Supreme Court Refers Central Secretariat Library Case To CJI, Centre’s Undertaking Not To Shift Books Continues

4 min read

“It may come back to me in all probability but in the meanwhile you will have to stay your hands,” Justice Sanjay Kumar told the authorities as the Supreme Court sent the Central Secretariat Library suo motu case to the Chief Justice of India for listing before the appropriate Bench, recording that the Centre’s undertaking not to shift the library’s 8.5 lakh books continues until the next hearing.

Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva of the Supreme Court, who heard the Central Secretariat Library suo motu case.

New Delhi: With the subject outside the roster now assigned to the Bench, the Supreme Court on November 20, 2026 directed that its suo motu case on the relocation of the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library be placed before the Chief Justice of India on the administrative side for listing before the appropriate Bench [In Re: 135-Yr-Old Library, 8.5 Lakh Books, And No Room In The New Central Vista Plan].

A Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva also recorded the statement of Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, on behalf of the respondents, that the undertaking given on November 16, under which the books will not be shifted, will remain in force until the next date of hearing.

The Bench’s concern: the books themselves

Whatever the question of roster, the Bench made clear that its concern was the collection itself. Referring again to photographs from the last hearing showing books lying in cartons, Justice Kumar made these oral remarks:

“We are more concerned about these books. Look at those photographs… Those have just been thrown like that. We found a place for that. And those books are just lying there. What is to happen?”

“Heritage is not just a Newton’s bungalow. Is it not? We need to look at these books.”

Justice Kumar recalled the 2009 fire at the Hyderabad High Court library, saying the then Chief Justice, Justice Anil Ramesh Dave, had been in tears over the loss of the books. The Solicitor General agreed, citing the ancient library at Nalanda, and told the Court: “It’s a treasure which we lose. We are conscious. The government is conscious.”

Within a day or two, the Solicitor General said, the amicus curiae and the officers concerned would sit together to find a solution. “My earlier statement continues. I had a word with the amicus. All of us will sit together along with the officers. We will find a way out,” he submitted.

These were oral remarks during the hearing. The Court has not ruled on the adequacy of the space allotted to the library or on the relocation itself. A party-in-person who asked that his appearance be recorded was told he would be heard if the matter came back to the Bench.

Why the matter was sent to the CJI

Before the parties made submissions, Justice Kumar explained that the case had been taken up suo motu with information to the office of the Chief Justice of India, but its subject matter did not fall within his present roster. When Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said the Centre had no objection to the Bench continuing, Justice Kumar replied, “Let’s follow the procedure. You know what happened recently.”

Justice Kumar indicated that the matter could well return to the same Bench, but asked the authorities to hold back in the meantime: “It may come back to me in all probability but in the meanwhile you will have to stay your hands.” He added that if there was any urgency, the authorities were free to mention the matter before the Chief Justice.

How the case began

The Central Secretariat Library occupies four floors of Shastri Bhawan, which is to be vacated for the Central Vista redevelopment, and holds more than 8.5 lakh books, including rare volumes, official records and gazetteers, the oldest dating to 1702. The Court took suo motu cognisance in October after reports that the space allotted at the new site was inadequate, sought an affidavit from the Centre on the layout and space at Kartavya Bhawan, and appointed Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan as amicus curiae. On November 16, it recorded the ASG’s statement that the books would not be shifted until November 20.

Why the hearing matters

Under the Supreme Court’s practice, the Chief Justice, as master of the roster, decides which Bench hears which category of cases. By sending the matter to the CJI on the administrative side, the Bench ensured that a suo motu case outside its roster is assigned through the regular process, even though the Centre had no objection to it continuing.

The protection for the collection does not lapse in the meantime. The Centre’s undertaking keeps the books where they are until the next hearing, while the amicus curiae and officials try to agree on a suitable home for one of the country’s oldest government libraries.

Case Title: In Re: 135-Yr-Old Library, 8.5 Lakh Books, And No Room In The New Central Vista Plan [SMW(C) No. 21/2026]
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, Supreme Court of India
Date of Hearing: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati for the Union of India; Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan, amicus curiae

Similar Posts