Kerala High Court Sends Punarjani Vigilance Closure Challenge Involving CM VD Satheesan To Chief Justice

4 min read

One Bench should not decide who may challenge the Punarjani vigilance closure and then hand the merits to another, the Kerala High Court has said, sending a plea that involves Chief Minister VD Satheesan to the Chief Justice. The petition, a single judge found, has the character of a public interest litigation.

Kerala High Court building in Kochi, where a plea on the Punarjani vigilance closure was sent to the Chief Justice.

Kochi: A petition against the decision of the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) to close its preliminary inquiry into alleged irregularities in the Punarjani rehabilitation project must be placed before the Chief Justice, the Kerala High Court directed on Monday (November 16). The project was launched in 2018 by present Chief Minister VD Satheesan, then the MLA for Paravur [Adv. KM Shajahan v. State of Kerala & Ors.].

Justice C Jayachandran held that the petition prima facie partakes the character of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL), and that the petitioner’s locus standi should also be examined by the Bench holding the PIL roster. The Registry has been asked to place the matter before the Chief Justice for appropriate orders.

One Bench for both questions

The earlier proceedings on the project had been pursued under PIL jurisdiction, the Court noted. It said it would not be appropriate for one Bench to rule on the petitioner’s standing, only for the case to be sent on to another Bench afterwards. In its words:

“It cannot be conceived in law that the question of locus can be considered by one court, and if the petitioner is found to have locus, the matter will have to be placed before the court having jurisdiction as per law.”

It went on to record:

“In such circumstances, there exists a strong prima facie indication that the petition, if at all liable to be considered on merits, partakes the character of a public interest litigation, liable to be considered by the Bench having jurisdiction as per the roster, and not by this Court.”

The petition and its allegations

Advocate KM Shajahan, the petitioner, wants the Vigilance Director’s decision of May 26, 2026 closing the inquiry set aside, and recommendations made in earlier vigilance reports enforced. Punarjani was a flood rehabilitation initiative started in 2018 to help families in the State affected by the floods.

The petition states that Satheesan solicited foreign contributions during a private visit to the United Kingdom in October 2018, in violation of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA). It says a preliminary inquiry report dated April 5, 2025 flagged the alleged collection of £22,500 at an event in Birmingham and questioned transactions of about Rs 1.22 crore involving the Kochi-based Manappatt Foundation and its chairman Ameer Ahamed.

As the petition tells it, the then Vigilance Director recommended a CBI inquiry to the State government on April 30, 2025. The authorities later sought further clarifications from the investigating officer, and a revised preliminary report followed on May 7, 2026. The petitioner’s case is that the revised report did not overturn the earlier findings, yet the Vigilance Director closed the inquiry on May 26, 2026.

Standing: the two sides

For the petitioner, it was argued that a citizen and whistleblower may challenge the closure of an inquiry even if he was not one of the original complainants.

Advocate General Jaju Babu opposed the plea. One of the original complainants, Jaison Panikulangara, had already gone to the High Court seeking a CBI inquiry into the Punarjani project, he pointed out, and a Division Bench rejected that PIL on December 9, 2020 and directed him to pursue his remedies under the Code of Criminal Procedure. Shajahan, a third party who did not initiate the original complaint, lacks locus standi to maintain the present challenge, the Advocate General argued.

Why the order matters

The order is procedural, but it settles where the challenge will be heard. By treating the petition as PIL in character, the Court has sent both the threshold question of standing and any hearing on merits to the roster Bench, so that a single forum decides whether a third party can question the closure of a vigilance inquiry and, if so, whether the closure stands.

The allegations about the Punarjani project are those made in the petition and the vigilance reports it relies on. They are untested, the Court has expressed no view on the merits, and the State has opposed the plea on maintainability. The Chief Minister is entitled to the presumption of innocence.

Case Title: Adv. KM Shajahan v. State of Kerala & Ors.
Bench: Justice C Jayachandran, Kerala High Court
Date of Order: November 16, 2026
Appearances: Advocates V Sethunath and Shamnas S for the petitioner; Advocate General Jaju Babu for the State

Similar Posts