Simon Soren, 70, is the only surviving convict in the 1981 Dumka double murder case, and the Supreme Court has ordered a medical team to examine him after his counsel cited a pending national policy on premature release of aged and terminally ill prisoners.

New Delhi: Directing the Chief Medical Officer of the District Government Hospital, Dumka, Jharkhand to constitute a medical team to examine Simon Soren and file a report, the Supreme Court on November 19, 2026 dealt with the only surviving accused in a double murder committed on October 18, 1981 [Simon Soren v. The State of Jharkhand & Anr.].
A Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran was hearing Soren’s appeal against the Jharkhand High Court’s judgment of October 28, 2024 in Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 425 of 2002. The Bench granted leave in the special leave petition.
What counsel asked for
Advocate-on-Record Fauzia Shakil, appearing for Soren, told the Bench that in Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 162 of 2025 filed by the National Legal Services Authority, the Supreme Court had directed all States and Union Territories to formulate and notify a comprehensive policy for the early or premature release of prisoners of advanced age or who are terminally ill, with a clear and unified definition of terminal illness. She asked that the matter be deferred by three months to await such a policy from the State of Jharkhand.
The history the Court recorded
Looking back over the case, the Court recorded:
“Forty-four years have elapsed from the crime committed on 18.10.1981 for the appeal to be taken up before this Court. We had noticed with anguish that the trial prolonged for twenty-two years and the appeal before the High Court also was pending for another twenty-two years. Of the six accused arrayed, two died before the framing of the charges and out of the four convicted, three died while the appeal was pending before the High Court.”
“The appellant is the only accused surviving who is 70 years of age and troubled with multiple ailments. We suspended the sentence and released him on bail by order dated 19.08.2026 despite he having spent only two years four months and twelve days in custody, especially considering the ordeal of prosecution for forty-five long years.”
Soren was sentenced to life imprisonment by the trial court in 2002, and surrendered after the High Court affirmed the conviction in 2024. The Supreme Court has also called for the records of the case.
The directions
Pending a policy, the Bench directed Soren to present himself at the District Government Hospital, Dumka for a medical examination and ordered:
“The Chief Medical Officer of the District Government Hospital, Dumka, Jharkhand shall constitute a medical team to examine the appellant and file a report.”
A copy of the order is to go to the Member Secretary, Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority, who will inform the Secretary, District Legal Services Authority, Dumka. On the DLSA’s request, the Superintendent of Police, Dumka is to ensure, through the Station House Officer of the police station where Soren lives, that the examination is facilitated. The report is to be filed on the next date. Soren’s bail continues, and the matter is posted to March 3. The record of proceedings gives the date as 03.03.2026, which appears to be a slip for 2027.
Why the order matters
The case is a stark example of delay in the criminal justice system: a 1981 crime whose trial and first appeal took 44 years, during which five of the six accused died. By seeking an independent medical report and tying the case to the NALSA-driven policy on aged and terminally ill prisoners, the Court has signalled that age and health will weigh heavily in how the remaining sentence is treated.
The appeal against conviction is still pending before the Supreme Court, and the Court has expressed no final view on its merits.
Case Title: Simon Soren v. The State of Jharkhand & Anr. [SLP (Crl.) No. 13759 of 2026]
Bench: Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran
Date of Order: November 19, 2026
Appearances: AoR Fauzia Shakil with Nazmeen Ahmed and Khalid Ali for the appellant; AoR Pallavi Langar with Sujeet Kumar Chaubey and Anushka Raghunath, and AoR Narain Rashika Ashok, for the respondents
