Kerala High Court Upholds Injunction Against Ameya Sweets Over ELADI Trademark Of Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala

4 min read

In an ELADI trademark dispute, the Kerala High Court has held that Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala prima facie established goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, the “classical trinity”, and has upheld an interim injunction barring Thrissur-based Ameya Sweets from selling candies under the ELADI and ELADI THRILL marks.

Kerala High Court building, where a Division Bench upheld an injunction in the ELADI trademark dispute.

Kochi: The Kerala High Court has dismissed a commercial appeal by a candy maker against a Thrissur court’s order barring it from using the word ELADI on its products, holding that Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala had prima facie established goodwill, misrepresentation and damage [Mrs. Vineetha Suresh Babu & Anr. v. Dr. Rose Mary Wilson & Ors.].

Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M. sat as a Division Bench and delivered the judgment on November 12, 2026 in Commercial Appeal No. 4 of 2026. The appeal was against the order dated August 20, 2026 in IA 1/2026 in CS No. 1 of 2026 of the Additional District Court, Thrissur.

Sweets versus Ayurvedic tablets

Dr. Rose Mary Wilson and K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan’s Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala Private Limited sued for trademark infringement and passing off. They claimed that their Ayurvedic chewable tablets have been sold as ELADI since 1989 and have built up considerable goodwill, and alleged that Ameya Sweets, run by Vineetha Suresh Babu, had adopted a deceptively similar name and packaging for its candies. In August 2026 the Additional District Court restrained Ameya Sweets from using ELADI and ELADI THRILL.

Classes, registrations and a common word

Before the Bench, Ameya Sweets argued that ELADI THRILL was separately registered, that its confectionery falls in Class 30 while the Vaidyasala’s medicinal products are registered in Class 5, and that ELADI is a descriptive term commonly used for Ayurvedic preparations which no single maker can monopolise.

The Bench was not persuaded. It held that even a commonly used word can acquire a distinctive identity through long and extensive commercial use, and that prior use of a mark can prevail over a later registration even where the competing goods sit in different classes. It also noted that ELADI was displayed prominently on the appellants’ products.

The classical trinity

Closing its analysis of the passing off claim, the Bench held that once the plaintiffs had:

“established goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, the classical trinity, the interim order passed by the learned Additional District Judge does not call for any interference.”

Three findings supported that conclusion: ELADI had become closely identified with the Vaidyasala’s products through long use; an unwary purchaser with imperfect recollection was likely to take the candies as coming from the same source; and Ameya Sweets had offered no plausible reason for adopting the word at a much later point of time.

Why the Bench left the injunction alone

Relying on Super Smelters Limited v. SRMB Srijan Private Limited on the restraint expected of an appellate court reviewing an interim injunction, the Bench concluded:

“On the facts narrated above, the view taken by the learned Additional District Judge is a possible and reasonable view, and we are not inclined to interfere with the exercise of such discretion.”

The appeal was dismissed. The findings are at the interim stage, and the suit will be decided on evidence before the trial court.

What the ruling signals

Traditional Ayurvedic names are often defended as generic and free for all to use. The ruling shows that a word drawn from common usage can still earn protection once decades of trade tie it to one maker in the public mind, and that moving from medicine to confectionery will not by itself save a later user who cannot explain why it picked the same name.

Case Title: Mrs. Vineetha Suresh Babu & Anr. v. Dr. Rose Mary Wilson & Ors.
Case No.: Commercial Appeal No. 4 of 2026; Neutral Citation 2026:KER:86708
Bench: Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M., High Court of Kerala
Date of Judgment: November 12, 2026
Appearances: Advocates K. Radhakrishnan Nair, Sajen Thampan, Jinu Samyuktha Padmakumar, Ayoona P.M., Athil Jamal, Ashmy Lal G. and Sarika Krishna A. for the appellants; Advocates P. Abraham Cherian, Nimmy K. Joseph, Joe Joseph, Jaison S. Rozario, Aravind Varghese, Pooja Jose, V. Varun, Haritha Mohan and Amal John Sabu for the respondents

Similar Posts