rolls, with their old EPIC numbers. A direction to disclose Form 6 data would also show how many applicants were affected while the SIR declaration was part of the online form.
These are the petitioner’s contentions. The Commission disputes them, and the Court has not ruled on the merits.
Case Title: Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors.
Case No.: W.P.(C) No. 1246 of 2026
Document: Rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner to the counter-affidavit dated 26.10.2026 and supplementary affidavit dated 14.11.2026
Filed on: November 15, 2026, by Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta
Bench: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana
Next Date: November 17, 2026
