Madras High Court Rules Hindu-Christian Marriage Cannot Be Registered Under Hindu Marriage Act, Voids Registration

3 min read

Can a marriage between a Hindu and a Christian be registered under the Hindu Marriage Act? The Madras High Court has answered in the negative, declaring a 2009 registration null and void.

Madras High Court building, where a 2009 marriage registration under the Hindu Marriage Act was declared void.

Chennai: Declaring null and void a marriage registered in February 2009 under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the Madras High Court has set aside a family court judgment, finding that the husband was a Christian at the time and that no marriage ceremony had taken place [Naveen Kumar v. Vigneshwari].

The man’s appeal against the family court’s 2019 decision dismissing his suit was allowed by a Division Bench of Justice CV Karthikeyan and Justice S Raveekumar.

Sections 5 and 8 read together

Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, the Bench explained, permits marriage only between two Hindus, while Section 8 merely provides for registration of such marriages. Registration, it held, cannot validate a marriage that does not satisfy the conditions in Section 5:

“A conjoint reading of Sections 5 and 8 of the Hindu Marriage Act makes it clear that a marriage between a Hindu and a person professing a different religion cannot be solemnized and validated by a mere registration under the said Act.”

Section 7A, which recognises self-respect marriages in Tamil Nadu, was held by the Court not to apply where either party is not a Hindu.

A suit, a denial and two baptism certificates

The appellant had sued to invalidate the marriage registered with the respondent in February 2009. According to him, she had misled him into going to the registrar’s office on the pretext of signing as a witness to another marriage. The respondent denied this and maintained that the marriage had taken place with his consent.

Disbelieving his claim that he was a Christian, the family court dismissed the suit in 2019. In appeal, the High Court looked at baptism certificates issued in 1998 and 2006 and concluded that he was a Christian when the marriage was registered. It also found that no marriage ceremony had been performed before registration, although the marriage certificate recorded otherwise.

Other statutes for interfaith couples

A marriage between a Christian and a person of another religion may be solemnised under the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, if its procedure is followed, the Bench pointed out, and the Special Marriage Act, 1954 provides a statutory mechanism for interfaith marriages. Neither route had been followed here, so the registration under the Hindu Marriage Act could not give the marriage legal validity.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Gullipilli Sowria Raj v. Bandaru Pavani, the High Court set aside the family court’s judgment and declared the marriage registration null and void. It also directed that the judgment be circulated among marriage registrars across Tamil Nadu to ensure compliance with statutory requirements.

A certificate is only as good as the marriage behind it

Marriage certificates under the Hindu Marriage Act are often issued on the strength of declarations at the registrar’s office. The ruling makes clear that if one party is not a Hindu, or no ceremony took place, registration under that Act confers no validity. The direction to circulate the judgment to registrars across Tamil Nadu is aimed at stopping such registrations at the source and steering interfaith couples to the Special Marriage Act or the Indian Christian Marriage Act.

Case Title: Naveen Kumar v. Vigneshwari
Bench: Justice CV Karthikeyan and Justice S Raveekumar
Date of Judgment: Not available
Appearances: Advocates N Easwaran and R Veeramani for the appellant

Similar Posts