Police statements cannot replace trial evidence, the Supreme Court has reiterated while acquitting a man in a 2011 double-murder case from Haryana, holding that a witness turning hostile does not make an earlier statement to police proof of guilt. The Court found that the conviction rested on inadmissible statements, unreliable recoveries and an incomplete chain of circumstances, and separately recommended consideration of victim compensation for the deceased women’s families.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has set aside the conviction and life sentence of Naresh in a case over the deaths of two women in Haryana, acquitting him of all charges because the prosecution had not proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt [Naresh v. State of Haryana].
A Bench of Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh pronounced the reportable judgment on November 16, 2026, with Justice Sharma authoring it. The ruling deals with police statements under Sections 161 and 162 CrPC, the proof needed for disclosure-led recoveries under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, and parity between co-accused.
Hostile witnesses and the limits of Section 162
No private witness who could speak to the occurrence or to the accused’s role supported the prosecution in court. The Supreme Court held that their earlier statements to police could not fill the gap left by the missing trial evidence.
On Section 162 CrPC, the Bench explained that a police statement can be used only to contradict a witness, and only in the manner the law prescribes. If the witness denies the relevant portion, it has to be proved through the officer who recorded it. A contradiction proved that way goes to the witness’s credibility; it does not establish that the earlier account is true.
Paragraph 33 puts it in one line: “a proved contradiction may show that the witness is unreliable, but it cannot show that what he told the police is true.” Here, the Court found that even the contradictions had not been properly proved through the investigating officers.
Decisions allowing reliance on dependable parts of a hostile witness’s testimony, the Bench said, concern what is said in court and cannot turn a disowned police statement into substantive proof. It also held that an admitted signature on the informant’s statement did not prove the truth of the hearsay recorded in it.
Recoveries that did not close the gap
Disclosure memoranda had been exhibited by the investigating officers without narrating the words actually attributed to Naresh. The Court therefore held that the disclosures were not proved as the law requires.
The recoveries had problems of their own. The stick first projected as the weapon could not have caused the fatal incised injuries, and a later disclosure pointing to a sharp-edged weapon came after the post-mortem findings. The High Court had rejected the co-accused’s corresponding later disclosure for that reason, but had not applied the same reasoning to Naresh.
The independent recovery witness also differed materially from the police on time and place. Medical opinion that a recovered weapon could have caused the injuries showed only that it was capable of doing so, not that it was used.
Forensic findings linked the recovered articles to neither deceased woman. The Bench expressly clarified that matching blood groups is not mandatory in every prosecution. In this case, though, the doubtful recoveries, shifts in the investigation’s account and inconclusive forensic results had to be weighed together, and several material circumstances had never been put to Naresh in his examination under Section 313 CrPC.
How the case reached the Supreme Court
Two women died in Ranila village, Bhiwani district, on the night of April 17, 2011. The prosecution alleged that Naresh and a co-accused assaulted them and moved their bodies into their houses. The informant had not seen the killings, and his account naming Naresh did not say where that information came from.
In February 2013 the trial court convicted both accused and sentenced them to death. By October 2013 the Punjab and Haryana High Court had acquitted the co-accused, while upholding Naresh’s conviction and commuting his death sentence to life imprisonment. The Supreme Court Legal Services Committee took his challenge forward.
His counsel argued that the vital links in a circumstantial case were absent and that the courts below had treated police statements as substantive evidence. Haryana defended the concurrent findings, pointing to the earlier statements, alleged motive, recoveries and medical evidence.
Same evidence, different outcomes
With the inadmissible statements set aside, what remained against Naresh was of the same kind and quality as the evidence held insufficient against his co-accused. The Court saw no legally sustainable basis for treating the two differently, and found no admissible evidence for the remaining charges under Sections 449, 297 and 201 IPC.
The judgment acquits Naresh of every charge and directs his release forthwith if he is in custody, unless he is wanted in another case. If he is on bail, his bonds and sureties stand discharged. The compensation imposed on him under Section 357 CrPC was set aside, and any fine deposited must be refunded.
In paragraph 81, the Court separately recommends that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, consider compensation for the deceased women’s legal representatives under the applicable Victim Compensation Scheme, after an appropriate inquiry. It referred to Section 357A(3) CrPC, now Section 396 BNSS. The recommendation is to consider compensation; no fixed amount was awarded.
Case Title: Naresh v. State of Haryana
Case Numbers: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1137–1138 of 2014
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1220
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh
Date of Judgment: November 16, 2026
Status: Final judgment; appeals allowed; acquittal on all charges; consideration of victim compensation recommended.
