“Unanimity In Defending Is Not Unanimity In Deciding”: SIR Petitioner Tells Supreme Court ECI’s Own Affidavits Admit Acts Taken Without Commission’s Decision

9 min read

Twenty statements in the Election Commission’s own affidavits show that officers acted in its name without a decision of the three-member body, the petitioner who has questioned how the Commission takes its decisions has told the Supreme Court. Ahead of the November 17 hearing, he has asked the Court to call for the original files. The Commission maintains that its SIR decisions were unanimous.

CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, the Supreme Court bench hearing the challenge to the Election Commission's decision-making

New Delhi: A rejoinder filed in the Supreme Court says the Election Commission of India’s (ECI) own counter and supplementary affidavits “admit on oath” that key steps in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) were taken by officers and divisions of its Secretariat without any decision of the three-member Commission [Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors.].

The rejoinder affidavit of Rakesh Kumar Singh, a resident of Patna, was filed on November 15, 2026 through Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta. It responds to the counter-affidavit dated October 26 and the supplementary affidavit dated November 14, both affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu on behalf of the Commission, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Dr Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Dr Vivek Joshi. The matter is listed before a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana on November 17.

What has changed since the petition

The petition rested, when it was filed, on reported written objections by the two Election Commissioners. That position “has since changed materially”, the rejoinder says. The counter-affidavit records that it was “approved for filing … by a unanimous decision of the three members”. The petitioner therefore argues that its admissions bind all three members, including the Chief Election Commissioner, and that the case “no longer depends on newspaper reportage.”

“Unanimity in defending an act is not unanimity in deciding it.”

The question before the Court

The petition, filed on September 27, 2026, asks whether acts done in the Commission’s name were decisions of the Commission as a three-member constitutional body. Under Article 324 of the Constitution and Sections 17 and 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, such decisions are taken unanimously “as far as possible” and, where the members differ, by majority. The petitioner asks whether the acts were instead taken by one member, or by officers acting without any such decision.

Twenty statements treated as admissions

The rejoinder sets out 20 statements from the Commission’s affidavits that it treats as admissions. The main ones are these.

  • Officers’ steps: the counter-affidavit says “certain steps taken by the officers … needed to be corrected to ensure that they are fully aligned with the steps approved by the Election Commission.”
  • Online Form 6: the SIR declaration “was entered into the online page of Form 6”, which “could be construed as though an amendment of Form 6 had been made”, although Form 6 “can only be amended by the Central Government”. It was separated only by a “decision dt. 21.10.2026 of the ER Division”, after the petition was filed.
  • Internal work allocation: an Office Order dated July 28, 2026 on the internal allocation of work was issued by an IAS officer of Additional Secretary rank on deputation. The two Election Commissioners wrote separately to the Cabinet Secretary on July 29, and the order “was never implemented” because of their joint direction of July 30.
  • IT systems: “henceforth”, all new IT modules and portals will go to the Committee of Officers and then for the Commission’s approval. The petitioner reads this as confirming that earlier modules were not placed before the Commission.
  • West Bengal appeals: appeals before the West Bengal Appellate Tribunals against electors found eligible by judicial officers were filed by officers of the Chief Electoral Officer, West Bengal, and “these matters were not brought to the Commission.” The rejoinder puts the pending appeals at 16.10 lakh.

It also invokes the Commission’s own Delegation Order of January 12, 1996, which provides that “in all other cases where no specific delegation has been made decisions will be taken by Election Commission.” None of these acts, the rejoinder says, falls within the matters delegated by that order or the 1997 order.

“Two of three members are a majority”

Files move first to one Election Commissioner, then the other, “and then finally to the Chief Election Commissioner”, the counter-affidavit says, likening this to a “chain of command”. The rejoinder says this description “proves the Petitioner’s apprehension.”

On Form 6, it says one Election Commissioner recorded on May 16, 2026, and the other concurred on May 19, that Form 6 could not lawfully be altered without amending the Rules, an averment it says has not been denied. “Two of three members are a majority,” it says, yet the change was implemented in July 2026 and stayed until October 21. Either the majority opinion was overridden by “the member at the end of the file chain”, in breach of Section 18(2) and the Constitution Bench ruling in T.N. Seshan v.

Union of India (1995), or the change was made with no decision of the Commission at all. “On either hypothesis the act was not the act of the Commission,” the rejoinder says.

Calling the members’ recorded opinions “suggestions”, “observations” or “queries”, it adds, cannot change the legal effect of a recorded difference of opinion.

