A 20-year-old went to court to get his bank account unfrozen and found a police probe ordered against him instead. The Kerala High Court has now held that in a bank account defreezing plea, a writ court cannot on its own direct a police investigation against the account holder merely because large amounts were credited into the account.

Kochi: A court hearing a plea to defreeze a bank account cannot independently order the police to investigate the petitioner only because large sums were credited to his account, the Kerala High Court has recently clarified. The ruling came in an intra-court appeal by a young hotel billing staff member from Kasaragod, whose account with the State Bank of India had been frozen [Mohammad Irfan K.I. v. State Bank of India].
A Division Bench of Justice Devan Ramachandran and Justice Basant Balaji heard Writ Appeal No. 2209 of 2026, filed against a judgment of Justice M.A. Abdul Hakhim that had dismissed the writ petition and directed the police to investigate the petitioner and his associates.
The line the Division Bench drew
In the appeal, the Division Bench clarified that a writ court dealing with a defreezing request is not to independently set the police on the petitioner merely because large amounts have passed through his account. Large credits, by themselves, are not a ground for a court to order a criminal investigation in such a plea.
Six requisitions of Rs 50,000
The petitioner, Mohammad Irfan K.I., aged 20, had approached the High Court in WP(C) No. 41222 of 2025 for a direction to the State Bank of India, Kasaragod branch, to unfreeze his account. The bank’s counter affidavit said it had received six requisitions from the Station House Officer, Cyber Crimes Cell, Puducherry, for Rs 50,000 each, and that the petitioner had been asked to explain the disputed transactions.
The petitioner’s reply affidavit said that the six amounts of Rs 50,000 were sent by his father’s sister’s daughter, Murshida P.K., and her husband, Sayyed Mohammed Badsha, who live abroad, to meet the cost of building a house for them in Kerala.
From a dismissed petition to a police probe
An order dated July 14, 2026 asked the bank to check whether the amounts came from Murshida’s account, and asked the petitioner to produce the building permit. The bank’s standing counsel later said the amounts had not come from her account. The petitioner could not produce a building permit; he said construction had not begun and the land was still being developed.
A statement filed by the Station House Officer of Bekal Police Station, impleaded on February 6, 2026, said the petitioner worked as billing staff at a hotel. The account statement for October 1 to October 29, 2025 also showed other large credits. In his judgment dated September 28, 2026, the single judge recorded:
“this Court is of the prima facie finding that the Petitioner has been using the account as a money mule.”
Relying on Sinana Farvin v. Kerala Gramin Bank and Others [2026 KHC OnLine 596], the single judge dismissed the writ petition but went further:
“Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed, but directing the Respondent No.3 to conduct an investigation against the Petitioner and his associates and to proceed in accordance with law.”
What the ruling leaves open
The ruling does not decide whether the credits in the petitioner’s account were lawful. Any police action on the Puducherry cyber cell’s requisitions remains a matter for the investigating agency under the law, and the petitioner is entitled to the presumption of innocence. LawChakra expresses no view on the merits of the allegations.
Why the judgment matters
Courts across the country are flooded with pleas from account holders whose accounts are frozen on requisitions from distant cyber police units, often without an FIR naming them. The ruling draws a line: a defreezing plea asks the court to test the freeze, not to start a fresh criminal process against the person who seeks relief. A petitioner who comes to court to explain his transactions should not leave with an investigation ordered against him only because the amounts were large.
The decision also keeps the roles separate. The police can still act on their own material, and banks can still act on lawful requisitions, but the trigger for a probe has to come from the law and the investigating agency, not from a writ court’s reading of a bank statement.
Case Title: Mohammad Irfan K.I. v. State Bank of India & Ors.
Case No.: W.A. No. 2209 of 2026 (arising from WP(C) No. 41222 of 2025, 2026:KER:74962)
Bench: Justice Devan Ramachandran and Justice Basant Balaji, Kerala High Court (Division Bench); Justice M.A. Abdul Hakhim (single judge, September 28, 2026)
Appearances (writ petition): Advocates Ipsita Ojal, Manas P Hameed, Laya Simon and Mariyamma A.K. for the petitioner; Advocate Amal George for the bank; Senior Government Pleader Bijulal K.R. for the State
