Supreme Court Moots Judicial Academy Scrutiny Of High Court Judgments For Objectionable Remarks On Women

3 min read

Could State Judicial Academies be put to work finding objectionable remarks on women in High Court judgments, so that the High Courts can expunge them on their own motion? The Supreme Court floated the idea on Monday, during its own hearing on a Patna High Court verdict on attempt to rape.

Supreme Court of India with CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana in suo motu case on remarks on women.

New Delhi: State Judicial Academies could survey the judgments of their respective High Courts for objectionable observations concerning women, and the High Courts could then start suo motu proceedings to remove the offending portions. The Supreme Court made this suggestion on November 16 [In Re: Order dated 09.07.2026 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Criminal Appeal (SJ) No. 775/2013 and Ancillary Issues].

The suggestion came orally from a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana. No directions have been issued yet, and the Court has not ruled on the merits of the suo motu case.

Judicial Academies as auditors

Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta, who is assisting the Bench, sought to place before the Court other judgments that, she submitted, contain offending observations against women. It was in this context that the CJI mooted the role of State Judicial Academies:

State Judicial Academies could survey High Court judgments to identify objectionable observations concerning women, after which the High Courts could be asked to initiate suo motu proceedings to expunge the offending portions.

Counsel for Pathak asked for time to file a response, and the Court gave him one week, deferring the hearing. The lawyers were also asked to remind the Bench on the next date about issuing directions to the judicial academies for the scrutiny exercise. Advocate General SD Sanjay appeared for the State of Bihar.

The Patna verdict that started it

The suo motu case traces back to a July 9, 2026 judgment of Justice Purnendu Singh of the Patna High Court, which set aside the conviction of Himanshu Pathak for attempt to rape in a 2008 case. According to the prosecution, Pathak locked a woman inside his photography studio, tried to remove her salwar and pressed her chest. A trial court had convicted him of attempt to rape and wrongful confinement.

The High Court held that even if the allegations were accepted, the acts amounted to outraging the woman’s modesty under Section 354 of the Indian Penal Code and not attempt to rape, finding no overt act that unequivocally showed an attempt to commit rape.

The Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance of the verdict and issued notice to Pathak on September 23, 2026.

These proceedings are about the High Court’s reasoning and observations. Pathak’s response is awaited, and any finding on his case remains open. LawChakra expresses no view on the merits.

Why the hearing matters

Objectionable remarks in a judgment do not disappear when the case ends. They stay in the law reports and can be cited for years. If the suggestion becomes a direction, the fight against gendered language in judgments would shift from case-by-case correction to a systematic audit. Judicial academies already train judges on gender sensitivity, and using them to find such passages and send them back to the High Courts for suo motu expunction would give the Supreme Court’s earlier guidance on gender stereotypes a practical follow-through.

The remarks were oral and no order has yet been passed. The next hearing will show whether the Bench formalises the scrutiny exercise and how far it reaches.

Case Title: In Re: Order dated 09.07.2026 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Criminal Appeal (SJ) No. 775/2013 and Ancillary Issues
Bench: CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, Supreme Court of India
Date of Hearing: November 16, 2026 (hearing deferred by one week)
Appearances: Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta assisting the Court; Advocate General SD Sanjay for the State of Bihar

Similar Posts