Supreme Court Halts Shifting Of 135-Year-Old Central Secretariat Library Books, Tells Centre Show Some Respect

4 min read

Is there any hurry to box up the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library? The Supreme Court did not think so on Monday, recording the Centre’s statement that the books will stay put until the next hearing, after Justice Sanjay Kumar told the Union to “show some respect to these books”.

Central Secretariat Library, the 135-year-old collection at the centre of the Supreme Court suo motu case on its Central Vista relocation.

New Delhi: The books of the Central Secretariat Library will not be shifted before the Supreme Court hears the matter again on November 20. On Monday (November 16), the Court recorded the Additional Solicitor General’s statement to that effect in its suo motu case on the library’s relocation under the Central Vista plan, while the Bench sharply criticised what it described as an ad hoc approach by the Union Government to the library’s heritage collection [In Re: 135-Yr-Old Library, 8.5 Lakh Books, And No Room In The New Central Vista Plan].

Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva heard the matter.

“Show some respect to these books”

The sharpest exchange came when Justice Kumar questioned the speed at which the collection was being moved. His oral remarks to the ASG were:

“You are just in a hurry to get done with this. What are you planning to do with these books? There seems to be an ad hoc approach. You are not bothered about…, this is some heritage. Basically, a heritage for us dating back to 1702. If you don’t want them, give it to some other country that will value them…Show some respect to these books; two lakh books thrown to the wind.”

These were oral observations made during the hearing. The Court has not ruled on the adequacy of the space allotted or on the relocation itself.

The order

Justice Kumar then put it to the ASG, “You will not shift the books then,” and the Court passed this order:

“ASG says the books will not be shifted until next hearing. List on 20th November. In the meanwhile, the affidavit came to be filed today shall be placed on record.”

A user of the library has also filed an intervention application.

What the amicus and the ASG told the Bench

The Bench was told that the Union Government had filed its affidavit the same day and that the matter could be taken up the day after. The affidavit was not yet on record.

The amicus curiae submitted that some urgency was being shown to shift the books by November, and asked that this be stopped. She wanted more clarity from the Centre on the space available at the new site, and a comparison between the area now used for bookshelves and the area proposed at the new location. She also told the Court that she had visited the place in RK Puram where some of the books are stored, describing it as being in an “atrocious condition”, with books lying there for about 15 years. These books, she said, formed part of the library’s original collection.

For the Union, Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati submitted that the books lying there came from the Tulsi Sadan Library. The Court asked the amicus to verify whether the books carry that library’s tag.

How the suo motu case began

The Court took suo motu cognisance of the lack of space allotted to the library, which holds about 8.5 lakh books and is housed in Shastri Bhawan, a building due for demolition under the Central Vista redevelopment. The case followed a newspaper report of September 29 on the relocation. On October 5, the Court asked the Union to file an affidavit on the space allotted at the new site, along with its layout, and appointed Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan as amicus curiae.

Why the hearing matters

Once books are boxed and moved, questions about space, cataloguing and the condition of stored volumes become much harder to answer. The order freezes the physical position of the collection while the Court examines whether the Central Vista plan leaves enough room for it.

The next hearing on November 20 will rest on the Union’s affidavit, now to be placed on record, and the amicus curiae’s comparison of present and proposed shelf space. The Court will also have the amicus’s report on whether the books stored at RK Puram belong to the Central Secretariat Library’s original collection.

Case Title: In Re: 135-Yr-Old Library, 8.5 Lakh Books, And No Room In The New Central Vista Plan [SMW(C) No. 21/2026]
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, Supreme Court of India
Date of Hearing: November 16, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan, amicus curiae; Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati for the Union of India

Similar Posts