Madras High Court Asks Tamil Nadu For White Paper On 20 Years Of Library Book Procurement

5 min read

How was the State buying books for its public libraries? The Madras High Court has asked the Tamil Nadu government to come out with a white paper on procurement over the last twenty years, saying the procurement scam has shaken the conscience of the people of the State.

Justices GR Swaminathan and MD Sumathi of the Madras High Court, who sought a white paper on library book procurement from Tamil Nadu

Madurai: By the next hearing, the Tamil Nadu government would do well to undertake a detailed probe and place before the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court a statement on how books have been procured for public libraries for the last twenty years and more, the Court said on Monday (November 16). A white paper would be in order, it added, and it also asked the authorities to explain whether the library cess collected in the State has been duly credited and how it has been spent [Ramasubbu v. K. Gopal, IAS & Anr.].

A Division Bench of Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi passed the order in a contempt petition alleging non-compliance with an earlier order on the procurement of books for public libraries. Justice Swaminathan authored it. The respondents are the Secretary to Government, Department of Higher Education, K. Gopal, and the Director of Public Libraries, R.V. Shajeevana.

“Earlier guidelines have been rendered toothless”

Publisher Badrinarayanan Seshadri of Kizhakku Padhippagam assisted the Court as a stakeholder, and he and two other stakeholders who did not wish to be named sent notes, which the Bench annexed to its order. It said:

“The earlier guidelines have been rendered toothless. It is time to evolve a foolproof procedure. Since the suggestions are fairly comprehensive, it should not take too long to issue a formal G.O so that we do not witness another scam in books procurement. Once such a binding procedure is put in place, we shall close this contempt petition.”

On the white paper, the Court recorded:

“The Government would do well to undertake a detailed probe and come out with a statement by the next hearing date as to how procurement of books has taken place for the last twenty years and more. It would be in order if a White paper is submitted. The scam has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu. Their faith in the system must be restored.”

The Bench explained the sentiment by recalling Periyar’s words that while schools build literacy and knowledge in particular fields, libraries foster awareness in all spheres, and C.N. Annadurai’s remark that the library should be accorded a place next to the basic necessities of life.

Nine questions on the Periyar Arivulagam purchase

Earlier on the day of the hearing, the Bench had handed the State a list of queries. Did the principles governing general procurement also apply to the special procurement made for the Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore? How many days were taken to select and buy books for the Kalaignar Library in Madurai and the Periyar Arivulagam, and how many books were bought for each?

The Court also asked how many books rejected by the expert committee were still procured for the Periyar Arivulagam, and what time the 137-member expert committee was given for its work. Referring to an earlier submission that publisher Agalvilakku had offered about 2,300 titles, of which about 1,700 were selected and bought, the Bench asked:

“Who rejected the 600 titles of Agalvilakku and at what stage? What was the reason for such rejection? Copies of the minutes to be made available. If 600 titles of a publisher could be rejected, what made the officials to select and purchase the remaining 1700?”

Further queries covered the budget for English and Tamil books, whether the work of librarians appointed as nodal officials was overseen by the Director of Public Libraries and the School Education Secretary, and how many recommended books were never bought.

State reports FIR and suspensions

When the matter was taken up in the afternoon, Advocate General Vijay Narayan sought more time to respond. He assured the Court that all persons involved in the scam would be dealt with and said five officials had already been suspended. State Public Prosecutor R. John Sathyan told the Bench that the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC), Chennai City, had registered FIR in Crime No. 4 of 2026 under the BNS and the Prevention of Corruption Act, and that Agalvilakku’s proprietor Mohan has been named as one of the accused.

The Advocate General added that any suggestion from the Court on streamlining future procurement would be considered by the Government.

Custodial interrogation and AI misuse

The Court said it was conscious that it should not direct the investigating officer to arrest any particular accused, but added:

“The bogus publishers have already been identified. Or at least some of them. Unless they are custodially interrogated, one will never know how much money was paid to which public servant. The modus operandi must be brought out. Unlike the earlier scams, the present one rises not only on scale but also the manner in which it has been committed. For the first time, AI and digital processes have been subverted for achieving sinister ends.”

Such matters, the Court noted, fall within the realm of the police. Impleading applications that have been filed will be considered on the next date. The case will be called on November 20, 2026 at 10.30 am as the first item.

The allegations in the DVAC FIR are yet to be tested at trial. The Court has not ruled on the guilt of any person, and every accused is entitled to the presumption of innocence.

Why the order matters

From one contested purchase, the library books case now reaches back over two decades of procurement practice and into the use of the library cess. By tying the closure of the contempt case to a binding Government Order, the Bench is pressing the State to replace guidelines it called toothless with an enforceable procedure for buying books with public money.

Case Title: Ramasubbu v. K. Gopal, IAS & Anr.
Case No.: CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026
Bench: Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi, Madras High Court (Madurai Bench)
Date of Order: November 16, 2026 (next hearing November 20, 2026)
Appearances: Senior counsel K.P.S. Palanivel Rajan for the petitioner; Advocate General Vijay Narayan, Additional Advocates General P.V. Balasubramanian and B. Saravanan, and State Public Prosecutor R. John Sathyan for the State

Similar Posts