Supreme Court Moots Judicial Academy Scrutiny Of High Court Judgments For Objectionable Remarks On Women

Could State Judicial Academies be put to work finding objectionable remarks on women in High Court judgments, so that the High Courts can expunge them on their own motion? The Supreme Court floated the idea on Monday, during its own hearing on a Patna High Court verdict on attempt to rape. New Delhi: State Judicial […]

Supreme Court Declines Allahabad HC Plea On ‘Doubtful Integrity’ ACR Remark, Says Insubordination Is Temperament Issue

Is insubordination an integrity issue? In oral remarks, the Supreme Court said it is a question of temperament, and declined to entertain the Allahabad High Court’s challenge, leaving a ‘Doubtful Integrity’ ACR Remark against a woman judicial officer in Uttar Pradesh expunged. New Delhi: A challenge by the Allahabad High Court to the removal of […]

Kerala High Court Questions Expunging Trial Judge’s Remarks Not On Record, Assures Survivor’s Lawyer Of Faith

The Kerala High Court has asked how Expunging Trial Judge’s Remarks can be ordered when they appear not to be on the judicial record, while conveying that “this Court has full faith in her as a lawyer” to the advocate who represented the survivor in the 2017 actress assault case. Kochi: On Wednesday, November 4, […]

Supreme Court Expunges Rajasthan High Court Remarks Against Judicial Officer Over Typographical Errors In Judgment

The Supreme Court has expunged Rajasthan High Court remarks against judicial officer, holding that a Special Judge could not be castigated on the judicial side for inadvertent typographical errors without first being heard.

Supreme Court Expunges Madras High Court Remarks Against IPS Officer A Arun, Cautions On Preventive Detention

The Supreme Court expunged Madras High Court remarks against IPS Officer A Arun after his unconditional apology, but cautioned that an apology is no substitute for care in preventive detention.

High Courts Are Expected to Be Guardians of District Judiciary: Supreme Court Tells HCs to Avoid Harsh Remarks on Trial Judges

The Supreme Court of India set aside a Calcutta High Court order cancelling eight-year-old bail, calling it a perverse and illegal use of revisional powers. It said High Courts must act as guardians and avoid disparaging remarks against judicial officers.

“Judge’s Order Being Set Aside Or Modified By Higher Court Not A Reflection Of His Ability, Integrity”: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court said setting aside a lower court order does not question a judge’s integrity, with Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma making the remark while hearing an additional sessions judge’s plea seeking deletion of adverse observations.

Supreme Court Stays Rajasthan High Court’s Strictures, Adverse Remarks Against Judge in POCSO Case

The Supreme Court has stayed the Rajasthan High Court’s order that criticised a POCSO court judge for using a “cut, copy, paste” method in her judgment and directed training. Notice has been issued to the State and further action has been halted for now.

“Judges Are Human Beings, And All Humans Are Prone To Mistakes”: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of India acknowledged the significant pressure on judges, leading to inevitable errors, during a ruling on adverse remarks made against a Delhi judicial officer. Despite a target to raise the judge-to-population ratio to 50 per million by 2024, it remains below 25, highlighting the burden on the judiciary.

Delhi High Court Overrules Trial Court’s Adverse Remarks Against ED, Says ‘Unwarranted’ ‘Unjustified’

The Delhi High Court expunged certain adverse observations made by a trial court against the Enforcement Directorate (ED). The Court found that the trial court’s comments regarding ED’s IO and the ED’s functioning were unjustified, adding that such remarks have a “deleterious effect” on a public servant’s career.