Averments it says stand unrebutted

Some averments of the petition, the rejoinder says, are not specifically denied by either affidavit. These include that the two Election Commissioners recorded at least fourteen objections between October 28, 2025 and August 14, 2026, and that one Commissioner recorded on April 16, 2026 that for over a year he had received neither agendas before nor minutes after Commission meetings.

They also include that the first full meeting of the three members in four months was held on September 9, 2026, and that the Commission did not respond to a questionnaire dated September 21, 2026. Relying on Badat & Co. v. East India Trading Co. (1964), it argues that “a general or evasive denial is, in law, no denial.”

Corrective steps “welcome”, but no cure

Eleven measures have been placed on record by the Commission, the rejoinder notes, most of them taken after the petition was filed. They include the October 21 separation of the declaration from Form 6, the constitution of a committee to “double-check the compliance of ECINet with applicable Acts and Rules”, and a November 4 office order re-allocating oversight of the IT/ICT Division to a Senior Deputy Election Commissioner. The petitioner calls these “welcome as far as they go” but treats them as admissions that the issues raised were real. Citing Marathwada University v. Seshrao Balwant Rao Chavan (1989), it argues that “a void act is not validated by later correction or ratification.”

No challenge to the CEC’s appointment, or to EVMs

The Commission objected that the petition seeks to remove the Chief Election Commissioner. In reply, the rejoinder says the petitioner “has never questioned the appointment” of Gyanesh Kumar and does not seek his removal. Article 324(5), it says, “protects the tenure of the Chief Election Commissioner; it does not confer immunity upon actions taken without lawful authority.”

It also says the counter-affidavit answers a challenge to Electronic Voting Machines “that the Writ Petition nowhere makes”, and repudiates the suggestion that the petitioner seeks to “discredit the system”. The petitioner’s aim, it says, is to ensure that the Commission’s authority “is exercised by the Commission itself”.

Records and directions sought

Agendas, minutes, file notings, approval sheets, electronic approvals and audit trails are in the Commission’s exclusive custody, the rejoinder says, and withholding them invites an adverse inference. It lists eleven documents referred to in the affidavits but not annexed, and says confidentiality can be dealt with by production in a sealed cover, as in S.P. Gupta and Raj Narain. Within the existing prayers, it asks the Court to:

  • direct production of the original records on the SIR orders, the July 2026 and November 2026 office orders, the West Bengal appeals, the Goa electors, the Form 6 declaration and the ECINet committee’s report;
  • direct a responsible officer to state, for each impugned action, the Commission decision relied on, its date, the mode of approval and whether it was unanimous or by majority, or the specific delegation under which it was taken;
  • direct that, until the case is decided, no communication, order or appeal be issued in the Commission’s name except on a decision recorded under Section 18 or a duly established delegation;
  • direct that agendas be circulated to all three members before meetings and minutes recorded and circulated afterwards, and that all files, access logs and audit trails be preserved; and
  • direct the Commission to take a recorded decision under Section 18 on whether the West Bengal appeals are to be pursued.

The Commission’s stand

Its three SIR orders, of June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026, were issued on unanimous decisions, the Commission has said in its affidavits, and the Chief Election Commissioner did not act unilaterally. It has said that differing views of members form part of the record and that a query or note on a file is not by itself a decision. In urgent matters, approvals are obtained electronically and recorded on file later, and delegated functions are performed by officers under Section 19A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and its delegation orders.

It has also argued that the petition rests on an unverified newspaper report and that the prayer against the Chief Election Commissioner is barred by Article 324(5).

Why the rejoinder matters

The rejoinder shifts the case from what was reported about the Commission’s internal notings to what the Commission itself has said on oath. The question before the Court is no longer only whether the Election Commissioners objected, but whether each act done in the Commission’s name can be traced to a decision of the Commission or a valid delegation. If the Court calls for the files, the answer will turn on the contemporaneous record rather than on either side’s affidavits.

These are the petitioner’s contentions. The Commission disputes them, and the Court has not ruled on the merits.

Case Title: Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors.
Case No.: W.P.(C) No. 1246 of 2026
Document: Rejoinder affidavit of the petitioner to the counter-affidavit dated 26.10.2026 and supplementary affidavit dated 14.11.2026 of Respondent Nos. 2 to 5
Filed on: November 15, 2026, by Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta
Bench: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana
Next Date: November 17, 2026

Similar Posts