“What is the justification? What is the requirement.” With that question, the Chief Justice pressed Punjab’s counsel to defend the State’s Voter ID Mandate for women seeking monthly assistance under the Mukh Mantri Mawan Dheeyan Satkar Yojana, and the State has said it will file a better affidavit.

Chandigarh: Hearing a public interest litigation against the Mukh Mantri Mawan Dheeyan Satkar Yojana, a monthly income-support scheme rolled out in April, the Punjab and Haryana High Court on Thursday, November 19, asked the Punjab government to explain why voter identity cards are mandatory for women to receive benefits under it, and adjourned the matter to December 15 [Harbakhsh Charitable Society v. State of Punjab & Ors.].
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor heard the matter. The Court made oral remarks during the hearing and has not ruled on the validity of the scheme or the voter ID condition.
Where the Bench drew the line
Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, appearing for the State, told the Bench that other State governments also require beneficiaries to submit voter ID cards for verification, and referred in particular to the Lakshmi Yojana scheme for women run by the Bharatiya Janata Party government in Delhi. The Chief Justice cut the submission short:
“Mr. Singh, whether it is this government, that government, this State, that State, we are not on that. We are on a simple issue. What is the justification? What is the requirement.”
Singh answered that a voter ID establishes that a person is actually a resident of the area and a citizen of the country, and that it is the only document showing a person is a genuine resident of a particular area. He pointed to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls by the Election Commission of India, which he said was meant to weed out people not residing in an area, and offered to explain in detail how voter IDs are prepared.
When he suggested the Court might otherwise have to consider whether the SIR exercise itself was valid, the Chief Justice asked him not to drag the Court into areas unrelated to the case.
ALSO READ: Punjab And Haryana HC Calls Punjab’s DA Appeal Delay Deliberate, Asks If State Has Rs 520
What the PIL contends
Eligible women from the general category receive Rs 1,000 a month under the scheme, and those belonging to Scheduled Castes receive Rs 1,500 a month. Harbakhsh Charitable Society, the petitioner, contends that the scheme’s sole purpose is to secure votes for the Aam Aadmi Party government in Punjab.
The petition says a voter ID card can be one of the documents used for identification, but that making a Punjab voter ID mandatory for the benefit shows the scheme is intended as a quid pro quo for votes. It also alleges that the State repeatedly pleads financial constraints when asked to meet its admitted liabilities towards employees and pensioners, while continuing to incur substantial recurring expenditure on discretionary subsidy or “freebie” schemes. These are the petitioner’s allegations, and the State disputes that the requirement has any such purpose.
A fresh affidavit and the next date
The Bench asked Singh to point to the law on the issue. He said the State would file a better affidavit, since its earlier reply had only referred to the practice of other States, and agreed that the State must have its own logic for the condition. The Court told the State to come out with a proper stand, which it would then examine, and listed the matter on December 15.
Why the hearing matters
An eligibility condition attached to a welfare benefit needs a rational connection to the scheme’s object, or it risks falling foul of the equality guarantee in Article 14. The Bench’s repeated question, “what is the justification”, goes to that test. That other governments impose a similar condition does not, by itself, answer it, which is why the Court has asked Punjab to explain its own reasons on affidavit.
The case sits where welfare policy meets electoral law. The State says a voter ID is the most reliable proof of local residence; the petitioner says tying cash support to voter registration turns a welfare benefit into an inducement for votes. The State’s fresh affidavit, due before December 15, will decide how the Court frames that question.
Case Title: Harbakhsh Charitable Society v. State of Punjab & Ors.
Bench: Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor, Punjab and Haryana High Court
Date of Hearing: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Varun Dutta and Karan Bhardwaj for the petitioner; Senior Advocate Vikas Singh for the State of Punjab
Next Date: December 15, 2026
